Contents · Israel is Attacking Wikipedia

Section 3

Direct Manipulation of Wikipedia

Israel—and its extensive propaganda movement—has, over the last twenty years, made at least seventeen publicly known efforts to directly manipulate Wikipedia. Any tweak that Israel makes to hide facts on Wikipedia improves its reputation on AI. In this section, we discuss past campaigns and efforts that have attempted to edit Wikipedia to be more aligned with Israeli narratives.

These seventeen different efforts, which we have identified through public reports, and at least nine of which are ongoing, are coordinated efforts to influence the direction of Wikipedia. These efforts have been operating openly, even promoting their efforts via mainstream media. We discuss each of the known efforts, bringing this collection together for the first time.

In this section, we only discuss direct manipulation of Wikipedia, where editors work to change the content or to remove editors. Influence attacks and organizations monitoring Wikipedia editors are discussed in Section 4.

Timeline:

3.1 JIDF (2001-2015)

The JIDF was a racist “hacktivist” group, which operated in secret beginning in 2000, and then publicly between 2008 and 2015.91 It described itself as a “collective of activists and a non-violent protest group with over 5,000 members and supporters, which seeks in its own way to counter anti-Semitic content [that] promotes terrorism online in places including [...] Wikipedia”.92

This racist group shared their views on Palestinians in an interview, in which they stated, “Palestinians should be transferred out of Israeli territories. They can live in any of the other many Arab states. We are against all land concessions to our enemies. We are against the release of terrorist prisoners from Israeli prisons”.93

According to Haaretz, “JIDF's measures ‘include reporting Wikipedia editors it claims are anti-Israel, and taking action against entries seen as including one-sided or false accounts of the history of Israel and the Mideast conflict’”.94

3.2 Israeli Government (2007)

The first documented case of Israel’s manipulation of Wikipedia stems from 2007, when an investigation traced the IP addresses associated with editors back to their sources.95 As a result, “A computer linked to the Israeli government twice tried to delete an entire article about the West Bank wall that was critical of the policy. An edit from the same address also modified the entry for Hezbollah describing all its operations as being ‘mostly military in nature’”.

3.3 CAMERA (2008)

The Committee for Accuracy on Middle East Reporting in America (CAMERA), an organization which attacks reporting perceived to criticize Israel, and which CAIR describes as promoting anti-Muslim and anti-Palestinian narratives,96 was revealed to be manipulating Wikipedia in a story first broken on April 21, 2008 by the Electronic Intifada (EI).97

They revealed that CAMERA was undertaking a secretive and coordinated campaign to recruit editors to infiltrate Wikipedia to manipulate topics relating to Israel, after the outlet obtained a series of emails sent by CAMERA senior research analyst Gilead Ini and others in which their plans were exposed.

These documents explain that CAMERA carefully encouraged the editors it recruited to disguise their activity by first editing other topics, selecting an innocuous username, and weaponizing Wikipedia’s own policies when making edits, all while seeding anti-Palestinian racism.

In an email on March 17th, Gilead Ini shares specific advice on how pro-Israel propaganda or opinion might be passed off as fact in a way that meets Wikipedia’s strict guidelines. The email reads:

“So, for example, imagine that you get rid of or modify a problematic sentence in an article alleging that ‘Palestinian [sic] become suicide bombers to respond to Israel’s oppressive policies.’ You should, in parallel, leave a comment on that article’s discussion page (either after or before making the change). Avoid defending the edit by arguing that ‘Israel’s policies aren’t ‘oppression,’ they are defensive. And anyway Palestinians obviously become suicide bombers for other reasons for example hate education!’ Instead, describe how this sentence violates Wikipedia’s policies and guidelines. One of the core policies is that assertions should adhere to a Neutral Point of View, usually abbreviated NPOV. (The opposite of NPOV is POV, or Point of View, which is basically another way of saying subjective statement, or opinion.) So it would be best to note on the discussion page that “This sentence violates Wikipedia’s NPOV policy, since the description of Israel’s policies as ‘oppressive’ is an opinion. In addition, it is often noted by Middle East experts that one of the reasons Palestinians decide to become suicide bombers is hate education and glorification of martyrdom in Palestinian society…’”

The campaign’s long-term goal was to enlist editors who would avoid topics related to Palestine and Israel altogether, instead building up credibility by editing other topics until they could be elected as administrators, at which time they would be able to exert greater influence on editing other topics to support Zionist ideology.

Another email from Ini, this time quoted in a May 2008 article from The American Prospect, demonstrates the intent to keep the operation secret.98 The email reads, “Please forward this alert to people committed to fair and factual reporting about Israel and the Middle East…Do not forward it to members of the news media”.

Wikipedia’s administrators quickly responded to the news of CAMERA’s campaign by banning Zeq—an editor who had worked closely with the pro-Israel group to develop their tactics to subvert the online encyclopedia’s rules—from editing any pages related to Palestine and Israel. Ini shut down the off-Wiki group chat shortly thereafter, explicitly citing the leak to the Electronic Intifada.99

3.4 Yesha Council (2010)

In 2010, a series of courses on becoming a Wikipedia editor were launched by the Yesha Council and Israel Sheli (“My Israel”), two organizations deeply entrenched in the Israeli settler takeover of the West Bank.100 In a report from Israel National News, Naftali Bennett—who was director of the Yesha Council at the time and later became the Prime Minister of Israel—made the purpose of these courses explicitly clear.101 He says,

“The goal of the day is to teach people how to edit in Wikipedia, which is the number 1 source of information in the world. As way of example, if someone searches the Gaza flotilla,102 we wanna be there. We wanna be the guys who influence what is written there, how it’s written, and to ensure that it’s balanced and Zionist in nature.”

Prospective editors who attended these classes would have an opportunity to contribute to Israel’s narrative. According to a report from Haaretz published on August 18, 2010, “The Yesha Council also announced a prize for the ‘Best Zionist Editor’—the person who over the next four years incorporates the most ‘Zionist’ changes in the encyclopedia. That lucky encyclopedist would receive a trip in a hot-air balloon over Israel”.103

This implies the Yesha Council was intending to recruit editors into long-term volunteer careers as defenders of Zionism on Wikipedia, in direct violation of multiple Wikipedia policies.

While this campaign to manipulate the open-source encyclopedia received more attention publicly, it appears that it sparked very little direct action from Wikipedia. A separate campaign by the Yesha council to manipulate Wikipedia was discovered in 2024 and is detailed in Section 3.14.

3.5 Kohelet Policy Forum (2013–ongoing)

In July 2023, when Israel was in the midst of widespread civil unrest due to attempts to overhaul the judiciary, a Haaretz report revealed that Israel’s Wikipedia manipulations had continued.104 It claimed that the Kohelet Policy Forum, a right-wing, U.S.-funded Israeli think tank,105 “has long employed writers to edit Wikipedia entries on its behalf” on Hebrew Wikipedia, going back to 2013.106

While the report is careful to state that these editors disclose their activity in accordance with the platform’s policies, editors were presumably paid to manipulate Wikipedia to conform to Kohelet’s extreme right-wing views.

Haaretz also reveals that one of those paid editors was creating sockpuppet accounts to unduly influence consensus decisions, a flagrant violation of Wikipedia’s rules. These sockpuppets were created in 2023, showing over a decade of manipulating Wikipedia, and indicating this behaviour likely continues.

3.6 National Library of Israel (2012–ongoing)

The National Library of Israel operates a partnership with Wikimedia Israel to teach Israelis how to edit Wikipedia.107 These teaching sessions run for two hours on the first Friday of the month, and have been running since 2012.108

In most countries, a library running a Wikipedia editing course would be benign, and even positive. However, Israeli participation in editing Wikipedia must be understood within the context of Israel’s 78-year occupation of Palestine, in which mandatory conscription means that a majority of Israelis have personally participated in the occupation.

In this context, any initiative taken by Wikimedia Israel to contribute to Wikipedia should be considered an extension of Israeli propaganda.

3.7 NGO Monitor (2013)

Soosim, an editor identified as Arnie Draiman, was indefinitely banned in June 2013.109 Soosim was an employee of pro-Israel group NGO Monitor, an organization which works to criticize and delegitimize NGOs critical of Israel. Soosim’s editing history reveals hundreds of edits to organizations that are criticized by NGO Monitor, and 91 edits of the NGO Monitor page itself.110 He is also alleged to have used a sockpuppet account.

Additionally, it was claimed that NGO Monitor laundered claims into Wikipedia. According to a report in The Signpost, Wikipedia’s internal media, editor Nomoskedasticity claimed that NGO Monitor would publish a claim, it would be reported by news media, and then that news article would be cited on Wikipedia:111

“The writer who complained about Soosim (user name Nomoskedasticity) also wrote that NGO Monitor has the custom of issuing a press release, waiting until it is quoted in a newspaper, and then quoting the news item in the relevant articles as fact. During the conversation, it turned out that Draiman even explained this during a workshop he gave on Israel advocacy in which he called on pro-Israel advocates to join the "wiki war."”

- The Signpost: “Partisan editing of Israel topics”, 19 June 2013112

3.8 The Israel Group (2015*–2021)

The Israel Group is a U.S.-based non-profit founded by a former Israeli soldier. They announced in 2019 a program called Wiki-Israel, which it had been working on “for many years” (we conservatively used 2015 in our timeline). The program’s intention was to dox what it referred to as “anti-Israel” editors on Wikipedia,113 following up on this claim by doxing two Wikipedia editors in 2020.

Speaking to the Washington Free Beacon—later known for alleging plagiarism against then-Harvard President Claudine Gay114—the Israel Group claimed that it “has been working for many years, under the radar, on a confidential initiative, Wiki-Israel, that combats Wikipedia's antisemitic bias against Israel”.115

David Swindle, a former employee of Israel Group, describes spending “20 hours a week” on Wikipedia, and says the group considered lawsuits, and doxxing editors.116

The Israel Group website refers to it as “Energizing Zionists”, and contains lists of editors and articles that the Israel Group believes are anti-Israel. Its analysis and claims are very similar to the ADL report discussed in Section 6. The founder of the Israel Group died in 2021,117 and it appears the site has been unmaintained since then.

3.9 Anti-Defamation League (2021)

The ADL itself has also been criticized for coordinating Wikipedia edits in violation of site rules. According to reports, the ADL hired an experienced editor to train staffers on how to incorporate ADL sources into various articles. Nine staffers then subsequently made 261 edits across 34 articles, which added more than 9,000 words that focused on the ADL’s own research into domestic extremism.118

3.10 Wikipedia Command Center (2023–ongoing)

In October 2023, Wikipedia editors noticed a WhatsApp group that was announced to “fight against anti-Israel bias”.119 This group was announced on Hebrew Wikipedia, and promoted on the Hebrew Wikipedia Facebook Group. It was described as a private coordination hub for pro-Israel editing, and was criticized for violating the Wikipedia policies WP:CANVASS, WP:MEATPUPPET, and WP:NPOV.

According to the announcement, this group was run by Dr. Shlomit Lir, a researcher from the gender studies program in the Bar Ilan University.120 Dr. Lir is the author of multiple articles and reports sharing her beliefs about Wikipedia being manipulated by anti-Israel editors. These reports, entitled “Manipulated History: Past Version vs. Present Subversion – The Growing Bias Against Israel on Wikipedia”, and “The bias against Israel on Wikipedia”, were published by the World Jewish Congress, a pro-Israel advocacy organization.

The Signpost, Wikipedia’s internal newsletter, reported comments from Lauren Dickinson from the Wikimedia Foundation's Communications Department, saying that ‘several staff had reviewed the [report], and found that “the WJC report makes a number of unsubstantiated claims of bias on Wikipedia.121 It lacks adequate references, quotes, links, or other sources to support its purported findings. Further, the report misunderstands Wikipedia's NPOV policy, as well as the importance of anonymity for user privacy on Wikimedia projects.”’

The announcement of the “Wikipedia Command Center” (above) can be translated as:

“To join the fight on this front, Shlomit Lir established a WhatsApp group to coordinate activity. Here is her invitation to join: As is known, public diplomacy (Hasbara) is a central tool in the fight for victory and justice. Following biases and distortions in many articles on English Wikipedia regarding the war against Hamas, we have opened a ‘Wikipedia war room’ (command center). It is intended for editors on the site and those who wish to alert about articles that need to be corrected. You can join through the link:”

Despite rallying against claimed manipulation of Wikipedia, it appears as though Dr. Lir is herself running a coordinated effort to manipulate Wikipedia. The post inviting users to join her group describes this as an invitation to participate in “Hasbara” (הסברה—Israeli propaganda) in a “Wikipedia War Room” (חמ"ל—a Hebrew military acronym) for editors to “coordinate” on pages that “need to be corrected”.

In February 2025, Lir was given a warning for canvassing and POV violations.122

3.11 BrightMind (2023–ongoing)

BrightMind is an organization founded “to strengthen the Israeli narrative on social networks and fight fake news”. It was founded in 2023 by content creator Ella Kenan, who spent seven years in the Israeli Intelligence Corps, part of the Israeli military’s Directorate of Military Intelligence.

In detailing the work of Ella Kenan and BrightMind, Kenan brags about her success influencing the founder of Wikipedia himself:

“Some of them changed Jerusalem to a city in the southern Levant, not the capital of Israel. The founder of Wikipedia went in and corrected it himself. The next day, a pro-Palestinian organization deleted it, so he took on the matter and fixed it from within the system. This means that our influence is measurable. The size of our communities and our critical mass has enabled us to delete thousands of fake content items. Organizations issued apologies and changed narratives online because of the pressure we exerted.”123

According to Kenan, the influence they have amassed has allowed their organization to “delete thousands of fake content items”, and has led to “changed narratives online because of the pressure we exerted”.

3.12 Pro-Israel editor collusion campaign (2024)

In 2025, reports from Bloomberg revealed a coordinated pro-Israel campaign. According to Bloomberg, “an editor who had been kicked off the website” emailed others, directing them to amend pages regarding Gaza, including articles pertaining to crimes against Israel, the use of human shields, and the 2001 Beit Rima raid in the West Bank.124

Another editor urged colleagues who work on PIA (Palestine-Israel Articles) pages “to vote against an article that referred to the war in the Gaza Strip as a ‘genocide’ started by Israel”, calling the page’s editors “propagandists” and the article “ridiculous”.125 These actions resulted in three pro-Israel editors being banned for coordination off of Wikipedia.

3.13 4IL (2024–ongoing)

In September 2024, 4IL, an Israeli government-backed digital advocacy initiative126 operated by the Ministry of Diaspora Affairs and Combating Antisemitism, shared a post on Instagram asking their followers to report Wikipedia pages they view as inaccurate, biased, or containing misinformation.127

4IL previously created Act.IL, an app that sent Israelis on digital “missions” to participate in propaganda online.128 The app was criticized for being a way of disseminating Israel-aligned propaganda without having Israel’s name on it.129 The app was shut down in 2022 due to shifts in social media consumption, and 4IL now instead operates a number of WhatsApp and Telegram groups in English and Hebrew.130

3.14 Yesha Council (2024-ongoing)

The Yesha Council, the coalition of illegal settler groups, which ran Wikipedia manipulation courses in 2010 under Naftali Bennett, was found in January 2024 to be once again creating programs to manipulate Wikipedia.131

A rough translation reads “Therefore, to expand the circle of Zionist editors, we partnered with Eran, a senior Wikipedia editor who, together with Zionist editors, trains and mentors new editors on Wikipedia”. This call is signed off by Shira Liebman, the Director of the Yesha Council.

3.15 National Vision (2024-ongoing)

National Vision (Hazon Leumi), an Israeli non-profit founded by hard-right MK Ariel Kallner, started a course to “Come influence” Wikipedia in August 2024.132

The announcement text reads, “The course is intended for anyone interested in writing, sharing knowledge, and influencing”.133 The course appeared to still be running as of mid-2025.

3.16 Jimmy Wales (2025-ongoing)

Jimmy Wales founded Wikipedia, and sits on the Wikimedia Foundation Board of Trustees.134 He has also claimed to be extremely biased towards Israel, and has intervened to manipulate Wikipedia to support his pro-Israel viewpoints.

Wales has called himself a “strong supporter of Israel”, and has visited Israel over ten times.135 He also received a prize of $900,000 from the Israeli Dan David Foundation, by far the largest award we can find which has been given to Wales.136

In 2025, Wales attempted to use his influence to change a Wikipedia page’s content in a pro-Israel direction, saying “At present, the lede and the overall presentation state, in Wikipedia’s voice, that Israel is committing genocide, although that claim is highly contested”, which “requires immediate correction” and that the relevant policy was “non-negotiable”.137

3.16.1 Wales’ post

The full content of Wales’ post138 reads:

“This message is from me, Jimbo Wales, co-founder of Wikipedia.

I believe that Wikipedia is at its best when we can have reasonable discussion rooted in a commitment to write articles that reflect a neutral point of view. I believe that's especially important on highly difficult or contentious topics.

I was asked point-blank in a high profile media interview about this article, and I answered with transparency and honesty: this article fails to meet our high standards and needs immediate attention.

As many of you will know, I have been leading an NPOV working group and studying the issue of neutrality in Wikipedia across many articles and topic areas including “Zionism”. While this article is a particularly egregious example, there is much more work to do. It should go without saying that I am writing this in my personal capacity, and I am not speaking on behalf of the Wikimedia Foundation or anyone else!

I assume good faith of everyone who has worked on this Gaza “genocide” article. At present, the lede and the overall presentation state, in Wikipedia’s voice, that Israel is committing genocide, although that claim is highly contested. This is a violation of WP:NPOV and WP:ATTRIBUTEPOV that requires immediate correction. Remember: "This policy is non-negotiable, and the principles upon which it is based cannot be superseded by other policies or guidelines, nor by editor consensus."

A neutral approach would begin with a formulation such as: “Multiple governments, NGOs, and legal bodies have described or rejected the characterization of Israel’s actions in Gaza as genocide.”

What I’m asking for

Be bold and start editing (WP:BOLD). Move from debate to concrete improvements immediately.

Assume good faith (WP:AGF). Avoid personalizing disagreements. Focus only on text and sources.

Attribute, don’t assert (WP:ATTRIBUTEPOV). The lead and body must not declare a legal conclusion. Present who says what, with attribution and dates.

Balance by due weight (WP:UNDUE). Include significant, high-quality sources from all sides—governments, courts, NGOs, commentators. No side should speak in Wikipedia’s own voice.

Use the best sources (WP:RS / WP:V). Prefer primary official statements and major secondary coverage. Avoid synthesis (WP:SYN / WP:NOR).

Clarify scope. Separate factual reporting on conduct and casualties from legal characterization. Editors with strong, policy-compliant sources who have felt sidelined are welcome. Your participation is needed now. Editors are reminded this article falls under the Arab–Israeli conflict topic area; all participation must comply with the corresponding editing restrictions and civility expectations.

By focusing on verifiable sources and neutrality, we can quickly deliver an article that meets our standards for contentious topics.”

- “Statement from Jimmy Wales” in Talk:Gaza genocide/Archive 22

3.16.2 Responses

Editor “Hemiauchenia” described Wales’ statement as “patronising” and accused Wales of “seeking to unfairly equate the opinion of impartial organisations with those of partial or political ones”.139 Hemiauchenia rightly asked why Wikipedia should consider the “opinions of the largely impartial UN and human rights scholars” as “weighed equally to the obviously partisan opinions of commentators and governments?” They continued, stating,

“You are allowed to disagree with the consensus of the Wikipedia community, but it is patronising to scorn the community as being ‘wrong’ for following the opinions of the UN, genocide scholars and major human rights organisations”.140

Wales responded to this stating that an editor’s job involves “not to take sides”, but to “carefully and neutrally document it”.141 Editor “Cortador” responded to Wales, saying “Wikipedia has never, ever treated all voices as equal, nor does policy demand we do. If we did, the Earth article would state that Earth’s shape is under debate. But we don’t do that because scholarly consensus is that Earth is roughly spherical”.142

3.16.3 Influence

As well as being founder of Wikipedia, Wales is a member of the Board of Trustees of Wikimedia Foundation, one who admits he holds strong, biased views in support of Israel. For both those reasons, he should not have taken part in that discussion.

At the time of the incident, he was also lead of a working group on the Neutral Point of View, creating a baseline NPOV policy that could be adopted by multiple Wikipedia language groups.143

Though Wales claims he was acting in a personal capacity, his actions do not match that. He starts by asserting his authority as “co-founder of Wikipedia”. He continues by adding pressure by highlighting a “high profile media interview” in which he was asked about the article, and he followed by saying the article “needs immediate attention”.

He further cited his authority on the topic by saying ‘I have been leading an NPOV working group and studying the issue of neutrality in Wikipedia across many articles and topic areas including “Zionism”’.

Only then does he say he is writing in his personal capacity.

He goes on to say that the article needs “immediate correction”, and quotes “This policy is non-negotiable”. He then suggests new wording that he would prefer.

3.16.4 Abuse of Power

To clarify, this is an abuse of power, leveraged to change content of an important Wikipedia page to take a pro-Israel slant.

One of the most influential people on Wikipedia begins by asserting his influence in multiple ways, then demands specific changes to a page based on his biases, despite significant work by Wikipedia editors to discuss and come to consensus on the topic.144 He amplified the importance by citing a “high profile media interview”, and charged the debate by demanding it be changed with high priority.

In addition, the idea that a founder, senior leader, and Board Trustee of an organization can speak without authority is laughable. If Wales had wanted to simply bring up the point, he could have done it anonymously. Instead, he started by asserting who he was, just in case his username was not known to readers.

As a member of the Board of Trustees, his aggressive attempt to change Wikipedia content on the basis of his personal opinion violates the Abuse of Power section of Wikimedia Foundation’s Universal Code of Conduct (section 3.2).145

It further violates the Code of Conduct of the Wikimedia Foundation Board of Trustees, Section 4,146 which states:

The Foundation recognizes as bullying behavior that may be characterized as offensive, intimidating, malicious or insulting, or an abuse or misuse of power through means intended to undermine, humiliate, denigrate or injure the recipient. Bullying does not need to be deliberate; someone may demonstrate bullying behavior without intending to. Whichever form it takes, it is unwarranted and unwelcome to the individual and will often cause embarrassment, fear, humiliation or distress to an individual or group of individuals. Bullying often results from a misuse of individual power derived from status/position, physical strength or force of personality. It can also arise from collective power arising out of strength of numbers.

- Code of Conduct of the Wikimedia Foundation Board of Trustees, Section 4, “Respect & Fairness” (emphasis ours)

Indeed, it also contradicts the Wikimedia Foundation’s response to the letter from Ted Cruz which we discuss in Section 4.4. Cruz asked “what supervision, oversight, or influence, if any, the Wikimedia Foundation has over the editing community”,147 to which the Foundation responded “The Wikimedia Foundation provides technology and legal support but does not write or control the content on Wikipedia—volunteer editors do”.148

We refer to this as “ongoing”, as Wales has not apologized, backed-down, or indicated that he would not repeat the behaviour. In subsequent interviews, he reiterated his approach, saying “I'm going to make my case as best I can”.149 When asked how he felt about the editors who had built a consensus, he stated “Yeah, I think they’re wrong”.150

In Section 7.1.6, we recommend Jimmy Wales step down for his abuse of power.

3.16.5 Continued pro-Israel actions in Zionism page

In fact, Wales’ pro-Israel advocacy on Wikipedia continued in November 2026. An article was published by Quillette, a right-wing, pro-Israel magazine, which is determined to be “unreliable” by Wikipedia.151

Nevertheless, Wales started a conversation leveraging the biased pro-Israel article, “asking that the tag be restored to acknowledge that the neutrality of this article has been disputed”.152

The Zionism page on Wikipedia is a key propaganda target for Israel. We found dozens of articles in Israeli media and society discussing it, along with the ADL’s repeated attacks on it. As we discussed in Section 6.3.4.5.6, the classification of Zionism is extremely well supported, and Wales’ attacks on it are an affront to the Wikipedia community who has spent considerable time and effort debating this article.

Wales’ actions here further show he is incapable of being unbiased, and further support our recommendation, in Section 7.1.6, that Wales should step down from the Wikimedia Board of Trustees, and disable his Wikipedia account.

3.16.6 Further Biased edits

In Section 3.11, we include a quote from Ella Kenan, describing how her organization influenced a founder of Wikipedia to take action on their behalf:

“Some of them changed Jerusalem to a city in the southern Levant, not the capital of Israel. The founder of Wikipedia went in and corrected it himself. The next day, a pro-Palestinian organization deleted it, so he took on the matter and fixed it from within the system.”

A campaign from an Israeli influence company got Jimmy Wales to intervene in a dispute about Israel. In the dispute, Wales showed both his biases and his lack of knowledge about the conflict, seemingly unaware of the international dispute over the status and location of Jerusalem, despite it being heavily documented in the Jerusalem Wikipedia article at the time:

“Both the State of Israel and the State of Palestine claim Jerusalem as their capital city. Israel maintains its primary governmental institutions there, and the State of Palestine ultimately foresees it as its seat of power. Neither claim is widely recognized internationally.”153

Wales’ biased and uneducated comments:

“:It's very much worth noting that the idea that the status is disputed does not extend to where Jerusalem is actually located. It is located in Israel. There is of course a well-known controversy about the question of it's recognition internationally as the capital of Israel, but that's not about where it is located. As noted by Schazjmd, we use the construct "Jerusalem, Israel" all over the place, which is 100% correct becuase that's where Jerusalem is.”154

- Jimmy Wales’ comment from February 5, 2025 (emphasis ours)

“::This comment fails to assume good faith, and I don't know why you made it. Do you have any policy based arguments? Jerusalem is, indisputably, in Israel, that's where it is physically located. I haven't solved any of the very real controversies nor attempted to. My point is that none of those controversies has any place in this article, since it's a very simple fact. If you want to fight about Israel and Palestine, please go do it somewhere else”155

- Jimmy Wales’ comment from February 5, 2025 (emphasis ours)

For reference, East Jerusalem and West Jerusalem are on different sides of the Green Line, and widely regarded as the capitals of Palestine and Israel, respectively. East Jerusalem is widely recognized to be in Occupied Palestinian territory, while West Jerusalem is widely recognized to be part of Israel.156

Ironically, Natalie Portman, whose birthplace was the subject of the controversy, was born in the Hadassah Mount Scopus hospital, which is an Israeli enclave located in East Jerusalem, east of the Green Line.157

3.17 “Wikipedia Lobby Group” (2024-ongoing)

Wikipedia editors have noted the existence of several groups looking to push a pro-Israel point-of-view.158 We have documented these groups in these sections, except the “Wikipedia Lobby Group”, which we were not able to identify or find further information about.

Notes

  1. “Jewish Internet Defense Force”, Wikipedia, January 31, 2026. ↩︎

  2. Benjamin Hartman, “GA special feature / An online battle for Israel’s legitimacy”, Haaretz, November 14, 2008 ↩︎

  3. Brian Cuban, “Inside the Jewish Internet Defense Force”, The Cuban Revolution, July 29, 2008 ↩︎

  4. Benjamin Hartman, “GA special feature / An online battle for Israel’s legitimacy”, Haaretz, November 14, 2008 ↩︎

  5. “Wikipedia and the art of censorship”, Belfast Telegraph, August 18, 2007 ↩︎

  6. Council on American-Islamic Relations, “Committee for Accuracy in Middle East Reporting”, Islamophobia.org, August 24, 2023 ↩︎

  7. “EI exclusive: a pro-Israel group’s plan to rewrite history on Wikipedia”, The Electronic Intifada, April 21, 2008 ↩︎

  8. Gershom Gorenberg, “The Mideast Editing Wars”, The American Prospect, May 1, 2008. ↩︎

  9. The original PDFs are no longer available on Electronic Intifada’s site, but they are still available on the Internet Archive, see the following:

    “Wikipedia and CAMERA”

    “[Isra-pedia] Re: Welcome to the Discussions Pages” ↩︎

  10. Rachel Shabi and Jemima Kiss, “Wikipedia editing courses launched by Zionist groups”, The Guardian, August 18, 2010 ↩︎

  11. “Course: Zionist Editing on Wikipedia”, YouTube Video, 2:03, August 18, 2010 ↩︎

  12. The “Gaza flotilla” refers to a fleet of six civilian ships that attempted to break Israel’s siege of Gaza in order to deliver aid to Palestinians in mid-2010. The flotilla was raided by the Israeli military on May 30-31, 2010, while still in international waters, killing nine activists and injuring dozens more

    “Gaza Freedom Flotilla”, Wikipedia ↩︎

  13. Nir Hasson, “The Right’s Latest Weapon: ‘Zionist Editing’ on Wikipedia”, Haaretz, August 18, 2010. ↩︎

  14. Omer Benjakob, “Fake Wikipedia Accounts: Conservative Israeli Think Tank Behind Skewed Judicial Overhaul Articles”, Haaretz, July 18, 2023 ↩︎

  15. “Spotlight on the Kohelet Policy Forum: How a Right-Wing, US-Funded Israeli Think Tank Is Shaping Policy and Law”, Jewish Currents, April 4, 2023 ↩︎

  16. “Talk: Kohelet Forum”, Wikipedia, May 23, 2013 ↩︎

  17. “Wikipedia at NLI: Become a Wikipedia Editor!”, The National Library of Israel ↩︎

  18. Orly Simon, Dr. Ahava Cohen, Gea Zohar, “The National Library of Israel's Engagement with Wikimedia Projects: Enriching Free Knowledge”, 2025 ↩︎

  19. Oded Yaron, “Aligning Text to the Right: Is a Political Organization Editing Wikipedia to Suit Its Interests?”, Haaretz, June 17, 2013 ↩︎

  20. Go Phightins!, Andreas Kolbe, and Emily Temple-Wood, “South African learners want Wikipedia; Editing of Israel topics”, The Signpost, June 19, 2013 ↩︎

  21. Go Phightins!, Andreas Kolbe, and Emily Temple-Wood, “South African learners want Wikipedia; Editing of Israel topics”, The Signpost, June 19, 2013 ↩︎

  22. Go Phightins!, Andreas Kolbe, and Emily Temple-Wood, “South African learners want Wikipedia; Editing of Israel topics”, The Signpost, June 19, 2013 ↩︎

  23. David Israel, “The Israel Group Launches Battle to Expose Anti-Israel Wikipedia Editors”, The Jewish Press, November 21, 2019. ↩︎

  24. Meredith Deliso, “A timeline of Harvard President Claudine Gay’s short, scandal-plagued tenure”, ABC News, January 2, 2024 ↩︎

  25. Adam Kredo, “Wikipedia’s Anti-Israel Editors Unmasked”, The Washington Free Beacon, November 20, 2019 ↩︎

  26. Boaz Hepner, "Chosen Links by Boaz" - Ep 12 Wikipedia's War on Truth: The Fight Against Bias Toward Israel”, Youtube, Recorded February 19, 2025 ↩︎

  27. “Jack Saltzberg, President and Founder of The Israel Group, Passes Away at 62”, Jewish Journal, August 16, 2021 ↩︎

  28. Arno Rosenfeld, “ADL may have violated Wikipedia rules — editing its own entries”, The Forward, April 8, 2021 ↩︎

  29. “Wikipedia Command Center”, Wikipedia, October 12, 2024 ↩︎

  30. “Wikipedia (Worldwide) as a Propaganda Tool”, Wikipedia, October 15, 2024 ↩︎

  31. “Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/2024-03-29/Special report”, Wikipedia, May 16, 2024 ↩︎

  32. Vanamonde93, “Arbitration enforcement log/2025: warning concerning Shlomit Lir”, Wikipedia, February 5, 2025 ↩︎

  33. Galit Hatan, “A fighter of fake news about Israel”, Globes, April 1, 2025. ↩︎

  34. Margi Murphy, “‘Edit Wars’ on Middle East Page Raise Tensions on Wikipedia”, Bloomberg, March 7, 2025 ↩︎

  35. Margi Murphy, “‘Edit Wars’ on Middle East Page Raise Tensions on Wikipedia”, Bloomberg, March 7, 2025 ↩︎

  36. David Kaye, Clement Nyaletsossi Voule, Michel Forst, and Michael Lynk, “Communication AL ISR 12/2019”, United Nations Special Procedures, August 28, 2019 ↩︎

  37. 4IL (@4ilorg), “Frustrated with inaccuracies, misinformation, and biased content about Israel on Wikipedia?”, Instagram, September 16, 2024 ↩︎

  38. “Act-IL Initiative”, The Abba Eban Institute for Diplomacy & Foreign Relations. ↩︎

  39. Natasha Soffer-Roth, “Mission failed: How Israel’s anti-BDS app went belly-up”, +972 Magazine, April 25, 2022. ↩︎

  40. Michael Arria, “Israel pulls the plug on its anti-BDS app — ‘a failure from the start’,” Mondoweiss, March 11, 2022. ↩︎

  41. X Post, Gil Feldman (@feldman_gil), January 28, 2024 ↩︎

  42. “Zionist Horizon”, August 19, 2024. ↩︎

  43. Uri Blau, “‘A Failure by Every Conceivable Parameter’: The Government’s Campaign Against the Global Delegitimization of Israel”, Shomrim: The Center for Media and Democracy, October 31, 2024 ↩︎

  44. Wikimedia Foundation Board of Trustees, “Renewing Jimmy Wales’s appointment to the Board of Trustees, 2024”, Wikimedia Foundation Governance Wiki, June 20, 2024 ↩︎

  45. Ben Sales, “In Tel Aviv, Wikipedia founder Jimmy Wales likes Israel but stays neutral”, Jewish Telegraphic Agency, May 18, 2015 ↩︎

  46. Tel Aviv University, “2015 Dan David Winners Announced”, Tel Aviv University, February 11, 2015 ↩︎

  47. Jimmy Wales (Jimbo Wales), “Statement from Jimbo Wales”, Wikipedia, Talk:Gaza genocide/Archive 22, November 2, 2025 ↩︎

  48. Jimmy Wales (Jimbo Wales), “Statement from Jimbo Wales”, Wikipedia, Talk:Gaza genocide/Archive 22, November 2, 2025 ↩︎

  49. Edna Mohamed and News Agencies, “Why did Wikipedia editor block edits to the ‘Gaza genocide’ page?”, Al Jazeera, 4 Nov 2025 ↩︎

  50. Hemiauchenia, “Statement from Jimbo Wales” (comment), Wikipedia, Talk:Gaza genocide/Archive 22, November 2, 2025 ↩︎

  51. Jimmy Wales (Jimbo Wales), “Statement from Jimbo Wales”, Wikipedia, Talk:Gaza genocide/Archive 22, November 2, 2025 ↩︎

  52. Cortador, “Statement from Jimbo Wales” (reply to Wales), Wikipedia, Talk:Gaza genocide/Archive 22, November 2, 2025 ↩︎

  53. Wikimedia Foundation Annual Plan 2025–2026, “Common global standards for NPOV policies”, Wikimedia Foundation, July 2025 ↩︎

  54. Beland, “RfC on first sentence”, Wikipedia, Talk:Gaza genocide/Archive 12, September 21, 2025 ↩︎

  55. Wikimedia Foundation, “Wikimedia Foundation Universal Code of Conduct”, Wikimedia Foundation Governance Wiki, March 30, 2024 ↩︎

  56. Wikimedia Foundation Board of Trustees, “Code of Conduct of the Wikimedia Foundation Board of Trustees”, October 4, 2025 ↩︎

  57. Ted Cruz, “Letter to Maryana Iskander, Chief Executive Officer, Wikimedia Foundation”, United States Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation, October 3, 2025 ↩︎

  58. Wikimedia Foundation, “Wikimedia Foundation responds to questions about how Wikipedia works”, Wikimedia Foundation, October 10, 2025 ↩︎

  59. Brian Lehrer, interview with Jimmy Wales, “Wikipedia Founder on Building Trust”, The Brian Lehrer Show, WNYC, December 11, 2025 ↩︎

  60. Josh Dzieza, “Jimmy Wales trusts the process”, The Verge, December 17, 2025 ↩︎

  61. “Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Perennial sources/all/Quillette”, Wikipedia, August 5, 2026 ↩︎

  62. “NPOV issues in this article”, Wikipedia, November 1, 2026 ↩︎

  63. “Jerusalem”, Wikipedia, February 4, 2025 ↩︎

  64. “Talk:Natalie Portman: Difference between revisions”, Wikipedia, February 5, 2025 ↩︎

  65. “Talk:Natalie Portman: Difference between revisions”, Wikipedia, February 5, 2025 ↩︎

  66. “Status of Jerusalem”, Wikipedia, November 1, 2026 ↩︎

  67. “Hadassah Medical Center”, Wikipedia, October 26, 2026 ↩︎

  68. MarioGom, “Wikipedia Command Center”, Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Israel/Archive 6, May 2, 2024 ↩︎

Become a T4P member

Tech for Palestine is a member-driven organization that brings together people, skills and resources. Through technology and collaboration, our members build tools and solutions that support the movement for Palestine.

These projects include: protest apps, tools for boycotting, support for Palestinian students & businesses, ethical tech alternatives, and many more.