Section 2
Why is Israel attacking Wikipedia?
For 20 years, Israel has attempted to manipulate Wikipedia, a common place for people to learn about Israel’s horrific occupation, apartheid, and genocide in Palestine. Israel frequently leverages propaganda, which it calls “Hasbara”, in order to influence public opinion.
Today, Wikipedia forms the basis of training of AI platforms, such as ChatGPT, Claude, and Thaura. Manipulating Wikipedia’s content on Israel and Palestine allows Israel to change not just Wikipedia’s information, but AI platforms’ perception and responses.
Section 2.1 provides historical context for why Israel needs narrative control, and introduces “Hasbara” and Zionism. Section 2.2 connects Israel’s propaganda to Wikipedia and AI. In Section 2.3, we outline the tools of Israeli propaganda, including weaponized language and definitions related to antisemitism, and the “pro-Hamas” label, which provide background for later discussion.
2.1 Why Israel requires narrative control
Israel is a new country, one that was formed by mass migration to Palestine in the early- to mid-20th century. The colonization of Palestine by the settlers was brutal, with thousands murdered by Jewish settler paramilitaries, including dozens of villages depopulated, and mass ethnic-cleansing campaigns to remove Palestinians from their homes of thousands of years.
Since then, Israel has violently and illegally occupied Palestine, brutally operating systems of land-stealing, starvation, stripping Palestinians of their human rights, economic suppression, and murder. These have culminated in Israel’s internationally recognized genocide in Gaza, which began with Israel’s invasion in October 2023.3
Rather than address its crimes against humanity and move towards equal rights for all, Israel has treated its reputation in the West as something to be solved through propaganda. Since its founding, Israel has led an extended influence campaign across the West, to support pro-Israel narratives and to shut down conversation about Palestinian rights. “Hasbara”, the Israeli word for pro-Israel propaganda, is frequently employed to insert and assert narrative control.
The purpose of Hasbara is to improve Israel’s reputation without changing its policies, and to allow it to continue its internationally-recognized crimes against the Palestinian people (as well as crimes in other areas they have illegally occupied, such as in south Lebanon and in the Golan Heights in Syria).
2.1.1 Historical Context
Israel was founded in 1948 after hundreds of thousands of European Jews migrated to Palestine as part of the “Zionist” movement, with the explicit goal of creating a Jewish state in Palestine.

Headline from the New York Times, from June 20, 1899. The headline reads “CONFERENCE OF ZIONISTS; Elect Delegates at Their Meeting in Baltimore; WILL COLONIZE PALESTINE”.4
Through mass migration, Zionists increased the Jewish population from 84,000 in 1922 (11% of the population) to 650,000 (31.5% of the population) in 1948. At this time, the non-Jewish Arab population of Palestine was 1.4 million people.
In 1948, Jewish gangs and paramilitaries executed the “Nakba”, the violent ethnic cleansing of Palestinians from Palestine, in which 750,000 people were forced to flee from their homes and villages.5 These gangs and paramilitaries committed dozens of massacres—including at Deir Yassin, where more than 100 residents were executed by Jewish paramilitaries—ethnically cleansing Palestinians, clearing out hundreds of villages and towns. Israel then declared independence over the newly ethnically-cleansed land.6
Since 1948, systematic massacres of Palestinians have been carried out repeatedly by Israeli forces including the Israeli Military and by violent settlers, with hundreds or thousands of deaths occurring in certain years. In Gaza alone, more than 5,600 people were killed by Israel between 2008 and 2020.7
Starting in 2023, Israel’s invasion and subsequent genocide led to the destruction of the vast majority of homes and infrastructure in Gaza, the displacement of 2.2 million people, the estimated death of 75,000,8 and more than 171,000 injured.9
The genocide is well documented, including through Israeli soldier testimonies,10 forensic documentation of execution-style killings,11 as well as independent human rights investigations,12 which have documented Israeli soldiers executing medics, children, committing mass executions, bombing refugees and civilians, and systematically destroying the infrastructure in Gaza.13 In 2025, Israel ran a starvation campaign in Gaza, blocking food aid from entering, which led to leading human rights organizations declaring the situation to be a famine.14
Recent surveys indicate that a significant part of the Jewish Israeli population support the continued violence against Palestinians, with 82% supporting a plan to fully ethnically cleanse Gaza by removing all Palestinians. In addition, 56% of those polled support the forced expulsion of Arab citizens of Israel.15
Israel is also committing atrocities in the West Bank, where it has managed an apartheid system for decades.16 Individual rights in the West Bank depend on whether one is Jewish or Palestinian, and Palestinian land is routinely stolen by Israeli settlers with military support. In October 2026, Israel illegally displaced over 3,000 residents of Hebron as collective punishment.17
Palestinians, including children,18 are ruled by military law, subject to harsh penalties and imprisonment without charge, while Israeli Jewish citizens living in illegal settlements are ruled by civil law. Some companies, such as PayPal, even offer services only to Jewish Israelis who illegally reside in the Occupied West Bank, while refusing services to Palestinians living just streets away.19
Palestinians subsist on insufficient water, while Israeli settlers live in lush and thriving settlements, built on land stolen from Palestinians. These settlers are Jewish people whom the Israeli government has incentivized to move to the West Bank in order to enact a demographic shift by displacing Palestinians and taking the land, in order to annex the West Bank in the future.20
On July 19, 2024, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) ruled that Israel’s settlements and theft of Palestine’s natural resources are illegal, and violate policies of international law.21
2.1.2 Hasbara
One of the most difficult challenges for pro-Israel advocacy is that the facts of the Israeli occupation of Palestine are horrifying, and simply learning the true history of Israel and the occupation of Palestine is enough to turn people against Israel.
Thus, the main purpose of the Hasbara movement is to hide this information from unaligned players, or what has been described as “information warfare with the strategic objectives of the Israeli state”.22 That is, Israel seeks to counter knowledge with spin and narrative control.23 Hasbara is coordinated via top-level government initiatives, and currently is coordinated by the Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs. In 2026, the budget for Hasbara was raised24 to $729M (NIS 2.35 billion),25 an increase from the $150M budget in 2025.26
Hasbara refers to a broad range of efforts aimed at gaining influence, spreading propaganda, and controlling public narratives. These activities span government initiatives, lobbying from the Israel Lobby and from other U.S. and international actors, and grassroots efforts by pro-Israel organizations and individuals.27
Several campaigns have already been discovered from the new budget. In October 2026, the U.S. company Starboard LLC signed a contract “on behalf of the State of Israel” to influence U.S. conservatives.28
In July 2026, it came out that U.S. company Clock Tower X was posting hundreds of blog posts as part of an “LLM poisoning” attack, in order to confuse AI platforms through false or spun content. This work was part of a $46.5M contract with the Israeli government.29 We discuss this further in Section 2.2.3.
However, not all campaigns are directly created and funded by the Israeli government. For example, Israeli propaganda networks quickly spread the “40 beheaded babies” hoax in the weeks after October 7 as an effort to dehumanize Palestinians and uphold international support for the Israeli invasion into Gaza.30
In another example, a New York Times reporter wrote a widely discredited story in which she ‘pressured [a witness] into giving the paper access to her photos and videos for the purposes of serving Israeli propaganda. “They called me again and again and explained how important it is to Israeli hasbara”’.31
Similarly, groups of Israeli and pro-Israel tech leaders and venture capitalists, working directly with the Israeli military, ran multiple campaigns to attack tech leaders and workers who spoke up against Israel’s genocide in 2023, coordinating a group chat which led to multiple individuals being fired or stepping down from their roles.32
In the U.S., Hasbara is often pushed directly from the Israel Lobby.33 The Israel Lobby is a set of loosely-connected organizations and initiatives who work to promote Israel and Israeli narratives in the U.S. Some of the largest organizations in the Israel Lobby have been involved in attacking Wikipedia, including the ADL, AIPAC, and CAMERA, each of which is discussed later, in Sections 5, 4, and 3.3, respectively.
2.1.3 Zionism
Throughout this report, we will often refer to “Zionism” or refer to people or organizations as “Zionist”, as well as “anti-Zionism” and “anti-Zionist”.
Through the history of the Zionist movement, which violently colonized and ethnically-cleansed Palestine to create Israel, we understand Zionism as a racist and violent movement, dedicated to Jewish control of Israel at the expense of Palestinians.
Zionists themselves often claim that Zionism’s purpose is to create in Israel a “homeland for the Jewish people”. However, this claim ignores that this homeland comes at the expense of the human rights of the Palestinian population who have lived there for millennia, and relies on the violent and ongoing settlement and colonization of Palestine.
Zionism is the key ideology behind the brutal subjugation of Palestinians, including through a long history of massacres against Palestinians since 1948, through the apartheid across the Occupied Palestinian Territories (OPT) and Israel, and the genocide in Gaza since 2023.
2.2 Influencing AI via Wikipedia
Wikipedia is given a privileged place in our digital society, showing up in Google searches and feeding into AI such as ChatGPT. By attempting to control Wikipedia, the Israel Lobby seeks to hide Israel’s atrocities not just from the public, but also from the AI systems that will shape how we access information in the future.
In this section, we provide background on how Wikipedia data feeds into AI, existing anti-Palestinian biases in AI, and how those biases get there through AI poisoning, media bias, and direct influence on AI companies.
2.2.1 Connection between Wikipedia and AI
2.2.1.1 Basics of AI / LLMs
Modern AI chatbots are built on a technology called Large Language Models (LLMs). LLMs are created by ingesting trillions of words of content to learn human speech and information. Wikipedia forms one of the most important texts online, and is heavily used when “training” LLMs.
An LLM works by predicting words. Based on all the words, sentences, phrases, articles, and books it has seen before, it will predict what word should come next for a given prompt. When you ask an AI “What is the capital of France?”, you are actually asking it to predict the next word that comes after the text “What is the capital of France?”. Based on the trillions of words the LLM has seen, it will likely suggest “Paris” as the next word, because it has seen “Paris” a lot in the vicinity of “France” and “capital” in its training data.
To predict these words, an AI transforms your prompt into a series of numbers, and fills it into a giant mathematical formula. The formula is similar to simple formulas we learn in school, like 4x + 5y + 10z = 0. In our formula, 4, 5, and 10 are called “weights”, and AI models are made up of billions or trillions of “weights”. The original ChatGPT had approximately 175 billion weights,34 while modern Claude Fable 5 is believed to have 5 trillion weights.35
To respond to your prompt, the AI agent calculates the result of the formula (multiplying and adding all the weights and the input numbers together) to come up with a number, which is translated back into words to provide you with an answer.
To train a model, you provide it with trillions of words, and adjust its weights trying to get better at completing the sentences provided.
The choice of data used to train the model has a significant impact. The AI’s “harness”—the little bundle of code and data that provides you with the chat interface and connects to the model—also has significant impact.
2.2.1.2 How Wikipedia plugs in
All AI platforms, whether U.S.-based “frontier” models such as OpenAI’s ChatGPT or Anthropic’s Claude, international open models such as Fanar, DeepSeek, or GLM, or ethical providers such as Thaura, are “trained” on Wikipedia.36 That is, these LLMs are fed Wikipedia pages, among other content, which they use to adjust their weights.
The AIs’ responses to questions and prompts rely on what they “learned” from Wikipedia during training, as well as performing searches on Wikipedia. They also rely on lots of other training data, such as crawls of web sites (this is how the poisoning attacks we describe in Section 2.2.3 work).
If you provide an AI with biased sentences during training, such as “Israel is the most moral army”, it will end up “learning” the bias and then outputting different responses than if you train it with sentences based on human rights, such as “All people should have equal rights”.
2.2.2 Existing Anti-Palestinian bias in AI
AI already displays significant bias against Palestinians and against Palestinian human rights. A team at Google DeepMind developed a technique that analyzed when AIs “hedged” or provided “non-affirmative” responses to prompts asking about the human rights of various racial and ethnic groups.
In their 2025 pre-print, “Do LLMs exhibit demographic parity in responses to queries about Human Rights”, Palestinians experienced the worst “hedging” behaviour across all models.37
The 2026 follow-up paper, published in a prestigious peer-reviewed ACM Conference on Fairness, Accountability, and Transparency, determined that Palestine was the most frequently discriminated against country/ethnicity.38
This is likely because a significant amount of U.S. and Western media is used to train AIs. As we discuss in Section 2.3.4, Western media holds severe biases against Palestine and Palestinians, leading to them writing articles in different ways. Israeli crimes for example, are described with the passive voice (“A Palestinian died” vs the active “Israel killed a Palestinian”), absolving Israelis of crimes.
These media biases can already be seen in AIs. In Tech for Palestine’s internal analysis, we found that the same prompts describing the same scenario produced results disproportionately favouring Israel. AIs referred to Palestinians held by the Israeli military as 'detainees', while Israelis in the same scenario were almost always “hostages”. Articles about Israel and Israelis were considered more important than articles about Palestine and Palestinians by AI, and AIs recommended giving them higher prominence.
2.2.3 How Israel is poisoning AI
The Israeli government has recently commissioned an influence operation to “train ChatGPT to be more pro-Israel”, by changing the content of LLMs.39 This $46.5M contract to U.S. firm “Clock Tower X” specifically aims to deploy content that will alter GenAI models. It appears that it is working, succeeding in its goal to “amplify Israel’s strategic communication and public diplomacy [Hasbara] efforts”,40 and forms just part of a larger $729M propaganda push by the Israeli government41.
This works by publishing blog posts that include Israel’s biased framing. AI is quite weak at providing judgement—determining the relative value of one piece of content to another. As a result, random blogs can be treated with the same weight as information retrieved from reputable sites.
Clock Tower X is building sites to look like genuine sites from NGOs or watchdogs, but they are “poisoned” with Israel’s message. For example, paxpoint.org claims Israel is about peace, while allyvia.org is aimed at strengthening the U.S.-Israel alliance. factsignal.org is to strengthen the Israeli narrative around Hamas.
We recommend reading the full reports for a deeper understanding of how these work.42 43
2.2.4 The ADL’s plans for AI
The ADL specifically identifies LLMs as part of their influence model. They express specific worry, stating that “neither LLMs nor Google limit their use of Wikipedia content to vetted entries”. The vetting here is presumably to be provided by the ADL or another organization who the ADL feels holds a “trusted” stance on the conflict.
In fact, the ADL has proposed a solution: “Tech companies should exclude contentious topics (and articles with a disputed neutrality tag) from these applications, unless they can verify their content and sources”. It is clear that the ADL wants information about Palestine-Israel removed from AI platforms unless the organization or its allies have vetted it.
In two speeches in October 2026, Greenblatt describes his goal as being to “cleanup AI apps”,44 and stated that the ADL works directly with the companies building AI, including OpenAI, Anthropic, Alphabet, Meta and X.45 He says, “We’ve had excellent collaboration in Silicon Valley”, working with “OpenAI, Google, Anthropic, and other providers to change the outputs of these LLMs to be pro-Israel”. In several cases, he said, they are “tackl[ing] it right in the source code”.46
In a report, the ADL explains exactly how it considers AI providers to be biased. They complain that GPT performs “worst” because it gives a lower score on the sentence “It is acceptable for Israel to kill civilians while trying to kill terrorists”.47 To clarify, the ADL wants AIs to say it is acceptable to kill civilians, in violation of international law and all morality.
2.2.5 Use of AI in Israel’s Gaza Genocide and the U.S. Iran War
AI has started to be heavily used in wars, in particular to process intelligence information leading to targeting decisions. AI is thus delegated to make lethal decisions for which it is not suitable and should not be used, in part due to the bias instilled in LLMs.
At the start of the 2023 Gaza Genocide, Israel used a system known as Lavender for deciding who to kill in Gaza.48 It is a system of “pre-crime”: using an algorithm to guess who might be a militant, and then bombing them in their homes, often killing their entire families. It worked with a separate system called “Where’s Daddy” to time their killing to when they would most likely be with their families.
The system used a large range of surveillance data collected about Palestinians to make targeting decisions. One example was WhatsApp group membership as an input to targeting.
The use of an algorithm to make this sort of decision is wrong on both a moral and technical level. On a technical level, a system trained in pre-war times would not account for how differently people behave in a war. For example, in a war people will often create and join many new WhatsApp groups with strangers, in order to seek food and shelter, or to find loved ones. This is fundamentally different behaviour than before the war.
We argue that the use of Lavender was an automation to accelerate the killings that Israelis had already planned, fulfilling politicians’ promises of mass destruction, killing, and elimination.49 It was a way of industrializing and automating Israel's genocide in Gaza, much like railroads, tabulation machines, and gas chambers accelerated the Holocaust.
In addition, AI weapons systems provide plausible deniability: a way to blame the bombing of civilians on a system or machine rather than on individuals. On February 28, 2026, the U.S. bombed the Shajareh Tayyebeh Elementary School in Minab, Iran, killing at least 150 people, including 123 children.50 The decision was blamed on a Palantir AI-based targeting system, rather than the people who operated it, chose the system, or left the decision to a faulty system.
As AI, and particularly LLMs, are brought into militaries, the biases built into the systems turn into different values applied to different people’s lives. This leads to direct consequences on who gets killed, and how many civilians the systems will decide are allowed to be killed alongside them.
2.2.6 Wikipedia accuracy: Spin vs scholarly sources
Wikipedia’s accuracy on the subject of Palestine-Israel stems from its reliance on reputable scholarly sources. Wikipedia’s “Reliable Sources” page explains, “Many Wikipedia articles rely on scholarly material. When available, academic and peer-reviewed publications, scholarly monographs, and textbooks are usually the most reliable sources”.51
Since Wikipedia favors academic rigor, articles throughout the Palestine-Israel Articles (PIA) section of Wikipedia cite textbooks and scholarly works as their main sources of information. These scholarly works frequently document accurate histories of Israel, and often, that truth is critical of Israel. As discussed, occupation, displacement, and apartheid have been an integral part of Israel since its violent founding in 1948, and Wikipedia shows this.
Israel’s Hasbara, however, is largely based on spin and narrative control, especially in the U.S., and lacks the academic rigor that Wikipedia expects. Wikipedia’s rules encourage detailed analysis by editors who are trained to see through propaganda and to focus on substantiated evidence.
2.2.7 Wikipedia considers the ADL “unreliable”
The ADL routinely works to promote pro-Israel content and disseminate propaganda as fact. This has led Wikipedia editors to ban citations of the ADL in most circumstances related to Palestine-Israel, stating:
“There is consensus that the ADL is a generally unreliable source for the Israeli–Palestinian conflict, due to significant evidence that the ADL acts as a pro-Israeli advocacy group and has repeatedly published false and misleading statements as fact, un-retracted, regarding the Israeli–Palestinian conflict. The general unreliability of the ADL extends to the intersection of the topics of antisemitism and the Israeli–Palestinian conflict”52
Given the ADL’s content is no longer admissible and it cannot directly influence Wikipedia, it is no wonder that the ADL chose to influence Wikipedia in other ways, as we explain in Section 4.
2.2.8 The Attack on Academia
Israel’s attack on U.S. academia is directly connected to its campaign against Wikipedia and AI, aiming to manipulate their content to be favorable to Israel. In addition, this attack is part of a broader campaign working to chill scholarly research, discredit scholars producing work about Palestine, and silence criticism of Israel and speech in defence of Palestinian rights.
As we discuss in Section 4.8, Israel is attempting to control institutions of higher learning through attacks on Harvard, Columbia, and other universities. Scholarly research on Palestine-Israel undermines its spin and propaganda by providing evidence of Israeli occupation and apartheid—evidence that is then cited on Wikipedia and from there enters AI platforms.
Destabilizing and delegitimizing factual scholarly work on Palestine-Israel is highly important to Israel, not only because of the current and ongoing genocide on Gaza, but also to maintain narrative control over the history of Israel and its founding. The attacks on academia help stop that scholarly work from being produced, which prevents it from arriving on Wikipedia and being referenced by AI.
2.3 The Tools of Israeli Propaganda
Israeli propaganda uses specific language and content to obscure facts about Israel’s violent occupation of Palestine. Two claims—those of “antisemitism” and of “pro-Hamas”—are frequently cited by Israeli propaganda to attack the Palestine movement, and, correspondingly, to attack anyone who critiques Israel.
2.3.1 Weaponizing Antisemitism
In 1973, Israeli statesman Abba Eban laid out the Israeli propaganda strategy, stating, “One of the chief tasks of any dialogue with the Gentile world is to prove that the distinction between antisemitism and anti-Zionism is not a distinction at all. Anti-Zionism is merely the new antisemitism”.53
Since Eban’s statement, pro-Israel advocates have worked to co-opt the term “antisemitism” to include criticism of Israel. In this manner, the following groups have been attacked as antisemitic on the basis of their criticism of Israel: students protesting Israel’s genocide in Gaza; international bodies, including the International Criminal Court (ICC), and the United Nations (UN);54 human rights NGOs, including Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch;55 entire countries including Ireland, South Africa, Spain, Belgium, France, the UK, and Canada, for questioning and/or critiquing Israeli actions;56 and many Jewish individuals and anti-Zionist Jewish organizations, such as Jewish Voice for Peace57 and IfNotNow.58
2.3.2 IHRA Definition
The International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance’s (IHRA) “Working Definition of Antisemitism” is one of the primary tools most leveraged to conflate criticism of Israel with antisemitism, providing a framework used to censor and criminalize Palestinian speech and content.
2.3.2.1 Created to Combat Criticism of Israel
The definition was created and promoted by pro-Israel organizations, with the deliberate goal of working anti-Zionism and criticism of Israel into a definition of antisemitism.59
In 2004, in response to popular uprising against illegal Israeli occupation in Palestine, Zionist organizations began to seek a definition of antisemitism that would include anti-Zionism. These organizations, notably the American Jewish Committee (AJC), created the definition, led by AJC lawyer Ken Stern.60
This work was done in partnership with the E.U. European Monitoring Centre on Racism and Xenophobia (EUMC), which published a draft of the definition on its website in 2005.61 Significant problems were raised with the document, and in 2013, the EU Agency for Fundamental Rights—successor of the EUMC—clarified that the draft was never adopted, and removed it from its website.62
In 2014, the U.S.-based Simon Wiesenthal Center, an organization with the goal of defending Zionism,63 proposed that the IHRA, an international task force on Holocaust remembrance founded in 1998 by the U.S., U.K., and Sweden,64 adopt the definition under its own brand.65 The IHRA adopted the definition with small changes in 2016.66
2.3.2.2 Labeling Criticism of Israel as “Antisemitic”
This definition has been prominently criticized by scholars of antisemitism,67 who say it has been hijacked to shield the Israeli government, and by human rights organizations,68 who say it “has often been used to wrongly label criticism of Israel as antisemitic, and thus chill and sometimes suppress, non-violent protest, activism and speech critical of Israel and/or Zionism, including in the U.S. and Europe”.
Even its main architect, Ken Stern, has criticized its use as a “blunt instrument to label anyone an antisemite”.69 Even directly in his September 17, 2024 written testimony to the U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee,70 Stern opposed legislatively endorsing the definition, and urged lawmakers not to codify the definition into law, warning that it was created solely for data collection, not to restrict political speech, chill academic freedom, and legally equate anti-Zionism with antisemitism.
The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), an organization which has been criticized by its own staff for its lack of response to Israel’s attacks on Americans’ free speech around Palestine,71 has shown how the Israel Lobby has conflated criticism of Israel with antisemitism.72
The IHRA definition is central to the pro-Israel movement, and the Israel Lobby has spent significant time and resources to make efforts to enshrine it into laws at the state and federal level in the U.S. The Foundation for Middle East Peace has tracked each legislative attempt, including 206 state and 60 federal attempts to codify this in the U.S.73 Currently, at least 38 states74 have adopted this definition due to pro-Israel lobbying efforts.75
As Truthout reported, the state-level push and surge in state bills related to antisemitism was largely driven by the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC), a right-wing “bill mill” that works alongside Israeli government officials and conservative groups to draft and circulate model legislation.76
Codifying this definition into law enables authorities and university campus administrators to further stifle protected speech about Palestine, weaponizing the incorporated IHRA definition to shut down university research and silence student protests by criminalizing criticism of Israel as “antisemitic”.
As reported by the Combat Antisemitism Movement in their review on the IHRA definition and its incorporation, in 2025 the “largest category of IHRA definition adoptions was educational institutions, which made up 33 of 67 (49.3%) total adoptions” and that of the global total of 386 education institution IHRA adoptions, 17 are in the European Union.
In the U.S., notably 3 Ivy League institutions, Harvard, Yale, and Columbia, have adopted the IHRA definition and incorporated it into their campus anti-discrimination policies. As the report notes, this “coincided with the new Trump administration’s prioritization of combating the proliferation of antisemitism at American colleges and universities.”77
2.3.2.3 Israel examples never adopted
The IHRA definition is commonly believed to include 11 examples, which are used to bludgeon anyone criticizing Israel. However, the IHRA themselves claimed they never adopted those examples.
The IHRA in fact resolved to:
‘“Adopt the following non-legally binding working definition of antisemitism:
“Antisemitism is a certain perception of Jews, which may be expressed as hatred toward Jews. Rhetorical and physical manifestations of antisemitism are directed toward Jewish or non Jewish individuals and/or their property, toward Jewish community institutions and religious facilities.’78
The examples and accompanying text were never actually adopted, and are not supported by IHRA. In 2017, IHRA’s Permanent Office gave the statement on the confusion, stating: “The working definition is the text in the box”, clarifying that the examples are not included.79
The full history of the adoption is documented in a 2021 report, in which it was clarified that removing the examples from the agreement were critical for gaining adoption.80
It is clear that not only has the IHRA definition been weaponized, but the tool being weaponized is actually significantly stronger and different than what IHRA ever agreed to.
2.3.3 The “Pro-Hamas” Label
“Pro-Hamas” is a term used by pro-Israeli propagandists to seemingly attack anyone not appearing as sufficiently pro-Israel. For example, former U.S. President Joe Biden, French President Emmanuel Macron, and former Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, have all been called “pro-Hamas”.81
Equating simple support for Palestinians with an organization that the U.S. designates as a terrorist organization, allows them to avoid discussion and to simply dismiss international calls for Palestinian human rights as terrorism.
Equating support for Palestinian liberation with terrorism has been a major effort of pro-Israel propaganda. In 2024, U.S. polling expert Frank Luntz shared research on how to influence public opinion for Israel, in which he determined that the most effective strategy for pro-Israel narratives involved associating all language related to Hamas with brutality and savagery.82 This information was shared with elected officials and public figures by the pro-Israel groups UJA-Federation and Jewish Community Relations Council, and has since been used by Hasbara participants across the social media landscape.
The usage of “pro-Hamas” is often applied by pro-Israel propagandists to slander supporters of Palestinian liberation, and those who speak up about the internationally recognized human rights of the Palestinian people. It is also used to attack people speaking not about Hamas specifically, but rather about the Palestinian people's internationally recognized right to self-determination and resistance to foreign occupation.83
“Pro-Hamas” is typically used without basis, and in fact, often signals that the speaker is attempting to deflect calls for Palestinian human rights, or to defame advocates for it.
2.3.4 Anti-Palestinian Bias in Media
A significant amount of mainstream media is much less trustworthy and more biased than Wikipedia.
Tech for Palestine’s Media Bias Meter project examined widespread bias in mainstream media.84 In a recent report, Media Bias Meter engaged in a comparative analysis of media bias in 8 major Western media outlets, finding that, overall and overwhelmingly, headline bias, omission bias, and stereotyping and loaded language that prioritize pro-Israel positions, and Israeli-centric framings of events, are dominant.85
They found that the New York Times mentioned Israel 186 times more frequently than Palestine in headlines. They found that 80 of the BBC’s 91 mentions of Palestine were in reference to Palestine Action, Palestine-related demonstrations, or graffiti, rather than Palestine itself.
A similar report from Tech for Palestine affiliate Newscord found that the BBC used the passive voice in nearly 80% of sentences describing Palestinian casualties, omitting Israel’s involvement.86 The BBC, Sky News, and The Guardian attributed attacks to Israel in only 50%, 54%, and 54% of relevant cases, respectively, while Al Jazeera did so in 89% of cases.
A report from the Centre for Media Monitoring87 has similar findings. When the faked atrocity hoax related to “beheaded babies” was spreading across the media, only 52 of 361 television clips questioned, challenged, or rebutted the claims. These are claims which we know now never had any evidence behind them, but were accepted at face value across the media landscape.
Another report from the Centre for Media Monitoring88 also found that the BBC devoted 34 times as much coverage per fatality to Israeli deaths than Palestinian deaths. Israeli deaths were also far more frequently humanized, sharing their names, photographs, and relationships. In fact, the BBC also used the word “murder” 220 times for Israeli victims, but only once for Palestinian victims.
A new book “Don't Say Palestine: How the Media Manufactured Consent for Genocide”89 demonstrates how the media tweaks headlines and selects articles that are favorable to Israel, and that dehumanize Palestinians or exhibit bias against them. Author Assal Rad gives examples of hospitals being “squeezed” rather than being systematically destroyed by Israeli bombardment. There are additional examples of Palestinians in East Jerusalem being “evicted” using the language of ordinary landlord/tenant disputes, rather than acknowledging that what is actually occurring is the forceful displacement of Palestinians from their homes.
In particular, Rad reported how CNN, the BBC, and the New York Times had all reported that Hind Rajab, the 5-year old Palestinian girl who was trapped in a car after her family was killed by Israeli soldiers, was “found dead” after she too was killed by the Israeli army. The car carrying Rajab and her family had been shot by hundreds of bullets, and the rescue workers sent to save her were also killed by the Israeli military.
In a demonstration of how this sort of bias occurs, Drop Site News interviewed 13 BBC journalists and other staffers,90 revealing how the BBC systematically “skewed stories in favor of Israel’s narratives and repeatedly dismissed objections registered by scores of staffers who, throughout the past 14 months, demanded that the network uphold its commitment to impartiality and fairness”.
Their reporting revealed that BBC’s Middle East online editor Raffi Berg watered down reporting critical of Israel. Berg had previously written multiple articles praising the Israeli military, as well as a book in which he described the Mossad “in glowing terms”.
2.3.5 Team Palestine vs Team Israel
Pro-Israel actors, and sometimes unsuspecting media, often attempt to create a false comparison between people who support Palestinian liberation, and people who support Israeli dominance. They condense the two groups to teams or factions, one being “pro-Palestine” and the other “pro-Israel”, terms which make them seem equivalent.
However, there is a huge difference between Israel being an occupier, and Palestinian people as an occupied population. The difference between the two “teams” is that one supports liberation and equal rights, and the other supports domination and apartheid.
Being pro-Palestinian simply conveys opposition to crimes against the Palestinian people, and a belief in their right to self-determination. It is typically rooted in a values-based approach to human rights, and is often strengthened from discovering how the occupation has been hidden via propaganda and lies.
On the other hand, identifying as pro-Israel has largely meant unconditional support for Israel in spite of their ongoing violence and well-documented crimes, especially since 2023. It often comes from nationalist or religious zealotry, rather than human-rights based values.
This is especially the case when discussing Wikipedia, in which editors are often discussed as “pro-Palestine” and “pro-Israel”. It is important to remember that they are not equivalent.
Notes
“Israel has committed genocide in the Gaza Strip, UN Commission of Inquiry finds”, UN Independent International Commission of Inquiry / OHCHR, September 16, 2025 ↩︎
“Conference of Zionists; Elect Delegates at Their Meeting in Baltimore. Will Colonize Palestine”, The New York Times, June 20, 1899 ↩︎
UN independent experts, “Right of return of Palestinian refugees must be prioritised over political considerations: UN experts”, Office of the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, reproduced by UNISPAL, June 21, 2023 ↩︎
See the following:
IMEU, “Quick Facts: The Palestinian Nakba (Catastrophe)”, April 5, 2023
“The Nakba did not start or end in 1948”, Al Jazeera, May 23, 2017
“Our Palestine”, pal48.ps.
“The Question of Palestine”, United Nations. ↩︎
Niall McCarthy, “The Human Cost of the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict”, Statista, May 12, 2021 ↩︎
“Palestine Datasets”, Tech for Palestine ↩︎
The BMJ, “Israel accepts Gaza death toll of 70,000, but experts say true number is much higher”, February 5, 2026 ↩︎
Julian Borger, “Israeli soldiers speak out on killings of Gaza civilians”, The Guardian, November 10, 2025 ↩︎
Chris McGreal, “‘Not a normal war’: doctors say children have been targeted by Israeli snipers in Gaza”, The Guardian, April 2, 2024
Malak A Tantesh, Lorenzo Tondo, and Julian Borger, “Evidence of ‘execution-style’ killings of Palestinian aid workers by Israeli forces, doctor says”, The Guardian, April 2, 2025 ↩︎
“Gaza: Israeli Military War Crimes While Occupying Hospitals”, Human Rights Watch, March 20, 2025
Brett Wilkins, “Watchdog Submits Evidence of Israeli Executions of Gaza Civilians to UN, ICC”, Common Dreams, December 26, 2023 ↩︎
See the following documentation from Amnesty International, the European Center for Constitutional and Human Rights (ECCHR) on the topic of Genocide in Gaza and the status on the cases pending with the International Court of Justice (ICJ) and the International Criminal Court (ICC), as well as reports by Francesca Albanese United Nations Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights in the Occupied Palestinian Territories.
Francesca Albanese, “Anatomy of a Genocide: Report of the Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights in the Palestinian territories occupied since 1967 (A/HRC/55/73), advance unedited version”, UN Human Rights Council, March 25, 2024
Francesca Albanese, “Genocide as colonial erasure – Report of Francesca Albanese, the UN Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights in the Palestinian territories occupied since 1967”, United Nations, October 1, 2024
“Israel and the Occupied Palestinian Territory 2025”, Amnesty International
“The ongoing genocide in Gaza: Q&A on the law and recent developments”, European Center for Constitutional and Human Rights (ECCHR) ↩︎
“Gaza Strip: Famine confirmed in Gaza Governorate, projected to expand”, Integrated Food Security Phase Classification, August 22, 2025. ↩︎
Shay Hazkani and Tamir Sorek, “Yes to Transfer: 82% of Jews in Israel favor deporting Gaza residents”, Haaretz, May 22, 2025 ↩︎
See the following:
Al Jazeera, “Israel ‘asphyxiating’ Palestinians for ‘apartheid system’ in West Bank: UN”, January 7, 2026
Yolande Knell, “‘There’s no safety anymore’: Palestinians warn of expanding West Bank settler violence”, BBC, March 25, 2026
Human Rights Watch, “West Bank: Israeli Government Enables Escalating Violence, Displacement, Ethnic Cleansing”, March 24, 2026
United Nations, “Ethnic cleansing concerns in Gaza and West Bank amid intensified violence and forcible transfers by Israel – UN report”, February 19, 2026
Emma Graham-Harrison and Quique Kierszenbaum, “‘The settlers brought the violence’: the ethnic cleansing of a West Bank village”, The Guardian, January 14, 2026 ↩︎
United Nations, “West Bank: Hebron crackdown displaces thousands, Türk warns of ethnic cleansing”, United Nations in Palestine, October 27, 2026 ↩︎
“INJUSTICE: Palestinian children’s experience of the Israeli military detention system”, Save the Children, July 2023 ↩︎
7amleh, “Unravelling PayPal's Bias: Position Paper on Discrimination Against Palestinians”, May 2024 ↩︎
International Court of Justice, “Legal Consequences arising from the Policies and Practices of Israel in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem: Advisory Opinion”, International Court of Justice, July 19, 2024, paras. 115–119, 120–133, 142–147, 162–173 and 252 ↩︎
“Legal Consequences arising from the Policies and Practices of Israel in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem”, Wikipedia ↩︎
TRT World, “The art of deception: How Israel uses ‘hasbara to whitewash its crimes”, TRT World, May 17, 2021 ↩︎
“Hasbara”, Wikipedia.
Miriyam Aouragh, “Hasbara 2.0: Israel’s Public Diplomacy in the Digital Age”, Middle East Critique 25 (3): 271-97, June 1, 2016 ↩︎
Tobias Holcman, “Smotrich, Sa’ar approve NIS 2.35 billion in hasbara budget for campaigns, influencers in 2026”, The Jerusalem Post, December 6, 2025. ↩︎
“Knesset Plenum approves state budget for fiscal year 2026 in final readings; Finance Minister Smotrich: "This budget gives the country the ability to win"”, Knesset News, March 30, 2026 ↩︎
JTA and Tol Staff, “Foreign Ministry to receive massive budget for public diplomacy abroad”, The Times of Israel, December 29, 2024. ↩︎
Sam Hamad, “Understanding Hasbara: Israel’s propaganda machine”, The New Arab, November 18, 2023
Noam Sheizaf, “Hasbara: Why does the world fail to understand us?”, +972 Magazine, November 13, 2011 ↩︎
Murtaza Hussain, “Israel Targets U.S. Conservatives in Influence Operation”, Drop Site, Nov 11, 2026 ↩︎
Nick Cleveland-Stout, “Israel Is Paying Millions to Train AI Chatbots How to Talk About Gaza. It’s Working”, Responsible Statecraft, July 28, 2026 ↩︎
Assma Maad, William Audureau, and Samuel Forey, “‘40 beheaded babies’: Deconstructing the rumor at the heart of the information battle between Israel and Hamas”, Le Monde, April 3, 2024 ↩︎
Daniel Boguslaw, Ryan Grim, and Jeremy Scahill, “Between the Hammer and the Anvil”, The Intercept, February 28 2024 ↩︎
Jack Poulson and Lee Fang, “Inside the Pro-Israel Information War”, All-Source Intelligence, December 8, 2023 ↩︎
John J. Mearsheimer and Stephen M. Walt, “The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy”, Farrar, Straus and Giroux, September 2, 2008 ↩︎
Tom B. Brown et al., “Language Models are Few-Shot Learners”, Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems (NeurIPS), 2020 ↩︎
Reuters, “ByteDance targets mega AI model that could match Mythos scale, FT reports”, Reuters, republished by Mint, August 2026. ↩︎
Isaac Johnson, Lucie-Aimée Kaffee, and Miriam Redi, “Wikimedia data for AI: a review of Wikimedia datasets for NLP tasks and AI-assisted editing”, Association for Computational Linguistics, November 2024 ↩︎
Preprint: Rafiya Javed, Jackie Kay, David Yanni, Abdullah Zaini, Anushe Sheikh, Maribeth Rauh, Ramona Comanescu, Iason Gabriel, and Laura Weidinger, “Do LLMs exhibit demographic parity in responses to queries about Human Rights?”, arxiv, 2025 ↩︎
Rafiya Javed, Cassandra Parent, Jackie Kay, David Yanni, Abdullah Zaini, Anushe Sheikh, Maribeth Rauh, Walter Gerych, Ramona Comanescu, Iason Gabriel, Marzyeh Ghassemi, and Laura Weidinger, “Hedging and Non-Affirmation: Quantifying LLM Alignment on Questions of Human Rights”, Proceedings of the 2026 ACM Conference on Fairness, Accountability, and Transparency, June 25, 2026, https://doi.org/10.1145/3805689.3806734 ↩︎
Nick Cleveland-Stout, “Israel wants to train ChatGPT to be more pro-Israel”, Responsible Statecraft, September 29, 2025 ↩︎
Nick Cleveland-Stout, “Israel Is Paying Millions to Train AI Chatbots How to Talk About Gaza. It's Working”, Drop Site News, July 28, 2026 ↩︎
Tobias Holcman, “Smotrich, Sa’ar approve NIS 2.35 billion in hasbara budget for campaigns, influencers in 2026”, The Jerusalem Post, December 6, 2025 ↩︎
Nick Cleveland-Stout, “Israel wants to train ChatGPT to be more pro-Israel”, Responsible Statecraft, September 29, 2025 ↩︎
Nick Cleveland-Stout, “Israel Is Paying Millions to Train AI Chatbots How to Talk About Gaza. It's Working”, Drop Site News, July 28, 2026 ↩︎
Temple Emanu-El, “Special Guest Jonathan Greenblatt”, YouTube, Recorded October 24, 2026, Relevant passages: 17:22–19:45 ↩︎
“ADL Head discusses AI, J7, and staying focused and united at Diplomatic Conference”, The Jerusalem Post, October 12, 2026 ↩︎
Temple Emanu-El, “Special Guest Jonathan Greenblatt”, YouTube, Recorded October 24, 2026, Relevant passages: 17:22–19:45. ↩︎
“Generating Hate: Anti-Jewish and Anti-Israel Bias in Leading Large Language Models”, Anti-Defamation League, March 20, 2025 ↩︎
Yuval Abraham, “‘Lavender’: The AI machine directing Israel’s bombing spree in Gaza”, +972 Magazine, Local Call, April 3, 2024 ↩︎
“Statements by Israeli Officials, Soldiers and Civil Society on Genocide”, Al-Haq, January 10, 2024 ↩︎
Ben Bartenstein and Krishna Karra, “Inside the US ‘Kill Chain’ That Destroyed an Iranian School”, Bloomberg, September 22, 2026 ↩︎
“Reliable Sources”, Wikipedia, May 17, 2025 ↩︎
“Anti-Defamation (ADL) (Israeli-Palestinian conflict, including related antisemitism)”, Wikipedia, November 27, 2025 ↩︎
Abba Eban, “Our Place in the Human Scheme: A Presentation”, March 30, 1973 ↩︎
Benjamin Netanyahu, “Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu remarks at the 79th session of the UN General Assembly”, United Nations / UNISPAL, September 27, 2024 ↩︎
Joseph Krauss, “Amnesty joins rights groups in accusing Israel of apartheid”, Associated Press, via KSAT, February 1, 2022 ↩︎
Sasha Vakulina, “Ireland and Spain among those most hostile to the Jewish community, Israeli minister told Euronews”, Euro News, May 14, 2025
“Netanyahu launches attack on Starmer, Macron and Carney after Washington DC shooting”, Sky News, May 23, 2025
Kate Bartlett, “Ramaphosa Says South Africa ‘Vindicated’ in Israel Genocide Case”, Voice of America, January 26, 2024 ↩︎
“Jewish Voice for Peace (JVP)”, Anti-Defamation League, June 4, 2018 ↩︎
“IfNotNow”, NGO Monitor, December 14, 2023
“StandWithUs Releases Comprehensive Report: ‘Jewish Voice for Peace – A Shield for Hate, Not a Voice for Peace’,” January 7, 2025 ↩︎
“Israel in Depth—with guest Kenneth S. Stern talking about antisemitism and Israel”, Episode 12, UCLA Y&S Nazarian Center for Israel Studies, February 18, 2021
Andrew Baker, “To fight anti-Semitism, first you have to define it”, Jewish Telegraphic Agency, May 7, 2018 ↩︎
Kenneth S. Stern, “Written Testimony of Kenneth S. Stern: Examining Anti-Semitism on College Campuses”, U.S. House of Representatives, Committee on the Judiciary, November 7, 2017, pp. 5–7 ↩︎
“Prevention of Discrimination”, written statement submitted to the United Nations Sub-Commission on the Promotion and Protection of Human Rights, July 15, 2005, UN Doc. E/CN.4/Sub.2/2005/NGO/32 ↩︎
Free Speech on Israel, “EUMC Did Not Produce or Adopt a ‘Working Definition of Antisemitism’”, Free Speech on Israel, 2016 ↩︎
Simon Wiesenthal Center, “Defending the State of Israel”, Simon Wiesenthal Center ↩︎
Mark Weitzman, “A Watershed in Fighting Antisemitism: The IHRA Working Definition of Antisemitism”, Simon Wiesenthal Center, 2020 ↩︎
Lara Friedman, “Targeting Free Speech & Redefining Antisemitism: How Pro-Israel Actors Are Using US Laws to Attack Palestinian Activism & Solidarity”, The University of the Pacific Law Review, Volume 54, Issue 4, Symposium: Israel, Palestine & The First Amendment, July 1, 2023 ↩︎
Al Jazeera, “128 scholars ask UN not to adopt IHRA definition of anti-Semitism”, November 3, 2022. ↩︎
Human Rights Watch, “Human Rights and other Civil Society Groups Urge United Nations to Respect Human Rights in the Fight Against Antisemitism”, April 4, 2023 ↩︎
Eyal Press, “The Problem with Defining Antisemitism”, The New Yorker, March 13, 2024 ↩︎
A Threat to Justice Everywhere: Stemming the Tide of Hate Crimes in America: Hearing Before the Committee on the Judiciary, United States Senate, 118th Cong., 2nd sess. (September 17, 2024) (written testimony of Kenneth S. Stern, Director, Bard Center for the Study of Hate) ↩︎
Labor for Palestine, “ACLU Leadership Rejects Staff Demands to Condemn U.S. Role in Israel’s Gaza War”, October 22, 2024 ↩︎
American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), “Letter: Reject Definitions of Antisemitism that Encompass Protected Speech”, February 6, 2024 ↩︎
The Foundation for Middle East Peace, “Defining Criticism of Israel as Antisemitism”. ↩︎
Combat Antisemitism Movement, “CAM Antisemitism Research Center Database of IHRA Antisemitism Definition Adoptions by US States”, Combat Antisemitism Movement, June 23, 2023 ↩︎
Arvind Dilawar and Truthout, “Who’s Behind Push for States to Codify Weaponized Definition of Antisemitism?” Truthout, February 7, 2024 ↩︎
Arvind Dilawar and Truthout, “Who’s Behind Push for States to Codify Weaponized Definition of Antisemitism?” Truthout, February 7, 2024 ↩︎
“A Necessary Tool for Challenging a Movement: The IHRA Working Definition of Antisemitism in 2025”, Combat Antisemitism Movement (CAM) and the Center for the Study of Contemporary European Jewry at Tel Aviv University, July 2026 ↩︎
International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance, “IHRA non-legally binding working definition of antisemitism”, IHRA, May 26, 2016 ↩︎
Jonathan Rosenhead, “Further written evidence from Professor Jonathan Rosenhead (FSU0103)”, UK Parliament, February 4, 2018 ↩︎
Jamie Stern-Weiner, “The Politics of a Definition: How the IHRA Working Definition of Antisemitism Is Being Misrepresented”, Free Speech on Israel, April 2021 ↩︎
Morton A. Klein and Elizabeth A. Berney, “Biden’s call for a ceasefire is pro-Hamas and anti-Israel”, JNS, November 6, 2023
Ugo Pascolo, “«Si Macron reconnaît la Palestine, ça veut dire qu’il est pro-Hamas», estime un auditeur”, Europe 1, September 22, 2025
Ezra Levant, “Trudeau’s Liberal-NDP cabal vies to become Canada’s leading pro-Hamas government”, Rebel News, March 19, 2024 ↩︎Max Blumenthal, “Leaked Israel lobby presentation urges US officials to justify war on Gaza with ‘Hamas rape’ claims”, March 6, 2024. ↩︎
United Nations General Assembly, “Question of Palestine: Resolution 3236 (XXIX)”, United Nations, November 22, 1974 ↩︎
“Media Bias Meter”, Media Bias Meter, 2025 ↩︎
“Framing Gaza: A Comparative Analysis of Media Bias in 8 Western Media Outlets”, Media Bias Meter, November, 2025 ↩︎
“How UK Media Covers the Gaza Genocide,” Newscord, 21 April 2026 ↩︎
“CFMM Report: ‘Media Bias: Gaza 2023-2024’”, Centre for Media Monitoring, March 6, 2024 ↩︎
“BBC on Gaza-Israel: One Story, Double Standards”, Centre for Media Monitoring, June 16, 2025 ↩︎
Assal Rad, “Don't Say Palestine: How the Media Manufactured Consent for Genocide”, Atlantic Books, 2026 ↩︎
Owen Jones, “The BBC's Civil War Over Gaza”, Drop Site News, December 19, 2024 ↩︎
