Section 6
The ADL report
Many of the influence attacks on Wikipedia rely on and reference the ADL report entitled “Editing for Hate: How Anti-Israel and Anti-Jewish Bias Undermines Wikipedia’s Neutrality” (March 2025). This is the central document used in the influence attacks on Wikipedia, which we discussed in Sections 4.1, 4.2, 4.3, and 4.4.
In Section 6.1, we discuss the core issues of the report, namely that the evidence it presents is poor, and that it fails to prove any of their claims. These flaws, combined with a lack of engagement with Wikipedia on these issues before the report’s publication demonstrates that the ADL is not making a good-faith attempt, as they claim, to reduce hate. Rather, it makes clear that their goal is to weaponize the report to gain influence over Wikipedia.
In Section 6.2 we discuss an article published in The Forward by Dr. Shira Klein, an expert on antisemitism and Wikipedia. Dr. Klein’s research was referenced in the ADL’s report, and her article publicly refutes the ADL’s claims.389 In the article, she states that Wikipedia is extremely reliable on the topic of Israel and Palestine, contradicting the ADL’s assertions.
In Section 6.3, we systematically go through the ADL report’s claims of collusion in Case Study 1, where we show the report is filled with fallacies, contradictory evidence, and unverifiable accusations that rely on biased definitions and fake-scientific terminology. We demonstrate that the report is not the scholarly work it claims to be, but is a deeply flawed and embarrassing piece of propaganda, which doesn’t merit U.S. government attention or to be addressed by Wikipedia.
In Section 6.4, we apply the same process to Case Study 2, the ADL’s claims about antisemitism in the Arabic Language section of Wikipedia. The ADL appears to have made the severe error of relying on English-language translations, which add incorrect nuance which isn’t there in the original. They claim that neutral passages imply praise for Hamas, without explanation. They also claim bias and antisemitism in simple and factual descriptions of Palestinian history which does not suit their narrative.
In Section 6.5, we continue this systematic analysis of a follow-up report by the ADL, called “Damage Done: Wikipedia Leaves Biased Edits Unchecked Despite Editor Bans”. In it, the ADL celebrates its success from manipulating Wikipedia along with their allies. They make further false claims which identify a supposed new cohort of antisemitic editing, and restate old recommendations and make new ones, in order to gain more influence over the platform. We dissect this report, methodically examining its spin and narrative claims that are once again unsupported by evidence, as well as its goals and propaganda purpose.
In Section 6.6, we address the “systematic edits” claims made by the ADL, which were repeated in the attacks from numerous politicians. The ADL claims that Tech for Palestine (authors of this report), created a mass-editing campaign. We demonstrate how the ADL spun this false narrative, citing data which itself demonstrates that no such mass-editing campaign exists. This shows how the ADL spins false stories into being, in order to tell a story that can be better weaponized by allies in Congress.
Finally, in Section 6.7, we go through the “Recommendations” made by the ADL to the US government, to Wikipedia, and to AI Labs creating LLMs. We go through each recommendation, explaining how the specific recommendations have not been backed up by the ADL’s fabricated findings.
6.1 The Reports’ Core Flaws
In this section we present the core flaws with the ADL’s report.390 These are based off of our detailed analysis of the ADL’s reports, which we present in Sections 6.3, 6.4, and 6.5.
6.1.1 The invented group
The core of the ADL’s argument is that it found 30 Wikipedia users who are conspiring to create anti-Israel and antisemitic bias.
The major problem with the ADL’s narrative is that it is just a story. They are telling a story of a group of 30 editors who they claim are colluding. But these 30 people are not people the ADL, or anybody else, have seen colluding. They have not seen them in a room together (nor even a Discord channel). The grouping is simply one that the ADL has invented.
The alleged members of this conspiracy almost certainly do not actually know each other, are not friends, and have never spoken in real-life. The only record of communication, or even the existence, of these people, is via public Wikipedia pages.
The ADL wants you to think it found 30 antisemites in a room, conspiring to stick it to the Jews. But the ADL have not found anything to connect these people apart from edits on Wikipedia. They don’t have the basics of a conspiracy. Who is the organizer? Where are their instructions? When or where do they meet? The ADL does not have any of this information, almost certainly because it does not exist.
(We note that the ADL and several pro-Israel organizations have attempted to say that these editors colluded on a specific Discord channel. This is provably false due to the dates and quantity of edits involved, as we discuss in Section 6.6.)
This group of 30 editors is an invention of the ADL. They took Wikipedia data—usernames and edits—and they decided to connect these 30 people in order to be able to tell a story about them. But the story is just that—a story. It is not rooted in the real world.
In each part of Section 6, we show how flimsy the evidence is which the ADL presents. But it’s important to remember that the entire narrative is simply a mirage which the ADL created, based on (bad) statistical inferences of data they found in Wikipedia datasets.
The simple fact is the ADL knows nothing about these people, or their relationship, in the real world. There is no evidence that they know each other, or that they have ever spoken, and that is because they almost certainly have not. These are simply 30 separate Wikipedia editors who have one shared topic of interest, and that is all the ADL actually knows.
We contrast this to the seventeen actually demonstrated conspiracies to add pro-Israel slants to Wikipedia, which we outlined in Section 3.
6.1.2 Unfalsifiable evidence
A key problem with the ADL’s story is that it is not “falsifiable”. That is, it cannot be demonstrated to be incorrect.
When the editors work on Palestine-Israel articles, the ADL says that they’re conspiring to add antisemitism to Wikipedia. But when they don’t work on Palestine-Israel Articles, the ADL says they’re covering their tracks. When they communicate on Wikipedia, the ADL says they’re colluding. When they don’t communicate on Wikipedia, the ADL says they’re colluding off-platform.
The ADL’s goal was to produce a narrative, and every fact, no matter what it actually says, is woven into the conspiracy.
In fact, the ADL had none of the basic elements of a properly-conducted data analysis, such as stating their hypotheses, defining the terms they use, presenting confidence intervals alongside the data, controlling for metrics such as account age or sample size. In particular, they made no effort to provide reproducibility (in fact, frequently hiding sources during their most egregious manipulation of the results).
6.1.3 Unsupported accusations of antisemitism
The ADL repeatedly invoked anti-Jewish bias and antisemitism, but did not even attempt to demonstrate it. In fact, nearly every claim about content referred specifically to content about Israel and Palestine.
The ADL’s main claim is of antisemitism, but despite that claim, they presented no evidence that their editors had any bias against Jews, or had inserted any anti-Jewish information on Wikipedia. Instead, the ADL attempted to demonstrate anti-Israel bias, and then made the leap to antisemitism without any additional evidence.
Despite spending significant amount of time claiming that editors were antisemitic, including claiming “deceptive, manipulative practices” “targeted at entries related to Jews and Israel”, bias in ‘pages on “Israel, Jews, and the Palestinians”’, editors who are “anti-Jewish and anti-Israel”, and alleging “Wikipedia needs to do far more to address anti-Jewish and anti-Israel bias and coordination”, the ADL’s supposed evidence barely even looked at Judaism, Jewish communities (that is, not including Israel), or Jewish people.
In fact, the ADL didn’t actually make a lot of accusations about antisemitism at all. One accusation they made, discussed in Section 6.3.4.5.5 was about removing a passage about a single Palestinian flying a swastika kite which was removed due to “Undue weight”.
The other accusations, which we discuss in Sections 6.3.4.5.6 and 6.3.4.5.7, were facts that were incredibly well supported by academic research, the bedrock of Wikipedia content. In one of the cases, the ADL actually distorted the quote by removing key content.
6.1.4 No false anti-Israel information was shown to be added
It is certainly true that Wikipedia contains a lot of information about Israel’s long history of crimes against humanity, but the ADL did not even attempt to show that any of it was false. In fact, they only at one point claimed that information on Wikipedia was factually incorrect, where the ADL disagreed with Wikipedia’s definition of Zionism. The claim with which they disagreed was supported by 17 references to scholarly works, many by Israeli Jewish historians.
Indeed, the ADL does a poor job of demonstrating that supposed anti-Israel facts are false. Wikipedia has a very high standard of evidence, relying principally on peer-reviewed scholarship. Facts unsupported by evidence rarely stay on the site, especially on controversial pages.
The ADL does attempt to claim biased edits, but it does not claim that those edits are incorrect. We address each of these supposedly biased edits in Section 6.3.4.5, in which we demonstrated serious flaws with each of the ADL claims, none of which we believe are substantiated. The ADL’s “Manipulation and Disinformation”, which we discuss in Section 6.3.4, also does not allege falsehoods.
This is a key flaw with the ADL’s case: they attempted to show simply that facts critical of Israel were added. At no point did they show these editors manipulated Wikipedia to add false information.
6.1.5 No divergence from scholarly opinion
To show actual anti-Israel bias, the ADL would need to demonstrate that information was introduced which contradicts peer-reviewed literature—the gold standard on Wikipedia.
As Dr. Shira Klein says:
“But where is the evidence of editors repeatedly misrepresenting or contradicting peer-reviewed literature? There is none. The report simply wants us to take the ADL’s word for it”.
“The ADL’s main claim is that a group of 30 “bad faith editors” are working in tandem to “minimize Palestinian violence and terrorism while delegitimizing Israel”. But to a scholar’s eye, the evidence the group offers to support this claim is lacking. To establish foul play, the ADL would need to demonstrate that Wikipedia content about Israel and Zionism regularly expresses as fact ideas that diverge from broadly held scholarly opinions on the matters in question. (When edited well, Wikipedia summarizes scholarly consensus, substantiating every claim with peer-reviewed literature.)”
6.1.6 Severe methodological flaws
6.1.6.1 Working backwards from a predetermined conclusion
Their method in Case Study 1, which we discuss in Section 6.3.1, was to work backwards from a pre-determined conclusion: they chose the editors they didn’t like, then attempted to find evidence to implicate them. This Stalinesque approach—“Show me the man and I’ll show you the crime”391—involved cherry-picking a tiny amount of evidence from the over 1,000,000 edits made by the editors, which they attempted to spin to implicate the editors. As shown in Section 6.3, the evidence they used for this was also incredibly flawed and failed to demonstrate even the spin they sought.
Frequently, the ADL’s evidence is circular. They will define a group of editors based on some criteria, and then use either that criteria, or a derivative of it, as proof of malicious editing.
As discussed in Section 6.3.2.2, the ADL’s chosen “bad-faith” editors, who had been selected for being frequent editors of key pages, were claimed to be colluding for participation in discussions in those pages.
Similarly, as discussed in Section 6.3.2.3, the ADL claimed that editors were suspicious for being frequent editors of some articles, when in fact the ADL had chosen them because they were frequent editors of those articles.
As we discuss in Section 6.3.2.4, the ADL selected the editors for being frequent editors. They attempted to use “time between edits” as proof of bad-faith, when clearly more frequent editors will have a lower average time between edits, as frequency and time-between-edits are mathematical inverses.
6.1.6.2 Manufacturing the appearance of collusion
The ADL makes consistent claims of collusion, but the evidence to support it does not exist. As we showed in 6.1.6.1, most of the attributes they claim are actually just reflections of the criteria they used to group the editors.
Beyond that, as we show in detail in Section 6.3.2, they produce a number of attributes: “editing frequency”, “group communication”, “tandem editing”, “time between edits”. However, they do not actually establish why we should consider these traits to demonstrate collusion. They do not have evidence that colluding editors have these traits, and present no reason to think that they would.
6.1.6.3 Framing ordinary Wikipedia activity as sinister
As we discuss in Section 6.3.4, the ADL frames ordinary editing behaviour as being sinister, claiming that editing outside of the Palestine-Israel articles is "camouflage" and that making minor edits is “gaming the system”. These activities are normal activities that every Wikipedia editor does, and indeed is encouraged to do. They claim that a cumulative million edits between 30 editors is a lot, despite the fact that 20 Wikipedia editors are known to have a million edits each.
They even suggest editors are paid to work on it, using data which decidedly does not show anyone working steadily 9-5.
6.1.6.4 Cherry-picked evidence
The ADLs evidence was cherry-picked to attempt to show things which supported the ADL’s narrative. The ADL’s targeted editors had contributed a million edits to Wikipedia, and from that massive corpus they selected a number of articles, stripped them of context, thus constructing the evidence to support that narrative.
Given a million context-stripped edits from any group of people, we have no doubt the ADL could make them say anything. However, the removed context in each case demonstrated that the ADL was lying about what these cherry-picked articles say.
The fact that none of the context-stripped edits held up makes clear that the ADL’s case is built on nothing at all. We discuss most of these edits in Section 6.3.4.
6.1.6.5 Lack of Wikimedia consultation
It also appears they did not take their evidence to Wikipedia before publication, who could have helped correct the issues.392 This shows the report was not a genuine attempt to help guide Wikipedia, but rather a propaganda tool for the influence operation discussed in Section 4.
Wikimedia made a small statement in response to a query from CNN, saying “It is unfortunate that we were not asked by the report’s authors to provide information and context that might have helped allay some of the concerns raised”.
That is to say, the ADL made serious and significant allegations about Wikipedia without once contacting the organization behind it. Given that the ADL makes a significant set of recommendations to Wikimedia about changes to make, it is quite shocking that it did not engage them for a simple comment before publishing, especially since engaging with organizations is a common activity in which the ADL engages.
6.1.7 Manipulation and misrepresentation of evidence
Repeatedly throughout their reports, the ADL manipulated and misrepresented data, through misleading descriptions, selective quotation, hiding context, and withholding the links which would demonstrate otherwise.
6.1.7.1 Distorting evidence through misleading descriptions and selective quotation
The ADL committed several gross violations of integrity in their report, when they deliberately distorted evidence. The most egregious, which we discuss in Section 6.3.4.5.7, is when they distorted a quote by removing the second half, which contradicted what the ADL attempted to make it show.
Similarly, it intentionally misconstrued the contents of the Palestine Remembered website, discussed in Section 6.3.6, by claiming that a Frequently Asked Question—which they subsequently answered in contradiction to the ADL’s claim—was in fact a statement made by the site owners.
In Section 6.3.4.5.1, we also discuss how the ADL claimed evidence was removed, when in fact it had simply been moved and then actually expanded.
6.1.7.2 Ignoring or hiding edit descriptions which undermined their narrative
Every change on Wikipedia is supported by an edit description, in which the editor provides context for the change. Frequently, the ADL claimed a biased reason for something which was simply and adequately explained by the edit. The ADL should have, but never did, explain why their reasoning was stronger than the stated reason for the edit, and only in a handful of cases did the ADL even acknowledge the editor’s stated reason for doing an edit.
Instead, the ADL simply claimed that edits were for the purpose of “anti-Israel bias”, and concocted fabricated stories that were frequently directly contradicted by the context the ADL deliberately omitted.
6.1.7.3 Withholding the links needed to scrutinize its claims
Wikipedia provides “permalinks” to each edit made by an editor on the platform. Each of the ADL’s claims should have been backed by a link to the exact change, which could be used to validate the claim. Instead, they were omitted in nearly every single case. See Sections 6.3.4.5 and 6.3.4.6 for major examples and discussion.
We believe the ADL deliberately omitted this valuable context. When we retrieved the approximately 100 actual source edits which the ADL hid, they almost always undermined the ADLs point and demonstrated a different situation from the ADL’s narrative. We have included those change links in Section 6.3 as we expose the significant flaws in their work.
6.1.8 Claims contradicted by the ADL’s own evidence
Frequently, the ADL’s claims were contradicted by their own data.
6.1.8.1 Supposedly suspicious editing patterns also appear among other editors
In sections 6.3.2.1 and 6.3.2.3, we show how the activities of which the ADL accuses editors were also present in editors outside the group, particularly in relation to editing frequency, and what they call “tandem editing”. For example, they claim that the bad-faith editors massively increased their edits to Palestine-Israel articles after October 7—which would be expected given the prevalence of this in the news—when other groupings of editors they present did the same thing.
6.1.8.2 The ADL’s accusations are undermined by source data
The ADL tried to undermine, as we discuss in Section 6.3.6, editors for having used a website called “PalestineRemembered”. However, the ADL’s data shows this is the 13th most commonly referenced site, and references to it are significantly outnumbered by more mainstream media outlets.
Similarly, they tried to claim that editors’ contribution time implied that these editors were working full time jobs. However, the actual source data they provide much more strongly supports editors who edit frequently but as a hobby.
Many of their claims of collusion were also undermined by the source data, as discussed in Section 6.3.2.
6.1.8.3 Wikipedia has demonstrated its tools capable of the challenge
Repeatedly, the ADL claims that Wikipedia has insufficient resources, does not have capacity, or was not able to take arbitration sanctions. Yet the actual data shows us that Wikipedia repeatedly did all that. The ADL’s documentation repeatedly shows the collaborative process working to remove false information, which we discuss in Sections 6.3.4.5.3, 6.3.5.2, and the arbitration process to remove rule-breakers is also working, as we discuss in Section 6.3.3.
6.2 Dr. Shira Klein’s Assessment
The low quality of the report is echoed by other researchers. Dr. Shira Klein, for example, whose work the ADL cited in their original version of the report, eviscerated the report, stating:
“The ADL report and Congressmembers’ letter both rely on a faulty premise: that criticism of Israel or Zionism is inherently antisemitic.”
“To read that report, one would think that English Wikipedia is a cesspit of antisemitism. But I wrote one of the academic papers that the report cites, and I can tell you: Its interpretation of the facts is very skewed.”“The ADL’s report is, dismally, riddled with errors, including in its manipulation of a peer-reviewed publication that I co-authored on Holocaust distortion on Wikipedia. The report inaccurately uses my research to uphold its allegations that antisemitism is running rampant across Wikipedia, amid the ADL’s ramped-up efforts to police public discourse about Israel. The organization sees Wikipedia, the eighth most-visited website in the world, as key to that endeavor.”
“Our research cannot reasonably be used to extrapolate broad conclusions about the extent of antisemitism on Wikipedia at large.”
“Another scholar, who focuses on environmental studies, was equally dismayed to discover his research appearing in the ADL’s report. “As someone whose peer-reviewed work was cited in this ADL ‘research,’ it doesn’t show anything,” he wrote on the social media platform Bluesky, in a now-deleted message directed to Rep. Debbie Wasserman Schultz, one of the representatives submitting the complaint to Wikipedia.”
“To non-experts, the ADL report might seem meticulously researched. Replete with charts and quotes, it looks a lot like an academic study. But it doesn’t apply an academic study’s rigor, and its methodology is faulty. (Not for the first time—just ask former ADL staffers.)”
“But where is the evidence of editors repeatedly misrepresenting or contradicting peer-reviewed literature? There is none. The report simply wants us to take the ADL’s word for it.”
“The data the ADL does give is cherry-picked to show Wikipedia’s alleged overemphasis on Israeli crimes and underemphasis on Palestinian violence.”
- Dr. Shira Klein, “Is Wikipedia a cesspool of antisemitism? Don’t trust the ADL’s answer”393 (selected quotes)
In a talk with the University of Southern California’s (USC) Shoah Foundation in February 2024, and before her article was published in The Forward, Dr. Klein reiterated the reliability of Wikipedia on content related to Palestine-Israel and antisemitism. She makes several important comments, including,
“[Wikipedia] is actually a pretty trustworthy place to get information on Israel-Palestine.”
“In the minds of most scholars of antisemitism, critique of Israel is not antisemitism, and anti-Zionism is not antisemitism.”
“When I look at Hebrew Wikipedia and its coverage of the war versus English Wikipedia and its coverage of the war, where the distortions lie are in Hebrew Wikipedia, and that is something that is noticed by a lot of Wikipedia and Hebrew Wikipedia editors as well.”394
Dr. Klein makes it clear that the ADL’s critique of Wikipedia is unfounded, and not based on sound research, but, rather, influenced by their own political allegiances to Israel and related motivations.
6.3 Detailed Critique of Case Study 1
The bulk of the ADL’s report and evidence are in Case Study 1, in which they claim there is a group of editors who are making “coordinated anti-Jewish, anti-Israel bias and manipulation”, specifically that there is “bad-faith coordination [...] to amplify criticism of Israel and minimize evidence of violence and antisemitism by Palestinian terrorist groups”.
They make three claims:
These editors are “bad-faith” or “suspicious”
These editors are “coordinating” their edits
These editors are putting misinformation on Wikipedia
In fact, they showed no such thing. Their criteria of “bad-faith” editors was simply editors who contributed facts and made arguments that the ADL did not like. They then tried to identify some attributes about their new grouping of editors, and claimed that some of these attributes —such as making a lot of edits, or working on similar pages—was evidence of coordination.
To reiterate: the ADL’s investigation starts by selecting their bad-faith editors, then attempts to find reasons to support the grouping they have already picked. They decided who the murderer was, then they planted the gun on them. They claim they set up an investigation, but they had already decided that the editors were guilty.
Below, we systematically go through their claims and show that there is nothing to them.
6.3.1 “Bad-Faith” Editors (pg 6)
The core of the ADL report is based on a collection of 30 supposed “bad-faith” editors. However, the process of selection of this group is a core flaw which undermines the entire report.
To identify “bad-faith editors”, the ADL began by selecting editors, and then searched for reasons to support their selection.
“We identified the group of 30 editors that appear to be in close coordination by calculating the minimum time between edits made on pages related to Israel, Jews, or the Palestinians, such as the 1948 Palestine War and Israeli War Crimes articles. We then analyzed all pages on which they commented or were mentioned, including backend discussion (“talk”) pages and user talk pages (discussion pages for individual editors).”
To rephrase this, they collected editors that contributed the most to some pages on the topic of Israel/Palestine, and analyzed their contributions and discussions to see whether they liked it. They then declared editors they did not like to be “bad-faith”.
In fact, it shows no such thing. They have no way of determining the editors are acting in “bad faith”—that is simply name-calling for editors who are contributing facts to Wikipedia that the ADL does not like.
To be clear, there is nothing “bad faith” about documenting facts that do not portray Israel in a good light. Though the pro-Israel movement has been keen to call anyone saying anything bad about Israel as antisemitic or anti-Israel, the truth is that Israel has a long history of Crimes Against Humanity, such ethnic cleansing, apartheid, and genocide. Documenting these in an encyclopedia is not in “bad faith”, it is in fact one of the major purposes for which encyclopedias exist.
Calling these editors “bad faith” is a serious misrepresentation, one that invalidates their entire report. The ADL has demonstrated that their “bad-faith” editors did nothing to be marked as “bad-faith” except contribute to Wikipedia in a way that the ADL does not like.
The ADL did not at any point in the report present any evidence of “bad-faith” behaviour by these editors to label them “bad-faith”, did not demonstrate these editors making false edits, introducing false claims, or of violating Wikipedia policies or rules. In fact, the most evidence they provided, in the section “Manipulation and Disinformation” was prioritizing different content from the ADL on the Wikipedia page for “Hamas”, which as we show in Section 6.3.4.5 was spurious.
6.3.2 “Coordinated Editors” (pg 6-14)
The ADL’s section on “coordinated editors” attempts to show evidence that their editors are in coordination. They offer no actual evidence of coordination, but instead attempt to infer it by analyzing some shared attributes of the editors.
This is a cardinal sin of data analysis: attempting to find non-standard attributes of a group, and then declaring these attributes as proof of your pre-chosen thesis. This is a massive flaw in their research, one which invalidates the entire thesis of the report.
The report goes through a number of arbitrary attributes where they show that their chosen group is different from other groups they have compiled. They claim that because those editors—on average as a group—score differently in some metrics, that this is proof that the editors are coordinating.
The report claims that these various attributes are evidence of “coordinated” editing, such as: editing more frequently than others, an increase of edits since October 7th, 2023, increased messaging on public “talk” pages, and something they refer to as “tandem editing”.
However, it does not explain why these are evidence of coordination, nor why any of these things are inappropriate.
6.3.2.1 Editing Frequency (pg 6-9)
One of the main attributes that the ADL attempts to claim is frequency of editing.


In the ADL’s Charts 1 and 2, they show total edits from different groups, demonstrating that their “bad-faith editors” edit more than other groups of editors they have compiled. They do not attempt to explain how this shows collusion, or is otherwise suspicious.
In addition, the two charts use different groupings, with Chart 1 being all 30 top editors, while Chart 2 uses only the top 5 of each group. These cherry-picked datasets suggest that the ADL is choosing to show the data that supports their narrative.

Chart 3 shows that their chosen editors increased their edits since October 7, 2023.
Again, the ADL does not explain how this contributes to collusion of “bad-faith” editing. In fact, the sole text which accompanies this graphic is “Additionally, this high degree of activity among the bad-faith editors increased substantially following the October 7, 2023, attack on Israel”.
In fact, the evidence shows the behavior of their target group changed in the exact same way as non-“bad-faith” editors of the “Israel-Hamas war” page. It seems that after Israel’s invasion of Gaza in October 2023, Wikipedia editors of all stripes increased their edits on the topic of Palestine/Israel. This seems a natural and obvious phenomenon, that topics in the news and in which a lot is happening, would get more attention.
6.3.2.2 Group Communication (pg 9-10)
In Chart 4, the ADL claims that their “bad-faith” editors mention each other frequently on Wikipedia’s “Talk pages”.

Again, it is unclear what exactly is being claimed here, since the ADL does not spell it out. Their sole statement to explain their point is “This frequency suggests these editors were in much closer communication than is typical on other Wikipedia pages, even those who work on similar content”.
This discrepancy can be explained extremely simply: the ADL chose to group these editors because they appeared together in the same pages as each other. That is, the ADL chose to group these editors for this attribute. They cannot appear shocked when the group chosen for this attribute then demonstrates this attribute.
This is purely circular logic: they frequently participate in the Talk pages of the same Wikipedia pages because they were grouped together by the ADL on that basis.
In addition, there is a relatively simple explanation for why these editors speak more in Talk pages. The Palestine/Israel Articles section of Wikipedia is highly scrutinized, and has strict editing rules. Tagging other editors in Talk pages is a core part of reaching the scholarly consensus which is core to Wikipedia. A significant amount of conversation in Talk pages demonstrates editors serious about their craft, following guidelines and working towards scholarly consensus.
Unfortunately, yet again, the ADL provides no discussion of why we should find this behaviour suspicious.
It also provides evidence against the ADLs unproven claim of illicit off-platform coordination, since the editors are shown to be more than willing to communicate on Wikipedia.
6.3.2.3 Tandem Editing (pg 10-13)
The ADL attempts to demonstrate “tandem editing”, as further proof of collusion. The report states,
“Next, we analyzed the time interval between when one editor from the group made an edit (such as a cut or addition) and another. Again, the 30 suspicious editors stood out, although in this case, we saw similar activity amongst the Israel-Hamas war editors, across all their edits, likely due to the Israel-Gaza conflict.”
“Tandem editing”, page 10
“...Editors from this group were much more likely to make edits to the same pages and to make edits within the same period of time as one another, suggesting a high degree of coordination.”
“Tandem editing”, page 12
This is yet another piece of circular logic from the ADL. The ADL grouped these editors for frequently editing similar sets of pages—by definition they will be editing these pages frequently.
Similarly, if two editors are editing the same pages frequently, their edits will occur closer in time than editors who do not edit the same pages frequently.
Indeed, the ADL itself admits as much, stating,
“...In this case, we saw similar activity amongst the Israel-Hamas war editors, across all their edits, likely due to the Israel-Gaza conflict.”
“Tandem editing”, page 10
“...(the 30 Pro Editors group is taken from a random sample of the top 5,000 most active Wikipedia editors, so the lack of overlap is not surprising).”
“Tandem editing”, page 11
They admit that groups with overlap in the pages they edit, such as the Israel-Hamas war page, also show signs of what they call “tandem editing”. Meanwhile, groups whose pages do not overlap, such as the general editors, do not. This demonstrates that “tandem editing” simply correlates to editing overlapping pages, which is obvious on reflection.
It seems natural, in fact, that editors who work on pages with frequent changes are more likely to continue editing the page further as information develops. Wikipedia also sends notifications to editors when edits are made to pages they follow, which encourages them to return to those pages and make further contributions.
We note at this point that the phrase “tandem editor” is not any sort of term of art. In fact, the term has almost never been used before, with only two casual uses we could find on Wikipedia, dating to 2009 and 2016, in which they were not defined.
Between the undefined, almost-never used term of “tandem editing”, and the fact that this behaviour appears frequently across other groups, it appears that the ADL found nothing at all, and tried to dress up their lack of findings with fancy-sounding words.
The report further claims that “tandem editing” “raises the likelihood that these edits are coordinated off Wikipedia, potentially on sites like Discord”. However, they do not present any actual evidence of editor coordination outside of Wikipedia, and offer no connection between their metric and actual off-site coordination. Moreover, coordinating off of Wikipedia is hardly necessary, given the ADL has shown these users are already coordinating on Wikipedia’s “Talk pages”.
6.3.2.4 Time Between Edits (pg 13-14)
The report suggests that time between edits is a further reason to consider these editors as suspicious. However, it has already been established that the ADL grouped these editors together based on time between edits, thus it is no surprise that the group displays this property. It is also known that these editors are frequent editors, and naturally, editors who edit more frequently have less time between edits. Thus, this property is not suspicious, but came out of which editors the ADL chose for their “bad-faith” group.
6.3.2.5 “Coordinated editors” summary and verdict
On pages 6-14, the ADL attempted to show coordination between the editors of their chosen group, concluding “Taken together, this high degree of communication and tandem editing suggest that this group of editors is working together, likely off-site and potentially in violation of Wikipedia’s policies”.
In fact, their data shows no evidence at all. The report merely pulled together a collection of data in which:
it was not explained why this is suspicious (“editing frequency”, “tandem editing”)
the data was clearly being manipulated or spun (“editing frequency”, “tandem editing”)
the data can obviously and easily be explained (increase in edits after October 7, 2023; “time between edits”)
circular logic (“group communication”, “tandem editing”, “time between edits”)
the ADL’s explanation is refuted by the data they provide (“tandem editing”, increase in edits after October 7, 2023)
The evidence is largely spun, unexplained, circular, and embarrassingly shallow, and does not come close to proving anything.
We contend that instead of showing proof, the ADL compiled unconvincing data into a fake scientific veneer, using terms such as “tandem editing” and “time between edits” to try and establish credibility despite a complete lack of evidence.
6.3.3 Harassment and Intimidation (pg 14-15)
The report highlights a situation where six Wikipedia editors were banned for harassment by ArbCom, Wikipedia’s court. Here, the ADL omits key information, and claims,
“Along with direct attacks and bullying, these bad-faith editors used frequent reporting as a means to harass and intimidate. One editor made 37% of their total edits to Wikipedia admin pages (over 13,000 edits in total) , more than 5,000 of which were reports against other editors on administrative notice boards. This high volume of reports suggests these editors focused more on attacking those they viewed as opponents rather than contributing to articles. Such harassment can be a form of area denial, making it impossible for good-faith editors to participate, and can lead to editors participating less or leaving altogether.”395
The ADL omits that this case was built around evidence provided by a pro-Israel editor, who was also banned for abusing the system. As we discuss in Section 4.5, the editor started 18 cases against perceived ideological enemies. Two pro-Israel editors were also removed for abuse in that case, and over 15 editors were removed in total in 2025.
Furthermore, this case actually disproves a key ADL complaint, that being that Wikipedia is not taking sufficient action on issues emerging within sections that contain articles related to Palestine-Israel. This arbitration proves that Wikipedia does in fact take allegations seriously, and they have an extensive process for handling issues.
If anything, it seems that Israel’s resources are being applied to manipulate Wikipedia—the exact complaint the ADL is making about editors who they do not agree with.
6.3.4 Manipulation and Disinformation (pg 15-23)
6.3.4.1 Avoiding detection (pg 15)
The report claims that their “bad-faith editors” also spend time editing the broader Wikipedia.
Incredibly, the ADL attempts to spin this as an attempt to “camouflage potentially violative edits”. This is absurd: it is a far simpler explanation that editors who spend inordinate amounts of time editing Wikipedia, do in fact edit Wikipedia outside of the Palestine/Israel section.
In fact, this evidence points to these being good-faith editors: people who take part in the overall Wikipedia project, and who also happen to contribute to the Palestine/Israel section as one of many interests and edits.
6.3.4.2 Making Minor Edits (pg 16)
The ADL further alleges that these editors are making hundreds of edits in order to “game the system” in order to gain enough edits to access editing privileges for the Palestine-Israel conflict pages. The report shares this text beneath an image showing documentation of edits,
‘One editor made hundreds of minor edits, removing categories across many articles. In other instances, they added categories or “+” to “LGBTQ” in hundreds of places. These numerous small edits allow bad-faith editors to “game the system,” in Wikipedia parlance, to rack up the necessary number of edits…to access editing privileges to protected pages on Israel and the Israeli/-Palestinian conflict.’
“Manipulation and Disinformation”, page 16
This type of manipulation, however, is exactly what the pro-Israel advocacy group CAMERA (Committee for Accuracy in Middle East Reporting) suggested in their attempted manipulation of Wikipedia in 2008.396
However, as these editors are extremely prolific editors on Wikipedia already, it seems unlikely that they would need to engage in this behavior to gain editing privileges. It is more likely that these are simple mass good-faith cleanups of Wikipedia pages made by dedicated Wikipedia editors to tidy up the online encyclopedia.
Once again, the ADL is demonstrating that these editors are not partisan promoters of anti-Israel content, but genuine contributors across the entire Wikipedia project.
6.3.4.3 Time Spent Editing (pg 16-17)
The ADL attempts to suggest that the editors it chose might work full-time on Wikipedia:
“We found that many of these 30 editors spent long blocks of unbroken time editing, often as many as eight hours in a day. While we cannot know the circumstances under which they edit, this pattern resembles full-time work, and poses the question of whether or not they are being paid to do so.”
“Manipulation and Disinformation”, page 16
However, a close look at the data shows that this actually resembles typical hobby time, rather than work time.


The two graphs above show editor activity on Wednesday, December 6, 2023, and Sunday, February 4, 2024 (the ADL omitted the day of the week from their data). Both graphs are excerpted from Image 2 in the “Manipulation and disinformation” section of the ADL report).
These graphs support the idea that these are hobby editors. The activity on the Wednesday is much more sporadic, indicating occasional edits at broad and disconnected parts of the day, indicating hobbyists taking opportunities when they have time between work and home life.
In fact, only 2 editors show significant clusters of edits on the Wednesday, with two editors editing for 12 hours, far longer than a typical work day. Other clusters on Wednesday are very short, indicating 2-3 hours of editing, again not supporting a work day. One editor shows two periods of 2-3 hours of edits, broken by a 7 hour gap, most likely when they went to work.
Meanwhile, we see much more focused activity on the Sunday, a non-work day in most of the English-speaking world, when hobbyists would have more time to focus on their hobbies.
These graphs clearly show editing patterns that are consistent with volunteer editors, rather than paid staff.
6.3.4.4 A million edits (pg 17-18)
The ADL says that these suspicious editors have, in total, made revisions to over 10,000 articles within the Israel/Palestine section, including a million edits.
In fact, this is not a significant achievement. According to Wikipedia’s numbers, 5,400 people have made over 25,000 edits each, close to the number that these “bad-faith editors” have achieved. In fact, 20 Wikipedia editors have completed over 1,000,000 edits each, the same number as all of these editors combined!397
6.3.4.5 Examples of supposed biased edits (pg 18-24)
In this section, the ADL finally attempts to provide actual examples of “manipulation and falsification”, in which they include: “adding or cutting content, removing citations and moving content to other pages, in ways that shift the narrative on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict to downplay Palestinian violence and antisemitism and heighten criticism of Israel”.
It is important to reiterate that the ADL, as a pro-Israel advocacy group, has a far-from-mainstream opinion about appropriate levels of criticism pertaining to Israel. As ADL CEO Greenblatt notes, “the ADL is a Zionist organization”.
We note that the ADL’s report rarely included sufficient information to validate their data. Though Wikipedia provides a specific “permalink” URL for each edit, the ADL never provided these permalinks in their report, and rarely provided enough points of reference to find the exact edit to which they refer. Given that these links would provide crucial context to understand why editors chose to make the edits they did, as well as evidence of subsequent reversions in some cases, this omission materially demonstrates the lack of seriousness with which the ADL approached their task.
6.3.4.5.1 Samir Kuntar (pg 18)
The ADL claims that one of the editors they identified made edits to Samir Kuntar’s Wikipedia page398 which:
“removed multiple citations for his conviction on murder and terrorism charges in Israel, as well as references to his accolades in Syria and Iran and designation as a terrorist by the U.S., while adding mention of his claims to innocence on some of the charges”.
- Image 3 caption, page 18, “Manipulation and disinformation”
The ADL did not include a permalink to the edits, nor provide any meaningful context about the exchange. We have found the likely edits, a set of 3 edits in which the editor provides context for their changes.399 We believe the ADL may have deliberately omitted this context, as it contradicts the facts they present and their spin on the subject.
The ADL claims that “references to his accolades in Syria and Iran and designation as a terrorist by the U.S.” were removed. This claim is false. These were not removed, but rather simply moved from the first paragraph to the third, where they were actually significantly expanded on.400
The ADL also omitted vital context around the claims to innocence, leaving out the comment on the edit in question, which says “per NPOV we must mention that Kuntar always maintained his innocence”401. This is a reference to Wikipedia’s Neutral Point of View policy, and provides vital context which undermines the ADL’s point.
6.3.4.5.2 Palestinian violence (pg 18-19)
In image 4, the ADL claims that an editor removed “citations to multiple peer-reviewed academic journal articles”. However, the actual change, which again the ADL did not include a link to, shows the actual reason for removal:
‘→top: removing recent insertion of POV - the first sentence already states that it can refer to terror - but "Palestinian terrorism" is not a mere alt name; it is a POV name, just a "Palestinian resistance" is a POV’402
That is to say the specific edit was reverted for two reasons. Firstly, because the first sentence already included a reference to terror. Secondly, because adding the term “Palestinian terrorism” violates Wikipedia’s Neutral-Point-of-View (NPOV) policy by adding a “point of view” (POV). That is, terms such as “terrorism” or “terrorist” are viewed as a POV on Wikipedia, which is not allowed. In fact, those words are specifically warned about in the Wikipedia Manual of Style403 as contentious labels.
The ADL once again made no attempt to engage seriously with the edit, skipping all context in order to make its false claim.
6.3.4.5.3 Destruction of Israel (pg 19)
To respond to the ADL’s claim regarding image 5, we refer to Dr. Shira Klein, noted expert on Jews, the Holocaust, and Wikipedia, who was originally quoted in the ADL report, in her article in The Forward:
‘The data the ADL does give is cherry-picked to show Wikipedia’s alleged overemphasis on Israeli crimes and underemphasis on Palestinian violence.
For example, one screenshot shows that, in November 2023, an editor removed a line about Palestinian groups that “seek the destruction of the State of Israel” from the Wikipedia article “Palestinian political violence.” The ADL describes that removal as the work of one of those “30 suspicious editors,” “removing references to calls for the destruction of Israel.”
Sounds nefarious. But here’s what actually happened, according to the publicly viewable edit history on that article. One editor deleted that line, citing its poor grammar. Other editors weighed in, wordsmithed, and ultimately agreed to reinsert it—which they did, just two days after its deletion. End of story.
This process—editors going back and forth and resolving things together—is exactly how Wikipedia is supposed to work. This happens, quite literally, hundreds of times a week. That is how content amasses on Wikipedia, through a never-ending negotiation of deletions, additions and modifications. Far from “bad-faith,” this is actually textbook editing.’
Shira Klein, “Is Wikipedia a cesspool of antisemitism? Don’t trust the ADL’s answer”, The Forward, May 16, 2025
6.3.4.5.4 Hamas edits (pg 20)
One of the biased claims that the ADL cites is:
‘The main Wikipedia entry on Hamas underwent changes to de-emphasize the organization’s terrorist actions. A sentence indicating that multiple governments designate Hamas as a terrorist group was moved from the beginning of the second paragraph to near the end of the fourth. The first reference to Hamas as a terrorist organization now appears further down in the lead section, which also no longer mentions the more than 1,100 fatalities of the October 7 attack. Instead, the lead section focuses on Hamas’s role as a political, social, and military organization that promotes “Palestinian nationalism in an Islamic context.”’
Page 20, “Manipulation and Disinformation”
The ADL did not provide any citations, permalinks or even screenshots to support their narrative of the changes.
Based on our research, these changes were made over a large series of edits by a range of editors, matching what we would expect from a collaborative online encyclopedia like Wikipedia. Extrapolating malicious intent from these edits seems to be a stretch from the ADL, who certainly did not attempt to provide any justification or references for their claims.
In fact, when we have located specific edits referred to by the ADL, those edits show a significantly different narrative than what the ADL put forward. The edit which removed the fatalities on October 7 was preceded by an edit from the same author who moved the October 7th attacks from their place in the 4th paragraph to a much more prominent one in the 2nd paragraph.404 If asked, a reasonable person would believe that these edits were pro-Israel, attempting to increase the prominence of October 7th to provide shielding for Israel’s subsequent genocide.
Another edit405 in this series split an overly-long paragraph into two paragraphs, hardly an act of malicious antisemitism, as the ADL claims.
In general, the changes about which the ADL is complaining actually seem quite reasonable. Despite the fact that the ADL wishes to define Hamas by Western governments’ description of it as a terrorist group, Wikipedia policy MOS:CONTENTIOUS policy does not allow “Contentious labels” like “terrorist” to be used directly406. Despite the ADL’s view of Hamas, the Wikipedia MOS:LEAD407 policy says that the lead paragraph should summarize the most important aspects of the subject, while “giv[ing] the basics in a nutshell”. Meanwhile, the WP:DUE408 policy says viewpoints should be represented “in proportion to the prominence of each viewpoint in those [reliable] sources”.
Looking at the current Wikipedia page for Hamas at time of writing,409 the first paragraph is an introduction, the second provides history on the organization, the third is what they stand for, and the fourth describes its relations with other countries, a logical place to include its designation as a terrorist group by various countries.
Lengthy discussion
Similarly, the ADL claim that
“A lengthy discussion of attacks against Israeli civilians and military targets was also removed, including a list of rocket attacks, a description of Hamas’s rocket arsenal, and language describing Hamas attacks on Israeli civilians as retaliation for assassinations of Hamas leaders.”
Page 20, “Manipulation and Disinformation”
This appears to refer to an edit410, marked with the comment “→Overview: the existence of this mini lede is not supported by any Wikipedia guideline and does not add anything of substance to the article”. That is, an editor had added a large “mini lede”, which provided a broad discussion of Hamas, but was not in a format which matched Wikipedia guidelines.
Again, the ADL spins the mundane, ordinary operation of Wikipedia into something malicious, by leaving out the evidence that would demonstrate otherwise.
Sexual violence
The ADL follows up by claiming that the same author edited the Gaza War page, claiming:
“In an example from August 2024, the same editor mentioned earlier removed
references to reports of widespread sexual violence perpetrated by Hamas during the October 7 attacks”
Page 20, “Manipulation and Disinformation”
Once again the ADL relies on hiding context for its claims, in this case hiding the edit’s explanatory comments:
“Undid revision 1240287591 by OtterAM (talk) we had an rfc on including this in the lead, did not gain consensus”
Nableezy, Wikipedia edit comment on Gaza War change411
This comment, omitted by the ADL in their attempt to assign malice to the editor, explains that this was discussed in a Wikipedia “Request for Comment”. This RFC412, entitled “RfC on sexual violence in lead section”, had 177 comments from 69 editors.
In the discussion, many editors discuss how the Gaza War article is an inappropriate place to discuss October 7 alleged sexual violence as was neither something that happened during the Gaza War, nor something that was known or claimed at the time of Israel’s invasion. As such, its presence in the lead was repeatedly questioned by Wikipedia editors.
Other editors discussed that the New York Times article on sexual violence was widely discredited413, and that similar articles on the Bosnian genocide did not include similar discussion in the lead, even though in the Bosnian case those claims were proven.
Adding “and terrorism”
Finally, in Image 6 the ADL aims to show, without discussion, that the heading “Violence and terrorism” was changed to “Violence”. Once again this claim is refuted by the context provided by the permalink which the ADL chose to omit.
The comment from the edit414 says “rv, already covered under prior heading”, with “rv” meaning a revert of an edit made earlier that day. That reverted edit415 appears to be propaganda, as the only change that it made was adding the “and terrorism” suffix, and was made by a user who claims to be “I am a librarian in the National Library of Israel”, likely part of the pro-Israel propaganda editing effort discussed in Section 3.6.
6.3.4.5.5 Swastika Kite (pg 21)
As another example, the ADL criticizes an editor for the removal of what it calls “explicit antisemitism”, a reference to a Palestinian flying an incendiary kite with a swastika. The passage was removed, according the edit description416, due to “undue weight on one random Palestinian”. “Undue weight” is a common part of Wikipedia’s Neutral Point of View rules,417 wherein an article should represent all significant viewpoints published by a verifiable source.
Wikipedia is not an antisemitism audit, and follows its own rules even if the ADL would prefer otherwise. Editors should clearly remove content which has “undue weight” regardless of whether it contains antisemitism or not. It is reasonable to assume that an editor would edit in accordance with Wikipedia’s rules, and it is unreasonable for the ADL to claim that this was intentional editing to minimize incidents of antisemitism.
Moreover, given that the ADL did not link to the change—a thing they seem capable of in other parts of their report—it seems likely that they were hiding the “undue weight” claim of the author in order to give weight to their claim about “explicit antisemitism”.
6.3.4.5.6 Zionism page (pg 22-23)
The ADL further objects to the language on Wikipedia’s Zionism page:418
‘Edits to the main Zionism page since 2022, meanwhile, seek to reframe Israel’s founding. The lead section now characterizes Zionism as an “ethnocultural nationalist movement” with an explicitly colonialist, ethnonationalist goal: “Zionists wanted to create a Jewish state in Palestine with as much land, as many Jews, and as few Palestinian Arabs as possible.”’
“Manipulation and Disinformation”, pg 22
The ADL does not explain their issue with this definition, nor why this is problematic. Israeli-Jewish historian Avi Shlaim, however, makes clear “That most Zionist leaders wanted the largest possible Jewish state in Palestine with as few Arabs inside it as possible is hardly open to question”.419
In fact, the statement the ADL highlights is heavily supported by academic references. Its footnote, reproduced in its entirety in Appendix A below, contains 1,459 words to support it, including 17 references to books and articles by noted historians. These historians include pro-Israel historian Benny Morris, Jewish-American academic Norman Finkelstein, Israeli academic Ilan Pappé, and Rashid Khalidi, a longtime professor at Columbia University. The referenced books and articles were published by notable academic publishers including Oxford University Press, University of California Press, Cambridge University Press, and Manchester University Press.
The main issue here seems to be the distance between the ADL’s positive view on Zionism, and what Wikipedia treats as reliable. The ADL, a self-described Zionist organization, likely discounts important elements of Zionism such as the ethnic cleansing of historic Palestine, the current genocide in Gaza, or the attempted modern-day ethnic cleansing of the West Bank, East Jerusalem, and Gaza, preferring to focus on Jewish identity and nationalism.
Wikipedia, meanwhile, demands academic sources in the place of narrative and spin, asking that articles “rely on scholarly material. When available, academic and peer-reviewed publications, scholarly monographs, and textbooks are usually the most reliable sources”.420
6.3.4.5.7 1948 Palestine War page (pg 23-24)
The ADL continues to criticize Wikipedia’s “1948 Palestine War” article421, saying:
“The 1948 Palestine War article, for example, underwent significant shifts in tone, content, and perspective from 2022 to 2024, including an extensive section on historiography that introduces concepts such as ‘Zionist narrative as not history in the proper sense’ and ‘Neo-Zionist narratives.’”
“Manipulation and Disinformation”, pg 23-24
The ADL is attempting to present the phrase “Zionist narrative as not history in the proper sense”, as evidence of antisemitism. They go on to use this to deliver a scathing critique of Wikipedia on this basis:
“In these examples, the larger pattern of changes demonstrates a systematic effort to skew numerous Wikipedia entries to promote a set of narratives critical of Israel, often delegitimizing Israel’s existence and actions. In many cases, these changes shift the entries from balanced historical accounts to a narrative that skews toward militant Palestinian perspectives, likely violating Wikipedia’s policies against advocacy. These edits are part of a concerning trend of gradually obscuring historical Jewish presence in the Middle East through unjustified expansions and modifications.”
- “Manipulation and Disinformation”, pg 24
However, the ADL has distorted the quote through selective quotation. The sentence on Wikipedia from which the ADL pulled422 read in February 2025 as:
‘According to Shlaim, this narrative is “not history in the proper sense of the word”, as most of the literature on the war was produced—not by professional academic historians—but rather by participants in the war, politicians, soldiers, and state-sponsored historians, as well as by sympathetic journalists, chroniclers, and biographers. It also portrays Israelis as morally superior, lacks political analysis, and gives undue weight to "the heroic feats of the Israeli fighters." This nationalist narrative was taught in Israeli schools and used for gaining legitimacy internationally.’
- Wikipedia’s “1948 Palestine War” page, 12 February, 2025
Not only does the full sentence make clear that antisemitism has nothing to do with the characterization of the Zionist narrative, but the individual being quoted is none other than Jewish Israeli historian Avi Shlaim423, a highly respected scholar who is widely regarded as one of the foremost experts of Israeli history in the world.
The ADL here used deliberate selective editing to distort the meaning of the quotation. It is clear to any reader of the full sentence that this is not antisemitic.
6.3.4.6 “Manipulation and Disinformation” summary and verdict
On pages 15-24 of their report, the ADL attempted to show that the editors it chose took part in coordinated, deceptive, or ideologically-motivated editing. The evidence presented focused on patterns of editing, such as editing outside of Palestine-Israel Articles, making many small edits, how they spent their time, as well as examples focussing on specific content.
In fact, the patterns were spurious and failed to show any suspicious behaviour:
They framed ordinary and best-practice Wikipedia activity as sinister (“avoiding detection”, “making minor edits”, “a million edits”) when it in fact demonstrates good-faith editing by those editors.
They suggested that Wikipedia editors were being paid, without actual evidence, using a single cherry-picked example which actually demonstrated the opposite (“time spent editing”).
They significantly exaggerated the total impact of these editors, when in fact their total edit count puts them outside the top 5000 editors, and where the 20 most prolific Wikipedia editors each have more edits than all of the grouped editors combined.
The examples were worse:
The ADL hid the context from the examples, when that context demonstrates that they are simply part of a collaborative Wikipedia editing process (“Palestinian violence”)
They ignored standard Wikipedia policies such as “undue weight” (WP:UNDUE, in “Hamas edits” and “Swastika Kite”) and the MOS:CONTENTIOUS and MOS:LEAD policies (in “Hamas edits”), instead choosing to imply malicious intent to the editors.
They make unsupported claims of antisemitism because they did not like content that is supported by 17 separate scholarly references (“Zionism page”)
They selectively edited a quote to make editors seem antisemitic, when the full quote shows no such thing (“1948 Palestine War page”)
According to the ADL, the editors in question made around 1,000,000 edits to Wikipedia, an ample corpus in which the ADL should have been able to find a large range of biased editing. Given their best efforts to provide evidence relied instead on cutting context and selective editing, we are left to conclude that the ADL could not find valid or persuasive evidence.
In addition, in almost every case, the ADL provided no links to the Wikipedia edits that could be used to investigate and replicate their data. Given that Wikipedia provides clear permalinks to every edit, we believe the ADL chose not to include links to their evidence because it was so low quality, and the raw evidence would undermine their claims.
6.3.5 Voting Patterns (pg 24-29)
The ADL presents overlap in the voting patterns of their chosen editors as signs of collusion. They present 19 articles that editors largely voted to keep, and 18 articles that the editors largely voted to delete, out of a larger corpus.
However, contrary to the ADL’s presentation of the data, these were not articles in which all 30 of the editors voted together, and most articles presented had few votes in total. In addition, the articles which were voted to keep can very clearly be seen as being notable articles, such as “1948 Palestine War”, while the articles that were voted to delete can be clearly seen to be low-quality non-notable articles, such as an article (“Free Palestine (phrase)”) described by a Wikipedia contributor as “an article about two words sometimes used together.”
6.3.5.1 Evidence of collusion
The ADL’s report conveys the impression that all 30 editors are voting together on each of these articles. In fact, that is not the case. None of the articles they listed had all 30 editors voting together, and most articles had relatively few votes. Indeed, it seems that the ADL is deliberately misrepresenting data to make it seem more meaningful. In Appendix E, we include the full result of the votes on the pages they cite.
We found that the ADL hid considerable context in the sample they presented, which we presume is their strongest evidence. They do not present how many editors voted, nor do they present the total counts so that we can see context. They even include an article in which only 40% of the voting editors from their group voted the same way.
In the article on “Denial of the 2023 Hamas-led attack on Israel”, only 7 delete votes were recorded424. In the article on “Killing of Barel Hadaria Shmueli”, only 13 votes in total were recorded425.
Many of the votes have mass agreement beyond the group of editors the ADL is maligning. In the “Free Palestine (phrase)” article, zero Wikipedia editors voted to keep it, information the ADL failed to share. Similarly, zero votes from any Wikipedia editors were recorded to keep “Alleged Palestinian genocide of Israelis”, or “2014 Rosh Hashanah Terror Tunnel Plot”, and zero votes were recorded to delete “Palestinian citizens of Israel”, and “1948 Palestine war”. Meanwhile, two or fewer votes were recorded to keep “Greater Palestine”, “Anti-semitic anti-Zionism”, “Israeli humanitarian aid to Gaza”, and “Hamas beheading incidents”, or to delete “Israeli occupation of the West Bank”, “Children in the Israeli–Palestinian conflict”, “Racial profiling in Israel”, and “Wehda Street massacre”.
6.3.5.2 Articles with votes to keep
The articles which a consensus of the ADL’s grouped editors voted to keep can clearly be seen as important and notable articles, including “Human rights violations against Palestinians by Israel”, “October 2023 UNRWA school airstrike”, “Israeli occupation of the West Bank”, “1948 Palestine war”, “Genocide against Palestinians”, and “Allegations of Israeli apartheid”. These are clearly important articles.
Further, those “bad-faith” editors actually voted to keep an article which we would expect biased anti-Israel editors to want to delete, that being “List of deaths and critical injuries caused by Palestinian stone-throwing”.
The ADL further notes that most of these articles were in fact kept by the larger Wikipedia contributor votes, demonstrating that the ADL’s claim of bias is nonsense.
6.3.5.3 Articles with votes to delete
On the other hand, the articles which the editors voted to remove are largely non-notable low-quality articles:
‘these bad-faith editors repeatedly voted to delete topics detailing Palestinian or anti-Israel violence, calls for the destruction of Israel, and criticism of Palestinian violence or terrorism, such as “Jerusalem Light Rail stabbing,” “Glorification of martyrdom in Palestinian society,” “Free Palestine phrase,” “List of Islamist terrorist attacks,” “Alleged Palestinian genocide of Israelis,” and “Denial of atrocities during the 2023 Hamas attack on Israel.”’
“Voting Patterns”, Page 25
The ADL calls these “notable articles”, however, an inspection of these articles indicate that there is very little merit to these articles, and that they are certainly not notable. Given there is a large number of articles on Wikipedia that detail anti-Israel violence, the fact that the ADL could not find notable articles which the group allegedly colluded to remove, seriously undermines the ADL’s position.
We recommend readers read the deletion vote426 for the “Free Palestine (phrase)” article, which includes the low quality content of this “notable article”:
“An article about two words sometimes used together. Even ignoring the transparent editorialising in the article, Wikipedia is not a platform for documenting the conjunction of words”
- AndyTheGrump, 7 December, 2023427
“Asserts that it is a commonly used phrase without any evidence and sources its origin to some pre 1948 committee no-one ever heard of”
- Selfstudier, 7 December, 2023428
Another article which the ADL calls notable is the article on “Greater Palestine”,429 considered by Wikipedia editors to be “filled with contradictory and unrelated pieces of information”. Wikipedia editors further comment “The page name itself is sourced to a single, one-off quote that carries little weight alone, let alone justification for a standalone page; the rest is [original research] and has no place anywhere”.430
Another article which the ADL calls notable is about “antisemitic anti-Zionism”,431 which was deleted because “no editor argues that this is an independently notable concept, but rather an aspect of anti-Zionism”.
The deletion vote for the article “2014 Rosh Hashanah Terror Tunnel Plot”432 even contains an admission from its author that it is low quality and should be removed:
“I created this article last week on the assumption that a just-breaking story would soon be substantiated. That has not happened. I am happy to follow CoretheApple's suggestion that it be taken down without prejudice if substantiation emerges.”
ShulMaven, Articles for deletion/2014 Rosh Hashanah Terror Tunnel Plot
Yet, the ADL refers to this article too as a “Notable article”.
The ADL undermines their own argument by trying to claim that deleting low-quality articles is only something that would be done in bad faith. In fact the opposite is true— the editors who voted to keep low-quality articles on non-notable topics are breaking Wikipedia’s rules on notability.433
6.3.6 Sources (pg 28-33)
The ADL went through the sources listed by the “bad-faith editors”, claiming that:
“The most common sources the bad-faith editors use in their contributions, however, include unreliable or highly biased resources and media outlets (while frequently removing reputable sources, such as mainstream media or academic publications).”
“Sources”, Page 29
It goes on to highlight that “the thirteenth most common among the bad-faith editors was to “PalestineRemembered.com,” an independent website critical of Zionism that contains mostly opinion and commentary rather than first-hand reporting or evidence”.

The ADL is attempting to tell a story where bad-faith editors cite biased and unreliable content in an attempt to manipulate Wikipedia, eschewing reliable media sources. However, the actual evidence compiled by the ADL shows the opposite.
In fact, these editors mostly quoted mainstream publications, including four Israeli news media (Haaretz, Jerusalem Post, Times of Israel, and Ynetnews), three mainstream Western media which have had multiple reports434 about having significant pro-Israel bias (BBC435, New York Times436, and The Guardian437), and two websites commonly used for citing academic papers (JSTOR and DOI), plus Google Books in first position. In addition, they cite the Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs, the United Nations, and two renowned Human Rights groups, one of which is Israeli.
Not only that, but the ADL notes that PalestineRemembered.com was cited specifically for village statistics in 1945 for which it appears to be a reputable and incredibly detailed resource.
The ADL further attempted to slander palestineremembered.com by claiming
‘For example, the site includes an FAQ on why Palestinians purportedly want to “destroy Israel and drive Israeli Jews into the sea.”’
Page 29, Sources
Once again, the ADL is twisting the actual evidence. Indeed, the actual passage,438 shown above, is incredibly clear, and very obviously indicates the opposite from what the ADL claims. That is, Palestine Remembered was refuting a supposedly common question asked of Palestinians by Israelis and Zionists. This is obvious from the title of the page “Zionist FAQs: Why do Palestinians want to destroy Israel and drive Israeli Jews into the sea?” and the first sentence on the page “This is the question asked most frequently by Israelis and Zionists”. As usual, the ADL did not provide a link to this page where their claim could be easily seen to be false.

Screenshot of Palestine Remembered, showing the actual content for which the ADL claimed: ‘For example, the site includes an FAQ on why Palestinians purportedly want to “destroy Israel and drive Israeli Jews into the sea.”’
The ADL continues to criticize editors for referencing Al Jazeera (for being “banned in Israel”). However, Wikipedia considers Al Jazeera “generally reliable”,439 and has had sixteen discussions on the topic, cementing its reliability. We should recall at this point that the ADL itself is considered to be “generally unreliable”440 according to Wikipedia on the topics of Palestine-Israel or antisemitism.
Notably, at no point did the ADL demonstrate the sources being used in a biased way, or even include a single example where biased articles were used to suggest antisemitic or even anti-Israel bias.
In attempting to show further bias by the “bad-faith” group of editors for citing Google Books, the ADL makes the incredible claim that Google Books “represents links to a range of books, some of which are also biased”. This is actually a real claim that the ADL made, and demonstrates how strained their evidence is. In fact, Wikipedia’s gold standard of truth is not online news media, but peer-reviewed scholarship, most of which is published in books.
6.4 Detailed Critique of Case Study 2
In “Case Study 2: Bias in Arabic-language Wikipedia content on Hamas” in the ADL’s report,441 the ADL focuses on analyzing specific Arabic-language Wikipedia pages, claiming that Arabic Wikipedia contains significant pro-Hamas bias, perpetuates pro-Hamas propaganda, and “flout[s]” Wikipedia’s rules for neutrality.
However, in our analysis of the sections they cite, we find that the ADL frequently sees pro-Hamas bias where none exists. Even though the ADL’s examples are cherry-picked from over 1.2M articles on Wikipedia, nearly all of the bias the ADL alleged turned out to be either neutral facts about Hamas, viewed through the organization’s own biases, or passages the ADL misunderstood due to misinterpretation of sections translated from Arabic.
Instead of analyzing the original Arabic language articles directly, they examined English translations, which resulted in the ADL inferring meaning that was not present in the original. Often, this analysis hinged on interpreting a single English word, such as “garrison” or “unique”, to infer violence or praise.
The ADL’s analysis shows an apparent failure to grasp the full meaning of the original Arabic text. By relying on an English translation rather than examining the terms within their proper linguistic, cultural, and/or Islamic contexts, the organization reached several incorrect conclusions. This includes an overly simplistic and decontextualized interpretation of a passage from a Hadith, a significant collection of Islamic texts.
To further build its case, the ADL singled out more minor and less significant pages to bolster its argument. Given the vast range of articles in Arabic Wikipedia, it is unreasonable to expect every single article to be completely free of bias. The same is true on English Wikipedia, where articles with less traffic, fewer edits, and fewer contributors naturally have fewer chances to improve their quality.
The ADL also claims that the specific passages they chose to analyze contain fewer citations or broken citations. This is a common problem across Wikipedia, and it does not demonstrate that the content is biased, that it endorses Hamas, or that it constitutes propaganda. These are separate claims and require separate evidence.
A main flaw is the ADL’s assumption that Arabic Wikipedia should be an exact copy of its English counterpart. Rather, Arabic Wikipedia serves 450M people spread across 25 countries with diverse governments, cultures, dialects, and religions, and is not supposed to be identical to English Wikipedia. While not all Arabs are Muslim, Islam carries particularly significant influence across the Arabic-speaking world.442
The ADL’s analysis relies on stripping this context from the articles under evaluation. In many cases, it appears that the ADL even lacks the understanding of the context, such as in the section that cites a Hadith. Several of their analyses rely on important words such as liberation, resistance, martyr, and jihad. It seems that the ADL either lacks a grasp of the full nuance and context of these Arabic words, or assumes its audience not to care.
Arabic Wikipedia is geared towards Arabic speakers, but the ADL, an American organization, interprets its content through a lens that is not only biased, but that also ignores the linguistic, cultural, and/or religious context to adequately analyze it. This results in a severely flawed analysis, and in several cases, the ADL appears to willfully misconstrue certain sections. This allows the ADL to slander editors with the terms “pro-Hamas” without merit.
6.4.1 Hamas Examples
We analyze the ADL’s examples concerning Hamas, each of which, the ADL claims, “glorifies the terrorist organization, minimizes its atrocities, and, in places, appears to function as propaganda that does not abide by Wikipedia’s NPOV requirements or its content source standards”. We found that none of the ADLs examples held up.
6.4.1.1 Pro-Palestinian Phrases for Liberation Framed as Praise for Hamas
The ADL claims that neutral, simple descriptions of Hamas are glorification of the organization. Two examples are the phrase “from the river to the sea” and (quoting the ADL) ‘“liberation” of “Palestine”’.
It is absurd to say that describing Hamas’s goal as the liberation of Palestine glorifies Hamas. It is a simple description of the goal of the organization. Many other organizations have the same goal, though prefer a different means.
Similarly, “from the river to the sea” is a common phrase associated with Palestinian liberation, referring to the land between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea—the area from which Israel ethnically cleansed Palestinians and where they seek self-determination. In this particular case, it is a direct quote that describes their goals, provided via a reference to the Wilson Center, an organization funded by the U.S. Congress to provide a “trusted, fiercely nonpartisan bridge between scholarship and public policy”.443
The ADL makes no attempt to explain their problem with these phrases.
Notably, the ADL even puts quotation marks around “Palestine”, signaling an extreme stance that questions Palestine’s very existence. This choice demonstrates not only how badly the ADL misunderstands the context of Arabic Wikipedia, but also how far its views stray from the rational mainstream.

6.4.1.2 “A Vision of the Liberation of Palestine” and Translating Religious Content
A clear example of the ADL’s lack of understanding of the Arabic text occurs in their discussion of the section “A vision of the liberation of Palestine”. This section contains religious references, which are not accurately translated, especially considering the religious context, further showing the ADL’s lack of contextual understanding.
The ADL takes specific issue with the line “a day’s garrison in the cause of God is better than the world and everything in it”, claiming that it “bolster[s] Hamas’s positions, rather than providing neutral, noteworthy information”, and that it “advocat[es] Hamas’s violent worldview”.
In fact, this is a quote to a Hadith, a reported saying of the Prophet Muhammad, which the Wikipedia page notes as being narrated by Hadith scholars Al-Bukhari, Muslim, Al-Tirmidhi and Ibn Majah.

In fact, the English translation of the Arabic word ribat as “garrison” is flawed. Ribat carries specific meaning within the Hadith, and the linguistic, historical, and religious context appear unknown to the ADL.
Ribat can be understood as “the act of standing guard for the sake of Allah” and “holds profound significance in Islamic tradition”. Historically, ribat referred to protecting vulnerable frontiers from enemy attacks, although now can be understood as: “standing vigil for the sake of Allah, guarding community vulnerabilities…its essence may extend to various forms of service and sacrifice in the way of Allah”.444
The English term “garrison” more commonly refers to troops stationed to guard a specific location. By understanding ribat as “garrison”, a literal translation, the ADL emphasizes a warlike or combative interpretation, which ignores the full meaning. The ADL’s use of this translation misses the specific religious context, and shows how ADL lacks the necessary linguistic, historical, and religious context in its analysis.
Contextual religious translations of the Hadith do not use “garrison”. The standard translation on Sunnah.com, from Dr. Muhammad Muhsin Khan, translates it as “To guard Muslims from infidels in Allah's Cause for one day is better than the world and whatever is on its surface…”,445 while A Manual of Hadith translates it to “A day’s frontier guard in the way of Allah is better than the world and what is in it”,446 and Sahih Muslim as "Observing Ribat (guarding the Muslim frontiers in the cause of Allah) for a day and a night is better than fasting and standing for night prayer for a whole month".447
The ADL’s choice of a simple context-free translation leads to its error. Many English translations of this hadith exist, which the ADL could have used to better understand the words in context, had they understood what they were looking at.
By relying on an English translation without linguistic, historical, or religious context, the ADL mischaracterizes the passage and fails to establish their claim of glorification or praise of Hamas.
6.4.1.3 Description of Hamas’s “Military Action”
In this section, the ADL makes a truly tenuous connection. The section describes the history and motivation for Hamas’s building of tunnels. The ADL introduces a connection of tunnels and the October 7 attack, and then uses that to claim the section “lauds the violent actions of the terrorist organization”.
The actual Wikipedia subsection describes a construction project. It does not mention October 7 in any way. The ADL introduces a new concept, and then attributes it to the Wikipedia editors in an attempt to insert violence which does not exist in the actual text.

6.4.1.4 “Social and Charitable Work” and Citations
The ADL further targets the “Social and charitable work” subsection of the page. They complain that “Wikipedia contributors uncritically recite Hamas’s social credo”.
It is unclear what is wrong with this. Wikipedia is an encyclopedia, and editors are not allowed to introduce their own research. Listing the credo of a group provides information about the group and the group’s beliefs.
Indeed, the Wikipedia page for the ADL includes that the ADL has a “stated purpose of combating antisemitism and other forms of bigotry and discrimination”,448 uncritically sharing the organization’s own perspective of the work it does.

6.4.1.5 “Women’s Work”
As we discuss in this section, it is worth remembering that Hamas refers not just to the Al-Qassam brigades, Hamas’s military wing, but to a broader organization encompassing political, military, and social activities. Hamas also governed Gaza, with responsibility for overseeing civilian services such as healthcare, education, and public administration.
The ADL’s major issue in this section rests on the use of “the first-person plural”, in the phrase “we find them as mothers”. Though they did not state the objection, we expect it might be either that the ADL believes this introduces the authors’ opinion, or that it is written in Wikipedia’s voice.
However, this is a conventional rhetorical construction in Arabic. The grammatical use of “we” does not itself demonstrate that Wikipedia’s editors personally endorse the proposition that follows, much less that they “advocate for jihad”, as the ADL claims.
In English, this might be written more simply as “they are mothers”. The ADL is assigning meaning to an ordinary grammatical construction without evidence.
The ADL also criticizes the sentence for referring to raising children “on the love of God and jihad for His sake”. Though they do not state it, we can infer that the ADL believes that “jihad” is necessarily violent, which is how the term is commonly used in English.
However, the page is not written in English, and the Arabic use of the word jihad is a more complex term. According to Wikipedia, “In an Islamic context, [jihad] encompasses almost any effort to make personal and social life conform with God's guidance, such as an internal struggle against evil in oneself, efforts to build a good Muslim community (ummah), and struggle to defend Islam.”449 This is supported by scholarship on Islam.450
Further, the actual wording does not “advocate” for jihad, as the ADL claims—the actual wording is descriptive.
The ADL also criticizes the page for referring to suicide bombers as “martyrs”. In this section in particular, the ADL expects Arabic Wikipedia to be written on the basis of its worldview, in which occupation is good and resistance to it is bad. In Arabic, martyr is a common term to refer to people understood to have died in or for the Palestinian struggle, including civilians as well as combatants. Simply translating the word as “martyr” and then treating it as evidence of pro-Hamas propaganda ignores the substantially different cultural and political meaning the term carries in Arabic.

6.4.1.6 Glorifying “Sons and Children of Movement Leaders Were Assassinated”
The ADL refers to another subsection of the Hamas article, claiming it is devoted to “glorifying the sons of Hamas leaders who have allegedly been killed” and to “idolizing” the organization. However, the subsection describes the arrest and killing of Hamas leaders and their children over the last two decades. Characterizing this passage as “idolizing” overstates its content. There is no language that praises or glorifies Hamas.
The ADL also claims that it “solely presents Hamas’s worldview”. In fact, the passage itself refers to Quds Press Agency’s monitoring, and presents facts about individuals who have been killed. Neither constitutes glorification, endorsement, or praise of Hamas.

6.4.1.7 Hamas’s Position on Fatah, Security Coordination, and Political Arrests
The ADL complains that the Hamas article, when referring to their political rival Fatah, ‘describes Hamas’s views without counterpoint and characterizes its rival’s views as “absurd”’.
Once again, the ADL conflates the description of Hamas’s perspective with support or endorsement for that perspective. It is not glorifying Hamas’ views to state them without commentary, nor is there any reason why every statement that describes Hamas’ views as requiring a counterpoint.
The Wikipedia article clearly says “The movement sees the option [...] as absurd”. This merely is documenting Hamas’s viewpoint, attributed to Hamas. Similarly, other passages in the section are also attributed to Hamas. No Hamas opinions are presented in Wikipedia’s voice, and the language does not endorse the opinions.
The ADL also states that there are few working citations and links, but, again, does not adequately support how this demonstrates bias.
6.4.1.8 The Position of European Union on Hamas
The ADL suggests in the section “Hamas and the European Union”, that “the EU is acquiescing to American and Israeli demands regarding Hamas, such as listing them as a terrorist group, because EU members do not want to risk “the Jewish issue” returning to Europe”.
The sole explanation for what is wrong with this section is in a link to the ADL’s Glossary of Extremism, which it has taken offline as part of its move away from anti-hate work, as described in Section 5.4.
Although this section may be incorrect, it does not support the ADL’s claims of glorification of Hamas, or perpetuation of Hamas propaganda.

6.4.2 “Additional examples”
In this section, the ADL cherry-picks pages in the search for “biased” or “unreliable” content “related to Hamas”. Arabic Wikipedia has over a million pages, and over a hundred of them are directly related to Hamas, with presumably many more tangentially related.
From this, the ADL has cherry-picked just three pages. Even from these three, we can see that the ADL’s examples are not as straightforward as they claim.
6.4.2.1 The Shalit Deal and “Praise” for Hamas
6.4.2.1.1 “Glorification” for the Gilad Shalit Deal
The ADL claims that Wikipedia “praises” Hamas on its page for the Shalit Deal, referring to the 2011 prisoner exchange with Gilad Shalit. Its evidence hinges on the ADL’s translation of the word "مميزة" (mumayyiza) into English as “unique”, which in English can be seen as positive.
This word, however, does not imply praise. Rather, it indicates something distinctive, unusual, or notable, which, in this case, is referring to how long Gilad Shalit was kept alive in captivity. We note that “unique” also does not necessarily imply praise in English, but can also be used as a neutral term implying an unusual situation.
Once again, the ADL’s reliance on English translations to analyze Arabic text is problematic. As demonstrated here, the ADL extrapolates meaning from its own assumptions about the language, rather than adequately considering the original Arabic text.

6.4.2.1.2 Analyzing “Praise” in the “Hamas Poster”
The ADL also shares a picture of a Hamas poster, which references Shalit. It is normal on Wikipedia to include visual documentation of an event and its political context. Including this image does not glorify the event.
The ADL appears to suggest that the descriptive text “Our heroic prisoners, every year a new Gilad” is biased towards Hamas. This is clearly indicated in the caption that this is a transcription of the words from the poster, and implies neither endorsement nor positivity.
6.4.2.2 The Killing of Yahya Sinwar
The ADL refers to the page on “The killing of Yahya Sinwar, as “represent[ing] Hamas’s perspective, glorifying his legacy and death”.
When reading the entire article, this particular paragraph represents the last paragraph of the opening section, in which they provide context for the significance of Sinwar’s death. His role in Hamas leadership was significant enough for Israel to loudly proclaim his death, and we would expect a Wikipedia entry on the topic should explain why his death is significant.
Similarly, many of the descriptions of Sinwar are simply facts about him, such as leading Hamas in Gaza since 2017, and his influence in the Palestinian arena. A number of the facts about him are accurate, but do contain a positive note, such as recounting that he died on the battlefield. However, these statements are limited, do not fill the entire article, and reflect Sinwar’s actual role as an important symbol of resistance for Palestinian people.

6.4.2.3 Al-Qassam Brigades and the Characterization of Resistance
Similarly, the Arabic-language Wikipedia page for the Al-Qassam Brigades, Hamas’ military arm, contains what the ADL calls “nearly 50 bulleted references to terrorist acts”. Part of the purpose of a Wikipedia page is to list the acts of the subject of the page.
It appears that the ADL is upset that those actions are not described as terrorist actions. However, Wikipedia discourages the use of the word “terrorist” in its manual of style (MOS:TERRORIST), part of its Neutral Point-of-view Policy.451 It is supposed to be used not to describe a group, but rather how to describe how one entity, such as the U.S. government, designates another. Certainly, the U.S. designates Hamas as a terrorist organization, as do over 20 other countries.
Though this particular rule is designed for English Wikipedia, it is not hard to believe that this would be carried over in many cases, especially since no other Arabic-speaking countries, with the exception of Israel, designate Hamas as a terrorist organization.
As a result, the proper Wikipedia approach would be to list the acts or innovations of Hamas’ neutrally, which appears to be what the ADL is demonstrating.
We also note that the ADL lists the example of the 1994 Ibrahimi Mosque massacre in which 29 were killed by Israeli soldier Baruch Goldstein, a member of the Jewish Defense League.452 In Section 5.10, we show that ADL CEO Jonathan Greenblatt was photographed next to a Jewish Defense League flag in the violent pro-Israel rally at UCLA in which he was a speaker.
6.4.3 Conclusion on Case Study 2
The ADL’s Case Study 2 is a faulty analysis that mistakes explanatory language with praise or glorification, relies on decontextualized English translations of the original Arabic, and interprets and filters content through its own biased pro-Israel framework.
Repeatedly, the ADL characterizes neutral or factual language that merely explains Hamas’s perspective as “glorification” or evidence of bias.
In addition, many of the ADL’s claims suffer from a misunderstanding of the original Arabic, or from a lack of understanding of Arabic language, Islam, or Arab culture, in which the ADL does not appear to have sufficient expertise for this work.
The examples the ADL provides do not offer substantial evidence that Arabic-language Wikipedia reproduces “Hamas’s own language and perspective”, that its pages constitute propaganda or endorse Hamas, or that their content is more extreme than the English-language versions.
6.5 Detailed Critique of “Damage Done” Follow-Up Report
On October 15, 2026, the ADL followed up with a second report, entitled “Damage Done: Wikipedia Leaves Biased Edits Unchecked Despite Editor Bans”.453 This report followed a lot of the same patterns as the original ADL report, the most notable of which is hiding the edit descriptions from editors they attempt to disparage.
This report was written by the ADL’s Center for Technology & Society (CTS). The CTS is the wing of the ADL that deals with tech and tech companies, and ADL CEO Jonathan Greenblatt has frequently claimed that they have influence over a huge number of technology companies: “All the businesses, from Alphabet to Zoom”.454
In this report, the ADL made no new claims of antisemitism, instead attempting to consolidate the claims of their last report by demonstrating a dire need for Wikipedia to change its policies in ways that would please the ADL.
6.5.1 “Finding 1”
The ADL’s first “Finding” attempts to demonstrate reasons why all edits by banned editors should be reviewed. It presents a Case Study of one of the banned editors, and attempts to demonstrate that the editor’s edits provide lasting damage to Wikipedia.
6.5.1.1 “Softening” Hamas
In ‘“Softening” Hamas’, the ADL targets a specific editor, Iskandar323, who was given a topic ban in January 2025. The ADL claims that their edits remain on Wikipedia and attempt to cast this as an example of “lasting damage” to Wikipedia. As in the first report, the text presents the edits as negative and antisemitic, offering no evidence to substantiate the claim.
Their first claim is that the editor is “softening” Hamas’ reputation, by moving criticism of Hamas into its own page. However, the actual edit description explains the reasoning:
“Removing material split to Criticism of Hamas to help resolve the page's grossly overlength page size (117kB of reasable prose prior to this move) - per WP:SPLIT and WP:TOOBIG - leaving child article link + brief summary)”455
That is, the page was huge, and Wikipedia’s policies state that pages that are too big should be split. Wikipedia’s Splitting page reads,
“If an article becomes too large, or a section of an article has a length that is out of proportion to the rest of the article, it may be appropriate for some or all of the article to be split into new articles. In some cases, refactoring an article into child or sister articles can allow subtopics to be discussed more fully elsewhere without dominating a general overview article to which they are non-central (but only if the new articles are themselves sufficiently notable to be included in the encyclopedia).”456
When splitting the page, information about Hamas was not removed, but was rather moved in its entirety to a new page, and prominently linked in a dedicated section. Indeed, the main article457 also retained a significant amount of information critical of Hamas, including a very large section entitled “Violence and Terrorism”, with subsections “Attacks on Civilians”, “Extrajudicial killings of rivals”, and “Terrorist designation”.
The ADL seems concerned that other people do not view the ADL’s enemies in exactly the same light as the ADL does. Wikipedia articles are primarily about the subject of the articles, and not, despite the ADL’s hopes, about criticism of the subject. The fact that criticism of Hamas overtook actual information about Hamas clearly reveals the need to reorganize the article.
The ADL then claims that the editor removed ‘roughly 17,000 characters of text and citations from “Gaza war”’, all of which featured content about the October 7 attack. In fact, as demonstrated by a link provided by the ADL itself, this section was actually moved to the article “October 7 attacks” (then called “2023 Hamas attack on Israel”), which is a natural place for it according to the contents cited by the ADL. None of it appears to have been removed during transition.458
The ADL further claims that the editor removed another 7,400 characters, specifically mentioning references to Israeli organization ZAKA, and again the comment provides context that the ADL omits:
“Reports of atrocities on 7 October: paring down material already split to the child article 2023 Hamas attack on Israel into a summarized version of the same - removing excess detail and outdated statements”459
That is, the Gaza War page still contained significant information on October 7 attacks, and thus the editor summarized it, holding onto the main content and citations. The edited article still contained references to ZAKA and other October 7-related content.
The ADL puts forward a relative picture only: the editor reduced content about Hamas, but gave us no reason to believe that reducing the content harmed readers’ understanding of Hamas.
The ADL claims that the editor engaged in “softening” Hamas, but the purpose of an encyclopedia is to document facts and information, not to push the ADL’s perspective. The page about Hamas is supposed to be about Hamas, and criticism of Hamas—alongside October 7—form part of that picture, but not the entire picture.
While we are not so naive as to claim the editor’s claims are to be taken at face value, the ADL provided no evidence that the pages were damaged in any way from the changes. Moreover, the ADL repeatedly hid edit descriptions in a clear attempt to twist and falsify the actions of others, both in the report and in the “Editing for Hate” report discussed in Section 6.3.
6.5.1.2 “Recasting” Al Jazeera
In this section, the ADL makes the claim that a user—formerly known as Cinaroot, and who changed their username and stopped editing after being doxxed by an ADL-affiliate—basically made multiple edits about the news media company Al Jazeera. The ADL has not stated what they find objectionable about Al Jazeera, nor how someone making edits about Al Jazeera is related to antisemitism, which is the supposed interest of the ADL.
They claim the user has made “nearly 200” edits about the topic. However, the user has made a total of 7,341 edits460 meaning these are less than 3% of the user’s edits.
Al Jazeera is one of the world’s largest news organizations, with more than 70 bureaus worldwide, 3,000 employees from 95 countries, and distribution in over 150 countries.461 Indeed, Al Jazeera is widely regarded as having trusted coverage as compared to other large media, such as the New York Times, or BBC, who have consistently been found to have bias in their reporting on conflict in the Middle East, as we discuss in Section 2.3.4. While the BBC, according to a report by Newscord, attributed attacks to Israel in only 50% of relevant cases, Al Jazeera identified the perpetrator 89% of the time.462
We believe that the ADL, in line with the rest of the Israel Lobby, dislikes Al Jazeera because it is one of the few international news organization without a large pro-Israel slant. It was one of the few news organizations which actively covered Israel’s genocide in Gaza, which Western news organizations largely suppressed, instead often promoting Israel propaganda.
Indeed, Israel shut down Al Jazeera’s local offices in Israel in 2024463. Israel has also killed at least 13 Al Jazeera journalists, including Shireen Abu Akleh, who Israel shot in Jenin in May 2022, and Ahmed Wishah, who was deliberately targeted by Israel in June 2026.464
According to the ADL, Cinaroot has worked to ‘recast Al Jazeera as “a democratizing global force”’, while providing no evidence that it is not, merely that the ADL does not like Al Jazeera. It is unclear how this editor, who is not banned, cited, or otherwise in bad standing at Wikipedia, is causing “lasting damage”, and the ADL has certainly not attempted to provide any evidence for it.
Like with “Bad-faith Editors” discussed in Section 6.3.1, it seems the ADL has simply identified an editor it does not like, and then attempted to frame their behaviour as harmful on that basis.
6.5.1.3 “Finding 1” conclusion
In “Finding 1”, the ADL doesn’t appear to have found anything at all. It spent time researching Iskandar323’s edits, and the strongest evidence it could produce for supposed lasting damage was moving content between pages. In its second case study, that of Cinaroot, it produced no evidence at all.
The cited content in Section 6.5.1.1 is the sole evidence presented for the primary and titular claim of the report. In a report entitled “Damage Done”, the entirety of the supposed damage that they cite is from two moves, which changed no content whatsoever, and a summarization of excessively verbose content while keeping the core information in place.
Wikipedia works off facts. Wikipedia editors ruthlessly cull edits made without strong supporting evidence. Indeed, the ADL has pointed to several facts that it dislikes on Wikipedia, such as “Zionists wanted to create a Jewish state in Palestine with as much land, as many Jews, and as few Palestinian Arabs as possible” (discussed in Section 6.3.4.5.6), that many pro-Israeli editors would clearly love to remove. However, it remains because it is supported by a huge volume of evidence.
The Palestine-Israel Articles section of Wikipedia is aggressively edited. There are plenty of pro-Israel editors on Wikipedia, and if they have not been able to remove the facts the ADL dislikes, it implies that those facts are sufficiently supported so as to withstand being cut.
The ADL’s “Finding” is nothing more than a means to provide itself with an avenue for influence over the contents of Wikipedia. If the ADL can trigger mass reviews of the Palestine-Israel Articles section of Wikipedia, then it can apply its massive resources to gain influence on those mass reviews.
6.5.2 “Finding 2”
6.5.2.1 Sustained, multi-front external pressure
In this section, the ADL refers to how “sustained, multi-front external pressure” had been applied against Wikipedia. This is, in fact, the very point we are making in this report, and we are indeed surprised to see the ADL admit it. The ADL itself states,
“The pressure came from several directions: congressional scrutiny, including a House Committee on Oversight investigation and a bipartisan Congressional letter from 23 members, federal inquiries from the Department of Justice and the Senate Commerce Committee; enforcement work by Wikipedia’s NPOV-policy editors, ADL reporting, and broader media scrutiny.”
- ADL, “Damage Done” report, Finding 2
We have been claiming for the past 100 pages that the Israel Lobby has been manipulating Wikipedia, and the ADL just confessed. Indeed, it seems that they are bragging. We discussed these campaigns by Israel-aligned US politicians in Sections 4.1, 4.2, 4.3, and 4.4. Section 4.5.4 further discusses ADL CEO Greenblatt’s recent confession that they have 45 employees stalking Wikipedia editors.
Despite the fact, as we point out in Section 6.1, 6.2, 6.3, 6.4, and 6.5, that the entirety of the ADL’s report was either fabricated, fictional, or false, the Israel Lobby was able to use it to attack Wikipedia. Indeed, there was apparently such a change that the ADL is celebrating its success, citing the change as “measurable, and runs across multiple metrics”.
6.5.2.2 ADL demonstrates changes are unnecessary
The ADL, both in the original “Editing for Hate” report, as well as the follow-up “Damage Done” report, proposed recommendations to Wikipedia to change their policies in ways which would give the ADL and other pro-Israel organizations more influence.
In this section, however, the ADL demonstrates that its requested changes are unnecessary. The biggest source of change, according to the ADL, comes from ArbCom actions against a number of editors. However, each of these actions began (and some had concluded) before the ADL report was published, and before Congress got involved.
This belies the ADL’s claim that more action is necessary, as according to the ADL, Wikipedia’s internal tools are more than capable of dealing with the potential for abuse across the platform.
6.5.2.3 Further spin in “Finding 2”
Naturally, the ADL makes a number of other misleading or undocumented claims in this section. They suggest, for example, and without any evidence, that editors might have “moved off-platform”. They also incorrectly claim that the Tech for Palestine workgroup discussed in Section 6.6 “coordinated editing across more than 100 articles on the conflict”.
This contains both factual error and spin. A total of 260 edits were made by the Tech for Palestine workgroup, one less than the ADL’s own campaign in 2021, which produced 261. The ADL explanation is misleading in claiming that 100 articles were changed, attempting to make it seem much much larger than the 260 total edits that were produced. They also falsely claimed the 100 articles were “on the conflict”, when, in actuality, only 2 edits were in the PIA section, and those were made by existing editors.
We note that the ADL continues to reference meaningless data, such as “group communication” and “tandem edits”, in its attempt to demonstrate coordination. We discuss those terms in Section 6.3.2.
6.5.2.4 “Finding 2” conclusion
We are gratified to see the ADL confess to their campaign to influence Wikipedia. However, all evidence, including that provided by the ADL, demonstrates that it is ArbCom who made the impact the ADL claims credit for. Indeed, the “sustained, multi-front external pressure” the Israel Lobby produced happened after Wikipedia’s pre-existing internal mechanisms had already acted.
6.5.3 “Finding 3”
In “Finding 3”, the ADL returns to the roots of the first ADL report, and identifies and then maligns without evidence a group of editors whose edits they do not like. In this case, they have found 11 new editors who they dislike. Though these editors have been at Wikipedia a long time, the ADL missed them the first time round, possibly due to the fact that their analysis techniques, which we discussed in Section 6.3, had no real basis in fact.
As in the first report, the ADL cherry-picks evidence to attempt to show that editors it dislikes are editing Wikipedia. This time, it brands their work as “more subtle and defensible under Wikipedia’s rules”—that is to say, these editors are editing Wikipedia in a normal way, and the ADL is simply picking on ones it dislikes.
Unlike the first report, the ADL does not even try to demonstrate anything more than its dislike of the content produced by these editors.
6.5.3.1 dmh223344
In one example, according to the ADL, an editor worked on the Zionism article, ‘consolidating material on “settler colonialism” that was previously spread through the article's general history, into a section of its own’. The ADL frames this as a bad thing, but it would seem that if this information was spread throughout the article, consolidating it into a section would increase understandability. Indeed, the relationship between settler-colonialism and Zionism is well-studied and well-known.
In the same section, the ADL complained that the editor ‘edited the page to "make sure transfer as euphemism for ethnic cleansing is covered"’. It appears that the ADL—a supposed civil rights organization—would prefer that “ethnic cleansing”, a violation of the most fundamental principles of human rights, should be referred to by a euphemism.
In case of doubt, the ADL further complains:
“‘The account's edit summary states what the edit was for: to ensure the article treats the term as a euphemism for ethnic cleansing’.”
“Damage Done” report, page 17
In order to defend Israel, the ADL is not just minimizing Israel’s long history of ethnic cleansing and other crimes against humanity, but even the concept of the acts themselves.
Finally, the ADL brings up that ‘Zionists sought a state with “as few Palestinian Arabs as possible”’. As we discussed in Section 6.3.4.5.6, this specific quote is extremely well documented in Wikipedia, and we included a copy of its citations—17 separate scholarly books and articles—in Appendix A. Again, the quote itself comes from Israeli-Jewish historian Avi Shlaim.465
6.5.3.2 Butterscotch Beluga
The ADL accuses editor Butterscotch Beluga of “gatekeeping”. In fact, what the ADL means here is that the editor frequently reverts edits which violate Wikipedia rules, that is, other people make bad edits, and Butterscotch Beluga reverts them.
The first piece of evidence the ADL provides is again related to the quote “as few Palestinian Arabs as possible” on the Wikipedia page on Zionism. There, the ADL points out that Butterscotch Beluga argues that the sentence is reliably sourced. We are unclear what the ADL’s issue here is, as they do not explain. Again, as discussed in Section 6.3.4.5.6 and as listed in Appendix A, there are 17 academic references supporting that sentence. This is likely another place where the ADL simply doesn’t like the content.
The ADL also continues its habit of casting doubt on the editor while hiding the evidence. For example, the ADL claims:
“On “German support for Israel in the Gaza war,” it restored wording that the German government “denied” a genocide was taking place in Gaza, which the other editor had changed to “rejected the assertion,” a phrasing choice that implies an established fact and an alleged German denial of that fact.”
In this case the ADL again hid the evidence. The edit description states, ‘Partial revert of edit that introduced WP:DOUBT like "alleged Gaza genocide"’.466 This description explains why Butterscotch Beluga reverted the edit: the addition of the word “alleged”, violating Wikipedia’s rules on WP:DOUBT. Thus, the ADL’s claim and evidence is irrelevant, as it was unrelated to the reason the edit was reverted.
The ADL raises further issue with this author as, ‘on the article about the slogan “Death to Israel,” it removed the category “Incitement to genocide of Jews,” writing, “Do not
treat Jews & Israel as interchangeable groups.”’ We have been led to believe that it
was antisemitic to treat Jews and Israel as interchangeable, and we are unclear why the
ADL is objecting to this.
In fact, this is a common ADL tactic. When an edit strengthens a fact they like, the ADL says that the revert weakens it. When an edit weakens a fact which they like, they say the revert strengthens it.
The opposite is actually true: the original edit is the edit that strengthens or weakens a fact, and the revert in fact restores it to its original state. In the German example above, the ADL complains that the editor introduced a German denial, when in fact it restored it from its previous place.
The ADL then claims:
“On pages related to the Hamas-led October 7, 2023, attacks in Israel, the account reverted the work of an editor who had changed the lead of “October 7 attacks” to describe the subject as a massacre.”
Here, the ADL chooses to omit linking to the edit in question. The revert’s description in fact shows that the edit did not just “describe the subject as a massacre”, but renamed the article from “October 7 attacks” to “October 7 massacres”, violating Wikipedia’s WP:POV rule on introducing points of view. In the same edit, they also “changed the wording of an exact quote”, which would by itself be grounds to revert the edit.467
Finally, the ADL claims that the editor ‘restored the wording that a rape allegation had been “later discredited” over another editor’s “have been called into question”’. Again, the ADL dislikes the editor, and so it attempts to discredit the edits. However, the ADL—seemingly deliberately—omits a link to the edit description,468 which demonstrates the ADL’s error:
‘Reverting edit that changed "were later discredited" with "have been called into question" under the inaccurate premise that "The Intercept is a political group" - Not only is The Intercept a WP:GREL news org, the statement is also cited to Haaretz. You previously attempted to make this change & were reverted, do not edit war to include your preferred content.’
6.5.3.3 إيان
The ADL’s attack on إيان is again, simply an instance where they do not like an editor’s edits, and they malign them as a result. The ADL opens by claiming “This account focuses on reframing the opening premise of a specific page”, which is demonstrably false and can be seen via the editor’s large and varied editing history.469
The ADL also claim that he made a significant edit with only “ce” as the description—in fact, the significant edit470 was made separately, and the edit to which they link was a copyedit.471
The ADL then attempts to discredit the editor by saying that they “defended the rewrite by citing Democracy Now, the anti-Zionist outlet Electronic Intifada, and Al Jazeera”. The ADL omitted from this claim what the editor actually said,472 which is that he was citing “authoritative scholars” Rashid Khalidi473 and Joseph Massad,474 as well as “prominent Palestinian journalist Mariam Barghouti”.475
They do not point to any misconduct, nor to any violation of the rules by إيان, nor a pattern of reverted or low-quality edits. Indeed, it seems the exchange to which they pointed was civil, fact-based, and centered on the rules of Wikipedia.
The ADL explained their issue: they simply do not like that Gaza is referred to as “blockaded”. However, this is an objectively true fact, one which would be removed via Wikipedia’s strong collaborative editorial controls if it were not true.
Gaza has been blockaded by Israel since 2007,476 which was what enabled Israel to create a famine in Gaza in 2025.477 This fact is a unique point about Gaza, one of the few, and possibly the only, fully blockaded territory on earth today.
Once again, the ADL simply dislikes facts.
6.5.3.4 “Finding 3” conclusion
The ADL’s third finding attempted to show that “biased editing has continued to reshape Israel- and Jewish-related entries across Wikipedia”. This is something they failed to show.
Instead, they cherry-picked a small handful of editors and attempted to create a false narrative by cherry-picking their edits. Even in this they failed, relying on selective editing, and out-of-context claims.
In several instances, its claims about these editors were simply that they introduced facts that the ADL disliked, such as the blockade of Gaza, or the well-documented connection between Zionism and colonialism. In one case, the editor did not even introduce facts, but merely made several reverts, in places where the ADL would prefer they were not reverted.
In multiple cases, though they generally included links to the edits in question, they failed to read the description of the edit. In a handful of the worst cases of out-of-context claims, they omitted the edits from their report—when those edits clearly contradicted the ADL’s claims.
6.5.4 “Finding 4”
Finding 4 was the lowest-quality “finding” in the report, and indeed there are two paragraphs in this section—in addition to one other in the conclusion—which read to us as “AI slop”.
6.5.4.1 Last word
“Finding 4” is very unclear, and it took significant reading and parsing to understand what was being claimed, which turns out to be much less significant than the executive summary makes it seem.
“On the 229 articles where these 19 accounts overlap, the 11 newly identified editors are far more active recently and hold the most recent edit, effectively a page's current text, on roughly six in ten of them.”
- “Finding 4” in “Executive Summary”
One could be forgiven for thinking that the ADL is saying these 11 editors are “far more active” as they hold the most recent edit on a page frequently. Indeed the ADL implies this directly by saying these new editors “hold the most recent edit, effectively a page’s current text”.
This is misleading. The ADL makes it appear as if the new editors are so prolific that they are the most recent editors on 60% of some important set of pages, which is not in fact the case.
This is clarified in the Definitions in the ADL’s Methodology appendix, where they define “Last word” as “holding the most recent edit to an article among the surveyed accounts. It is not a claim that no other editor has touched the page since”.
Bearing this in mind, we will clarify the ADL’s actual fourth finding:
In Finding 3, they identified 11 new editors whose edits they dislike
They compared them with 8 of the editors they disliked from the “Editing for Hate” report
They found that when an editor from both groups (the 8 and the 11 editors respectively) edited the same page, that in 60% of cases the newer editor (from the group of 11) made the most recent edit of the 19 editors.
We note that 11 is roughly 60% of 19.
Ultimately, the finding here is that among two arbitrary groups of people, identified by the ADL on different arbitrary criteria which could best be described as “we don’t like them”, both groups held the arbitrary distinction of “Last word” approximately in proportion to the group size.
The ADL attempts to sell this as “The new cohort now sets the frame”. However, they did not attempt to explain why a member of an arbitrarily chosen group editing after a member of another arbitrarily chosen group “sets the frame”, given that many other editors edited the pages after these editors.
This “Finding” is nonsense—easily the most shamefully bad section of either report—which makes it all the more troubling that the ADL attempted to tie this to claims about sexual violence.
6.5.4.2 Sexual Violence
The ADL goes on to discuss Wikipedia articles on sexual violence.
We note that this section contained multiple instances of “AI slop”, which we discuss in Section 6.5.5.
We have repeatedly pointed out that Israel attempts to create propaganda to support its narratives. One way it does this is by making claims of atrocities, as dehumanizing propaganda against Palestinians. For example, Israeli propaganda networks quickly spread the “40 beheaded babies” hoax in the weeks after October 7, a claim which had no evidence behind it at the time, and has been proven false.478
Similarly, very shortly after October 7, when no evidence of sexual violence yet existed, claims of mass sexual violence was already spreading, despite the lack of evidence at that time.
Wikipedia is a prime target for Israel propaganda around sexual violence. At the same time, sexual violence is a very difficult subject to discuss in reasonable terms in an online community.
In cases of sexual violence, there is significant stigma attached to those who push back on claims of sexual assault, including in cases with little or limited evidence. On Wikipedia, however, pushing back on claims with little or limited evidence is one of the central activities that keeps the online encyclopedia accurate.
We believe that the ADL is weaponizing this tension, attempting to portray editors who uphold Wikipedia standards as being deniers of sexual violence.
6.5.4.2.1 Reverting and reframing
Indeed, the first presentation of evidence is simply that two of the editors, whom the ADL does not like, have edited pages on sexual and gender-based violence.
The first actual evidence the ADL points to regards an editor who prevented the removal of the word “reportedly” from the “Sexual and gender-based violence in the October 7 attacks” article. Although it happened in 5 instances, the ADL does not include their sources, and reduces context to simply quoting the editor saying “these are not weasel words... removing them in fact violates NPOV”.
However, the truth is quite different. In the “weasel words” edit, which the ADL points to,479 the reverted editor also added the text “by Islamist and fringe-leftist publications”, in clear vandalism of the page. In another instance,480 the editor added additional context, “we use the same term in the page for sexual violence against Palestinians”.481 We note that these were some of the few edits of which the ADL forgot to link to in their report.
The ADL’s second piece of evidence482 relates to the same article and editor, which they frame, using the editor’s quote, as “a debate over the existence of weaponized sexual violence”. However, the ADL makes it seem like the editor is denying claims of sexual violence, linking, for example, to a United Nations report,483 which discusses sexual violence.
However, the edits in question484 make clear that it is the weaponization of sexual violence which is under question, and indeed links to the very United Nations report the ADL cites, which states, “Neither could I determine whether sexual violence was used as a tactic of war, or in a widespread and/or systematic manner”,485 agreeing with the editor’s characterization.
6.5.4.2.2 Tagging and Removing
The ADL also criticizes an editor for flagging passages as unsupported, and then deleting them when no evidence was presented to support them.
“The sequence began on December 13, 2024, when the account removed all mentions of the Israeli police from the article’s account of the attacks. Two days later, it flagged a sentence in the sexual violence section with a “by whom” tag, and nine days after that it deleted the sentence it had tagged.”
“Damage Done” report, from “Tagging, then removing” section
If we inspect the edits, we see the first comment includes an explanation of“per talk”—referring to the Talk section of Wikipedia where changes are discussed. The second comment is extremely detailed, explaining that the comment is presented in “wikivoice” (that is, a factual uncontested claim), which goes against Wikipedia policies:
“I added the by-whom tag because the sentence stated in wikivoice what is an alleged claim by some as a factual claim that is uncontested, when the rest of the section and the main page shows that it is not. Since the denunciation is specified in the rest of the section, this sentence is unnecessary, and additionally violates NPOV and RS-sourced information, so should be removed”486
It appears, once again, that the ADL is simply cherry-picking edits and removing their context, in an effort to make editors they dislike look bad. This is despite the fact that the very links they present dispute the ADL’s version of events.
6.5.5 AI-slop
ADL’s Greenblatt declared in a recent interview that the ADL had become “AI-first” over the last 3 years.487
AI slop is low-quality research produced by AI that is not verified by humans. We identified “AI slop” in the report when we saw text that made little contextual sense, and has the trademark sound of AI-produced content. These include unnatural use of the passive voice, hedging language—especially in contrast to the ADL’s much more aggressive editorial voice—as well as “uncanny valley”488 phrases such as “the finding is the pattern”, “the sequence matters more than any single edit” or “That decline is real, but it is not repair”.
Two of the three AI slop sections that we identified, included below, were in this “Sexual violence” section. We cannot prove that LLMs were used to generate this text; it is also possible that the sloppy nonsensical text was written by a human, which is arguably worse.
In either case, we are disgusted by the repugnant and inexcusable sloppiness in their “Sexual violence” section. That the content passed their editors and made it to publication indicates the cavalier attitude the ADL has with respect to their readers, and to victims of sexual violence. This is not surprising, as the ADL was perfectly willing to weaponize this sexual violence to score points.
Example 1:
“The finding is the pattern: hedged language installed in article leads and defended for over a year, statements in Wikipedia’s factual voice converted to attributed claims, and the resulting framing protected through at least 89 reverts in activity running from November 2023 to within days of the data pull in July 2026.”
- First section of believed AI slop, final paragraph of “Case Study: Controlling the Frame on October 7 Sexual Violence”
Example 2:
“The sequence matters more than any single edit. Flagging a passage as unsupported and deleting it days later for being unsupported produces a record in which every step looks like maintenance. The effect over five weeks was evident: the removal of every reference to the Israeli police from the article’s account of the attacks, a sentence attributing sexual violence that the account had itself tagged nine days earlier, and finally an entire section. A reader arriving at Wikipedia’s “October 7 attacks” page today finds an account of the attacks roughly 3,300 characters shorter, with the police findings and the attribution of sexual violence no longer there”.
- Second section of believed AI slop, 2nd paragraph of “Tagging, then removing”
Example 3:
“The coordinated mechanics of the campaign have visibly diminished, and the
Wikimedia Foundation has signaled an intention to invest in anti-abuse
infrastructure. That decline is real, but it is not repair. The campaign now edits more quietly, not less effectively, and the text it already wrote has never been
systematically reviewed. Neither response — individual bans nor promised
infrastructure — closes the governance gap that allowed a coordinated campaign to operate for years. Reviewing and repairing the distortions is the work that has not yet begun. As long as it remains undone, every search query, AI-generated answer, and knowledge panel drawing on those articles carries the distortions forward”.
- Third section of believed AI slop, 2nd paragraph of “Conclusion”. (emphasis ours)
We note also that their Methodology section reads as AI slop in its entirety.
6.5.6 “Damage done” conclusion
Similar to their first report, the ADL’s methodology was to identify editors it disliked, and then to cherry-pick edits that present Wikipedia in a bad light. It then attempted to draw “findings” that conveniently supported the ADL’s goals.
This report presented even less evidence, and it was just as tenuous as the first report. We found no piece of evidence provided by the ADL that stood up to even minor scrutiny.
The ADL’s core thesis, that of lasting damage made to Wikipedia, was not even remotely proven outside of its subjective lens. Did an edit to the Hamas page which consolidated content improve or worsen the page? The ADL simply claimed the change was made by one of their targeted editors, and that was that.
Whether discussing the pages on Hamas, Al Jazeera, or sexual violence, the ADL did not engage with either the topic or the edits beyond superficially listing them. In most cases, we were to infer from context what was bad about the changes—it was almost never spelt out.
We found that each of the four findings relied on evidence that was unsupported, relying on cherry-picked examples, omitting context, or misleading its audience on the actual Wikipedia editorial processes.
Our main takeaway was the ADL’s confession in “Finding 2”. To quote the ADL in full:
“The pressure came from several directions: congressional scrutiny, including a House Committee on Oversight investigation and a bipartisan Congressional letter from 23 members, federal inquiries from the Department of Justice and the Senate Commerce Committee; enforcement work by Wikipedia’s NPOV-policy editors, ADL reporting, and broader media scrutiny.”
- ADL, “Damage Done” report, Finding 2
6.6 “Systematic” Edits
The ADL repeatedly uses the word “systematic” in its report.
“a group of editors systematically evade Wikipedia’s rules”
Introduction, pg 1 (emphasis ours)
“include the systematic removal of citations”
Introduction, pg 2 (emphasis ours)
“have recruited volunteers to make such edits systematically”
Introduction, pg 5 (emphasis ours)
“the larger pattern of changes demonstrates a systematic effort toskew numerous Wikipedia entries”
Manipulation and disinformation, pg 24 (emphasis ours)
“We are not suggesting simply that people critical of Israel are systematically revising Wikipedia.”
Conclusion, pg 42 (emphasis ours)
This phrasing was echoed in a letter from multiple Congresspersons to Wikimedia in 2025:
“One recent report raised troubling questions about potentially systematic efforts to advance antisemitic and anti-Israel information in Wikipedia articles related to conflicts with the State of Israel”
Letter from James Comer, Chair of Committee on Oversight and Government Reform; and Nancy Mace, Chair of the Subcommittee on Cybersecurity, Information Technology, and Government Innovation to Wikimedia, August 27, 2025489 (emphasis ours)
The ADL is attempting to create a narrative that editors who report genuine facts about Israel and Palestine’s history, and work within the Wikipedia system, are colluding and being coordinated by anti-Israel factions.
However, at no point did they demonstrate this. All of their claims about systematic editing campaigns rely on their low-quality evidence from Case Study 1, which does not even try to show actual collusion, but tries at best to infer it from statistical signals, and does a very poor job at that. They cannot point to a single case of actual collusion, of editors who know each other, of chat rooms in which they work.
For this reason, they have attempted to bring Tech for Palestine—authors of this report—into their narrative, claiming that Tech for Palestine were “supporters” of this campaign, making “edits systematically, reshaping the narrative on Israel and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict to promote pro-Hamas, pro-terrorist views”.
It’s important to remember that the evidence collected by the ADL goes back to at least 2008. The claims about Tech for Palestine refer to a community-created workgroup in the Tech for Palestine Discord which was created in 2024—long after most of Wikipedia’s Palestine/Israel Articles were created—and ran for only 8 months.
This workgroup could not possibly qualify as a large-scale campaign as, according to the extremely pro-Israel Jewish Journal who reported on this group, about 260 edits were made to Wikipedia in total by the workgroup’s members.490 Those edits are described as having been outside the PIA section of Wikipedia, such as noting celebrities who supported a ceasefire. The new editors brought in by this initiative could not have made any changes to the PIA section as Wikipedia editors are required to have made 500 edits outside the PIA section to be able to edit within it..491
The ADL includes this claim by linking to an extreme-right media publication called Pirate Wires, who previously have published antisemitic conspiracies claiming manipulation of Wikipedia by Jewish philanthropist George Soros.492 The author of this article, Ashley Rindsberg, appears to now run a Wikipedia-stalking-as-a-service company, of which the ADL appears to be a client, which we discuss in Section 4.6.3.
The ADL’s goal in linking Tech for Palestine with their alleged “bad-faith” editors is to invent, out of nowhere, a story of systematic coordination. Without that the ADL simply has individuals who are taking part in the proper process of editing Wikipedia, sometimes adding information that the ADL doesn’t like.
We reiterate that the ADL’s entire evidence for systematic editing comes from this claim. Given the workgroup contributed just 260 edits to Wikipedia, less than most accomplished editors contribute in a day, and one less than the ADL contributed when it was manipulating Wikipedia as discussed in Section 3.9, it is clear the ADL has no evidence at all of mass collusion.
The ADL also claims that the efforts were “largely coordinated on Discord”. They have presented no evidence of this claim, have not named or suggested which Discord groups might have been doing this, apart of course from the Tech for Palestine Discord, which could not have been responsible. Indeed, we are not aware that anyone else has made this claim, nor has any evidence been presented by any group, to our knowledge.
We highlight this as an example of both the poor standard of evidence used by the ADL in their report, and also as an example of how the ADL misuses its role to create misinformation and propaganda, wherein they actively inflate and launder unreliable facts and bring them into the mainstream.
Indeed, every organization that has made these claims is recycling the same evidence493, attempting to repeat it and cross-cite each other to spin the narrative into existence. Other organizations tried to spin it further, with the Jerusalem Post494 for example claiming that 8,000 articles were edited—in fact 8,000 people was the number of people who had ever joined the entire Tech for Palestine Discord server (of whom only 50 ever even spoke in the Wikipedia workgroup).
This claim of “systematic edits”, in addition to other claims throughout the ADL report, are all in service of their efforts to spread false propaganda and misinformation.
The best evidence that the ADL has of “systematic edits” is a single Discord server, set up in 2024, in which Wikipedia was a minor interest, and in which no new editors made any changes to PIA, and in which just 260 edits were ever made.
6.7 The ADL’s Conclusion and Recommendations
The ADL’s conclusion reveals their true objective in exerting influence over Wikipedia, aiming to transform it from a truthful, fact-based encyclopedia, into one that parrots the ADL’s views. One of their major goals is poisoning LLM and generative AI models to reach their propaganda goals.
Despite Wikipedia’s design depending on good-faith actors, the ADL claims that “bad-faith” Wikipedia editors are in coordination, yet they provide no substantial evidence of such coordination. Rather, they present poor-quality research in which they use circular logic to fabricate statistical connections to demonstrate collusion.
Despite their claims of antisemitism, their attempts to demonstrate it instead center on discussion of Israel. Even so, they fail to demonstrate that there are any widespread falsehoods added to Wikipedia about Jewish people, or even about Israel.
The ADL’s suggestions that some editors are paid is not supported by evidence, and in fact the evidence that they present suggests that these editors are hobbyists.
And finally, the ADL’s broader claim of a concerning amount of anti-Israel bias on Wikipedia is unsupported—Wikipedia has simply documented Israel’s actions, from its establishment as a state to the present. The ADL report has shown no evidence of antisemitism in Wikipedia editing, nor intentional bias against Israel, but rather a realistic depiction of accurate facts.
6.7.1 The ADL’s Recommendations
The ADL exposes their true goal, stating,
“Tech companies should exclude contentious topics (and articles with a disputed neutrality tag) from these applications, unless they can verify their content and sources. Curbing the use of unreliable content from Wikipedia will both reduce its spread and visibility, and disincentivize such manipulation.”
This means, essentially, that the ADL wants tech companies to exclude all Wikipedia information about Israel and Palestine from LLMs, and other derivatives of Wikipedia. Such a move would obfuscate the truth of Israel’s violent founding and their ongoing occupation of Palestine.
After years of attempts to manipulate Wikipedia, as documented in this report, we recognize the ADL’s goal related to technology companies, wherein they seek to remove and reduce access to information pertaining to the truth of Israel and Palestine. And by doing so, this would allow for more openings for pro-Israel organizations and media to fill the space with their own pro-Israel narratives.
It is important to recognize that though imperfect, Wikipedia is the best and most unbiased content which exists on the conflict. This is exactly why the ADL does not like it.
In analyzing the realities, and fallacies, of the ADL report, we seek to make visible the ways in which the ADL seeks to manipulate Wikipedia, and how doing so seeks to fulfill the larger goals of online suppression of accurate information pertaining to Israel and Palestine in order to push forward a pro-Israel narrative.
6.7.1.1 Recommendations for Wikipedia
The ADL’s recommendations are clearly efforts to introduce ways for the ADL and the pro-Israel lobby to influence Wikipedia.
Their first recommendations are to create a “reputable expert program”, to engage in a “Pre-screening” for special closure editors, and to ensure that “closure”, or decisions on “controversial content” cannot be decided by a majority vote. Rather, controversial decisions “should be decided on the merits by specially designated closure editors”.
The “reputable expert program”, for example, would create a panel of “experts” on “Israel and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, vetted by the Wikimedia Foundation, to review contentious pages for accuracy and bias”. Such an expert program is unnecessary and redundant, however, as Wikipedia already relies on experts, and the citation of reputable academic sources. And PIA (Palestine and Israel Articles) sections are especially reliant on the application of reputable research, as we discussed previously in the report related to the Wikipedia page on “Zionism”.
Wikipedia’s reliability is supported by experts in the field, such as Dr. Shira Klein, who the ADL themself understands as expert enough to cite in this report. It is clear that the ADL is not interested in citing experts, but rather seeks a means to influence. By creating special privileged groups that can control content on Israel and Palestine, this enables Israel, via the ADL and other Hasbara partners, to influence programs, chosen experts, and their decisions.
The ADL’s second set of recommendations focuses on “at scale” approaches against abuse or to prevent bias. These calls to address potentially problematic issues “at scale” are vague, and seem like programs that Wikipedia has already implemented at scale, and quite successfully.
The emphasis on creating centralized tools to be employed “at scale” seem, rather, to be a way for the ADL to exert more direct influence. We note in Section 4.6.2 that the ADL’s partner in the report, the “stealth nonprofit startup” that was created and funded by pro-Israel tech elite, is creating tools that fit this narrative. We presume the ADL is creating space for this pro-Israel technology to be inserted into.
Furthermore, LLMs are already biased against Palestinians and prioritizing pro-Israel narratives, so attempts to use AI and other centralized approaches for “at scale” abuse or bias prevention will be faulty. However, the faultiness will bias towards the Israel Lobby’s preferred direction, so that is why they want this.
Ultimately, then, the issue seems to be that the ADL does not like the experts used by Wikipedia already—historians, scholars, and noted experts in their respective fields—and wishes to replace them with “experts” whose perspectives are friendlier to Israel, and align more closely with their own.
Most importantly though, the tools Wikipedia already has for preventing bias and other issues “at scale” have proven to be effective. Despite the ADL’s claims, Wikipedia remains very neutral. And it is in fact this which the ADL is pushing back on—almost all other media out there is biased towards Israel, and its objection is that Wikipedia is not.
6.7.1.2 Recommendations for AI Companies
The ADL recommends removing Wikipedia as source material in Large Language Models (LLMs), replacing it with other sources, or warning users that it is not reliable.
Again, the ADL has failed to demonstrate an actual problem with Wikipedia. Its claims about the bias within Wikipedia are false and absurd, as discussed in Section 6, and even sometimes intentionally taken out of context to present their narrative. The ADL has falsified this narrative in an effort to damage LLMs by making them biased towards Israel and away from human rights.
By attempting to manipulate LLMs in this way, they attempt to erase important historical information pertaining to the region, from even prior to the establishment of the Israeli state. Such manipulation obscures the history of Israel, and its efforts to colonize, occupy, and settle Palestine.
They recommend that LLMs instead rely on “other relevant and trustworthy sources, like Reuters”. But, a significant amount of mainstream media is much less trustworthy and more biased than Wikipedia. In Section 2.3.4, we discuss multiple reports which analyze media bias in headlines and content, across the mainstream media landscape.
Wikipedia’s high quality comes from its significant use of academic papers and scholarly books, which operate at a far higher standard than news media. Wikipedia’s approach allows editors to find and remove unvalidated information, to ensure that each fact is thoroughly cited and reputable, and provides many eyes to ensure high quality. Despite this, the ADL seeks to replace this incredible resource with a reliance on already biased news media, over which it has significantly more influence.
Similarly, it advocates for search companies to downgrade Wikipedia content, not because it isn’t trustworthy and factual, but because it is, and because the trustworthy facts are inconvenient to their narrative.
6.7.1.3 Recommendations for Government
The ADL asks governments to step in and take steps that would be disastrous for civil rights on the basis of false claims of “antisemitism”. As discussed previously, the ADL did not make any effort to actually present evidence of antisemitism on English Wikipedia.
Despite this, the ADL tries to bring in the government to, among other things, “institut[e] a private identity verification program for editors”. This suggestion would require Wikipedia editors to register in order to be able to edit Wikipedia. This is a chilling effect, which would harm normal Wikipedia editors, but would not harm pro-Israel editors, who are aligned with the government in this case.
We are once again reminded that the ADL is not a civil rights organization, but one who will reject civil rights if it helps them achieve their goal of promoting pro-Israel narratives, which is made possible through obscuring Israel’s crimes.
We note that one of the ADL’s suggestions has already been established, “holding hearings on the topic of bias and antisemitism on Wikipedia”, as discussed previously.
By asking the government to step in to address fake claims, the ADL attempts to introduce new ways to influence Wikipedia content. The U.S. government has been systematically bribed by AIPAC to be pro-Israel, whether through funding campaigns to allow pro-Israel candidates to join the government, or to suppress human rights- based decision-making, which would limit military support the U.S. provides to Israel. These AIPAC-aligned politicians are now the ones that the ADL is asking to regulate Wikipedia.
Notes
Shira Klein, “Is Wikipedia a cesspool of antisemitism? Don’t trust the ADL’s answer”, The Forward, May 16, 2025. ↩︎
“Editing for Hate: How Anti-Israel and Anti-Jewish Bias Undermines Wikipedia’s Neutrality”, Anti-Defamation League, March 18, 2025 ↩︎
Attributed variously to Stalinist jurists Lavrentiy Beria, former head of the Soviet NKVD, and Andrey Vyshinsky, former Soviet Foreign Minister.
“Give me the man and I will give you the case against him”, Wikipedia ↩︎Clare Duffy, “The ADL says Wikipedia contains antisemitic bias, amid dispute over how the Israel-Hamas conflict is represented on the site”, CNN, March 20, 2025 ↩︎
Shira Klein, “Is Wikipedia a cesspool of antisemitism? Don’t trust the ADL’s answer”, The Forward, May 16, 2025 ↩︎
USC Shoah Foundation, “Antisemitism on Wikipedia: Distorting the History of the Holocaust”, YouTube, May 23, 2024, at 47:50 ↩︎
“Wikipedia:Arbitration/Requests/Case/Palestine-Israel articles 5”, Wikipedia, January 23, 2025 ↩︎
Isra Guy, “[Isra-pedia]...”, Electronic Intifada, March 21, 2008. ↩︎
“Wikipedia:List of Wikipedians by number of edits”, Wikipedia, March 28, 2026. ↩︎
“Samir Kuntar”, Wikipedia ↩︎
Showing three edits between September 19, 2024 and October 9, 2024.
“Samir Kuntar: Difference between revisions”, Wikipedia. ↩︎
Showing difference in a single edit from October 9, 2024.
“Samir Kuntar: Difference between revisions”, Wikipedia. ↩︎
The revision from October 9, 2024, including an explanatory comment.
“Samir Kuntar”, Wikipedia. ↩︎
“Palestinian political violence: Difference between revisions”, Wikipedia, 25 November, 2023 ↩︎
“MOS:TERRORIST”, Wikipedia ↩︎
“Hamas: Difference between revisions”, Wikipedia, September 22, 2024 ↩︎
“Hamas: Difference between revisions”, Wikipedia, October 11, 2023 ↩︎
“Wikipedia:Manual of style/Words to watch”, Wikipedia ↩︎
“Wikipedia:Manual of Style/Lead section”, Wikipedia ↩︎
“Wikipedia:Neutral point of view - Due and undue weight”, Wikipedia ↩︎
“Hamas: Difference between revisions”, Wikipedia, October 10, 2023, ↩︎
“Gaza war: Difference between revisions”, Wikipedia, August 14, 2024 ↩︎
Discussion thread from December 2023 to February 2024.
“Talk:Gaza war/Archive 39 - RfC on sexual violence in lead section”, Wikipedia ↩︎
Daniel Boguslaw, Ryan Grim, and Jeremy Scahill, “Between the Hammer and the Anvil”, The Intercept, February 28 2024 ↩︎
“Hamas: Difference between revisions”, Wikipedia, October 19, 2023 ↩︎
“Hamas: Difference between revisions”, Wikipedia, October 19, 2023 ↩︎
“2018–2019 Gaza border protests: Difference between revisions”, Wikipedia, March 7, 2024 ↩︎
“Wikipedia:Reliable sources and undue weight”, Wikipedia, February 6, 2025. ↩︎
Avi Shlaim, Israel and Palestine: Reappraisals, Revisions, Refutations (2009) Verso Books. ISBN 978-1-78960-165-7 ↩︎
“Wikipedia:Reliable sources”, Wikipedia, September 16, 2026. ↩︎
“1948 Palestine War”, Wikipedia. ↩︎
“1948 Palestine War”, Wikipedia, February 12, 2025. ↩︎
“Avi Shlaim”, Wikipedia. ↩︎
“Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Denial of the 2023 Hamas-led attack on Israel”, Wikipedia, July 28, 2024. ↩︎
“Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Killing of Barel Hadaria Shmueli”, Wikipedia, January 22, 2022. ↩︎
“Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Free Palestine (phrase)”, Wikipedia, December 8, 2023 ↩︎
“Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Free Palestine (phrase)”, Wikipedia, December 8, 2023 ↩︎
“Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Free Palestine (phrase)”, Wikipedia, December 8, 2023 ↩︎
“Greater Palestine”, Wikipedia, January 12, 2024 ↩︎
“Talk: Greater Palestine”, Wikipedia ↩︎
“Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anti-semitic anti-Zionism”, Wikipedia, March 18, 2016 ↩︎
“Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2014 Rosh Hashanah Terror Tunnel Plot”, Wikipedia, August 4, 2014 ↩︎
“Wikipedia:Notability”, Wikipedia ↩︎
News Desk, “New report exposes systemic pro-Israel bias across eight major western media outlets”, The Cradle, November 21, 2025. ↩︎
Michael Savage, “‘Heads will roll’: BBC reckons with bias accusations over Israel and Palestine coverage”, The Guardian, June 29, 2025. ↩︎
MEE Staff, “Over 150 New York Times contributors to boycott paper over Gaza coverage”, Middle East Eye, October 27, 2025. ↩︎
Nadine Talaat, Sebastian Shehadi, and Chiri Choukeir, “We Ran the Numbers – Here’s How Britain’s Progressive Newspapers Have Covered Gaza”, Novara Media, August 1, 2024. ↩︎
“Zionist FAQs: Why do Palestinians want to destroy Israel and drive Israeli Jews into the sea?” Palestine Remembered. ↩︎
“Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Perennial sources”, Wikipedia, March 22, 2026. ↩︎
“Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Perennial sources”, Wikipedia, March 22, 2026. ↩︎
“Editing for Hate: How Anti-Israel and Anti-Jewish Bias Undermines Wikipedia’s Neutrality”, Anti-Defamation League, March 18, 2025 ↩︎
“World Arabic Language Day 2024”, UNESCO, December 18, 2024 ↩︎
“Doctrine of Hamas”, Wilson Center, October 20, 2023 ↩︎
“The Overlooked Virtue of Safeguarding the Ummah”, Muslim American Society,” July 15, 2026. ↩︎
Muḥammad ibn Ismāʿīl al-Bukhārī, Sahih al-Bukhari, Translated by Muhammad Muhsin Khan, Book 56, Hadith 107 (Hadith 2892), Sunnah.com ↩︎
Maulana Muhammad Ali, A Manual of Hadith (Lahore: Ahmadiyya Anjuman Ishaat Islam, 1944), chap. 19 ("Jihād"), sec. 2, hadith 6 ↩︎
Encyclopedia of Translated Prophetic Hadiths (HadeethEnc.com), “Hadith: Observing Ribat..” ↩︎
“Anti-Defamation League”, Wikipedia ↩︎
Asma Afsaruddin, “22 - Jihad in Islamic Thought”, The Cambridge World History of Violence, Volume 2: AD 500–AD 1500, Cambridge University Press, 13 March 2020 ↩︎
“Wikipedia:Manual of Style/Words to watch“, Wikipedia ↩︎
“Cave of the Patriarchs massacre”, Wikipedia ↩︎
“Damage Done: Wikipedia Leaves Biased Edits Unchecked Despite Editor Bans”, Anti-Defamation League, October 15, 2026 ↩︎
“Confronting Elon Musk”, Rapid Response Podcast, September 29, 2023. ↩︎
“Hamas: Difference between revisions”, Wikipedia, October 10, 2023. ↩︎
“Hamas: Difference between revisions”, Wikipedia, October 10, 2023. ↩︎
“October 7 attacks: Difference between revisions”, Wikipedia, November 21, 2023. ↩︎
“Gaza War: Difference between revisions”, Wikipedia, November 23, 2023. ↩︎
“User contributions for Renamed user c0af5c6d5769c6d5a58e1b9188e21cc2”, Wikipedia ↩︎
“How UK Media Covers the Gaza Genocide”, Newscord, 21 April 2026 ↩︎
Eric Lewis, “Israel shutting down Al Jazeera is straight out of the authoritarian playbook”, The Independent, May 15, 2024 ↩︎
“Our Martyrs”, Al Jazeera. ↩︎
Avi Shlaim, Israel and Palestine: Reappraisals, Revisions, Refutations (2009) Verso Books. ISBN 978-1-78960-165-7. ↩︎
“German support for Israel in the Gaza war: Difference between revisions”, Wikipedia, April 6, 2026. ↩︎
“October 7 attacks: Difference between revisions,” Wikipedia, November 25, 2025. ↩︎
“Sexual and gender-based violence in the October 7 attacks: Difference between revisions”,
Wikipedia, May 12, 2026. ↩︎
“User contributions for إيان”, Wikipedia. ↩︎
“October 7 attacks: Difference between revisions”, Wikipedia, June 3, 2025. ↩︎
“October 7 attacks: Difference between revisions”, Wikipedia, June 4, 2025. ↩︎
“Talk:October 7 attacks: Difference between revisions”, Wikipedia, June 4, 2025. ↩︎
“Rashid Khalidi”, Wikipedia. ↩︎
“Joseph Massad”, Wikipedia. ↩︎
“Mariam Barghouti”, Wikipedia. ↩︎
“Blockade of the Gaza Strip”, Wikipedia. ↩︎
“Gaza Strip famine”, Wikipedia. ↩︎
Assma Maad, William Audureau, and Samuel Forey, “‘40 beheaded babies’: Deconstructing the rumor at the heart of the information battle between Israel and Hamas”, Le Monde, April 3, 2024 ↩︎
“Sexual and gender-based violence in the October 7 attacks: Difference between revisions“, Wikipedia, November 8, 2025. ↩︎
“Sexual and gender-based violence in the October 7 attacks: Difference between revisions”, Wikipedia, August 26, 2025 ↩︎
“Sexual and gender-based violence in the October 7 attacks: Difference between revisions”, Wikipedia, November 8, 2025 ↩︎
“Sexual and gender-based violence in the October 7 attacks: Difference between revisions”, Wikipedia, March 8, 2025 ↩︎
Office of the Special Representative of the Secretary-General on Sexual Violence in Conflict, “Briefing by SRSG-SVC Ms. Pramila Patten to the Security Council – Findings of visit to Israel and the occupied West Bank”, United Nations, March 11, 2024 ↩︎
“Sexual and gender-based violence in the October 7 attacks: Difference between revisions”, Wikipedia, March 8, 2025 ↩︎
Office of the Special Representative of the Secretary-General on Sexual Violence in Conflict, “Briefing by SRSG-SVC Ms. Pramila Patten to the Security Council – Findings of visit to Israel and the occupied West Bank”, United Nations, March 11, 2024 ↩︎
“October 7 attacks: Difference between revisions”, Wikipedia, January 17, 2025. ↩︎
Temple Emanu-El, “Special Guest Jonathan Greenblatt”, YouTube, Recorded October 24, 2026 ↩︎
“Uncanny valley” refers to the feeling of emotional discomfort coming from computer-generated content which appears almost, but not quite, human ↩︎
“Letter to Wikimedia”, Congress of the United States, August 27, 2025 ↩︎
Aaron Bandler, “Gaming the Wiki System,” Jewish Journal, March 20, 2025
This references a dossier, no longer online, which had the 260 edits claim. ↩︎“Wikipedia:Contentious topics/Arab–Israeli conflict”, Wikipedia, October 16, 2026 ↩︎
Ashley Rindsberg, “How Soros-Backed Operatives Took Over Key Roles at Wikipedia”, Pirate Wires, January 6, 2025. ↩︎
To our knowledge, the information presented in Pirate Wires, the Jewish Journal, and Wikipedia Flood blog post. ↩︎
Ohad Merlin, “Wikipedia suspends pro-Palestine editors coordinating efforts behind the scenes”, The Jerusalem Post, December 12, 2024 ↩︎
